In 2 decades I have never seen anyone have more / better or even equal success with Alpha yohimbine vs HCL for going from lean to ultra lean / shredded. Perhaps less sides / or reaction to the Alpha-Y sure, but never equal or better mobilization of fatty acids from stubborn areas when appropriately used in a completely fasted state and already considerably lean / shredded. Crucify me if you will, it is just what I have observed.
I think that you are looking at this differently than most of the people posting about it in the ongoing discussion.
As a company, we feel that both regular Yohimbine HCL and Alpha Yohimbine are great products; that's why we offer both:
SNS Alpha Yohimbine contains Rauwolscine, a potent type of plant alkaloid that has become very popular in many energy and weight loss products because of its potential energy and fat loss benefits. SNS Alpha Yohimbine provides you this all-star ingredient at a great price that allows for...
seriousnutritionsolutions.com
SNS Yohimbine 2.5 provides 2.5 mg. per capsule of Yohimbine HCl, a popular ingredient that is commonly used to help burn fat, suppress appetite, and enhance libido.
seriousnutritionsolutions.com
I don't think that its necessarily a matter of arguing over which one is better, I think its a matter of each individual person finding out which one is better for them personally.
For the person that can take both - try them and see which one works best for you as an individual, stack them, do whatever you'd like based on your own individual results and tolerance.
For the person that cannot take Yohimbine HCL, it's not an issue of whether its better or not better than Alpha Yohimbine; since they can't take regular Yohimbine HCL, that's completely irrelevant; as they're looking at it as they can take Alpha Yohimbine whereas they cannot/will not take Yohimbine HCL. I fall into this category myself - regular Yohimbine HCL makes me feel terrible and there is zero chance of me using it ever under any circumstance.
As far as you saying that in 2 decades that you haven't seen anyone have the results off Alpha Yohimbine that you have off Yohimbine HCL, real Alpha Yohimbine hasn't been available for a decade yet, no less 2 decades. I'm not saying that it is or isn't as good, but I am saying that there's no way to compare the two on that level bc it hasn't been around that long.
Also, an important point to note is that 99% of people that use Yohimbine HCL are using 2.5 to 5 mg. per day based on the way that companies are required to label the products; they aren't doing the extreme AM style dosing on it to begin with. So for average consumer, its a more fair comparison to compare 2.5 to 5 mg. of Yohimbine HCL to 1.5 to 3 mg. Alpha Yohimbine.
It's also important to note that to the average consumer, they enjoy the energy benefit from Alpha Yohimbine.
I hope all that makes sense.
For me personally, Yohimbine HCL makes me feel terrible, like I'm getting the flu, whereas our Alpha Yohimbine caps give me a great energy boost even at 1.5 mg.