Guest viewing limit reached
  • You have reached the maximum number of guest views allowed
  • Please register below to remove this limitation

Best tasting protein powder?

I really like PES and I have never tasted anything that has beat Xtreme Formulations Lemon Cream Pie or Cinn Roll
 
Pec.Major said:
I went with Select Protein CPBC. I am not a huge fan of cookies and cream so I did not want to spend money on something that I might not like. I like Select Protein, so CPBC will probably be amazing.
Click to expand...

Smart man! PBC is my long time favorite. CnC was my top dog for a long while as well and that's coming from someone not very fond of the flavor typically.
 
LiveToLift said:
Smart man! PBC is my long time favorite. CnC was my top dog for a long while as well and that's coming from someone not very fond of the flavor typically.
Click to expand...

What were you doing with CnC to enjoy it? I have some that I would like to use but I feel like I have to force it down
 
Just finished up a CnC recipe...
Invalid Link Removed
Invalid Link Removed
 
It will be up on Instagram (driven2lift) and in the baking with whey thread by tomorrow :)

Thanks guys
 
Woody said:
Nothing has made me want to try Select more than that....
Click to expand...

Please allow me to quote this as i plea for a promotion
(Jk lol)
But thank you brother,
Much appreciated.

The truffle itself was super easy, using up the last of my Vitafiber so this is a "Quest-style CnC Truffle"
 
Best tasting for myself was Lemon Creme Pie UP 2.0 or Vasolate Banana. Both of those are MRPs, so also SAN Chocolate Graham Crackee
 
PES Select flavors are definitely great.

I'm currently using (and can't get enough of ...) iForce's Protean Blueberry Muffin. This flavor is absolutely spot on!






-Spaz
 
So I got my Select Protein CPBC today. I have already drinken it 3 times today. :)
And I agree, not much chocolate taste, the peanut is dominating. I don´t mind it. But I still rank snickerdoodle the best. I have only tried milk chocolate, CNC and snickerdoodle.
 
Big_Spaz said:
PES Select flavors are definitely great.

I'm currently using (and can't get enough of ...) iForce's Protean Blueberry Muffin. This flavor is absolutely spot on!






-Spaz
Click to expand...

Agreed with all of this. I use BBM Protean in my morning oats and then use it at night in my cottage cheese. Tastes amazing either way
 
Okay here is the deal, I am tired of ON whey Double Rich Chocolate after 9 months or so on it. Unfortunately where I live we don't get all the brands and shipping costs an arm and a leg...but I stood all I can stand and I can stands no more!

So I have decided to buy two tubs (2 lbs each ) of any good protein - I am thinking

1) Beverly UMP - CnC
2) Iforce Blueberry Muffin

I wanted to do MTS but its not on the sites I usually buy from. So I believe the common consensus is this two? If you could have only 2 brands of protein what you do? Help a bah out....
 
PEScience Select would be in my top 2 ;)

But of those I vote UMP
 
Driven2lift said:
PEScience Select would be in my top 2 ;)

But of those I vote UMP
Click to expand...

I am willing to change my line up but I can afford only 2 tubs...since shipping costs approx. the price of 1 tub...I have heard good things about PES Select, Blue Star, Iforce and ofcourse Beverly (Not going for XF for now)....

So I need to get this right with no regrets. So which two would be GOAT?
 
AKM007 said:
I am willing to change my line up but I can afford only 2 tubs...since shipping costs approx. the price of 1 tub...

So I need to get this right and no regrets. I get only 2 choices but it should be GOAT!
Click to expand...

If you love CNC then yes the beverly is your choice
If you are a huge blueberry fan then that would be wise
Do you want peanut butter?? Metabolic Nutrition PB Cookie
Do you want cinnamon? XF 2.0 Cinnamon Roll, Snickerdoodle PES,
Do you want chocolate? XF 2.0 Triple Chocolate, Metabolic Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Covered banana Blue Star.
Other good choices for CnC Blue Star Milk & Cookies, Champion nutrition Cookies and Cream, Protogen CnC
Red velvet --> Iforce or MTS

Really comes down to what 2 flavors you value most. Personally the most unique flavor i have ever tried was XF 2.0 Lemon Cream Pie.. It sounds different, but it is done to perfection. Legit Lemon Cream Meringue Pie.
 
The Solution said:
If you love CNC then yes the beverly is your choice
If you are a huge blueberry fan then that would be wise
Do you want peanut butter?? Metabolic Nutrition PB Cookie
Do you want cinnamon? XF 2.0 Cinnamon Roll, Snickerdoodle PES,
Do you want chocolate? XF 2.0 Triple Chocolate, Metabolic Chocolate Cake
Other good choices for CnC Blue Star Milk & Cookies, Champion nutrition Cookies and Cream, Protogen CnC
Red velvet --> Iforce or MTS

Really comes down to what 2 flavors you value most. Personally the most unique flavor i have ever tried was XF 2.0 Lemon Cream Pie.. It sounds different, but it is done to perfection. Legit Lemon Cream Meringue Pie.
Click to expand...

Thanks man for the suggestions! I have experience of just one flavor...ON's Double Rich Chocolate...for the last 8 or 9 months.. At this point anything would taste good but I am severely limited by the shipping rates. I think I am set on one tub of Beverly CnC (who wouldn't love oreo milkshakes)! Its the other one that I am not sure off.

SOLUTION If you could buy only one last protein tub regardless of the type of flavor, what would it be? Is it XF Lemon cream pie?

Please note, apart from this splurge - I will probably not be able to buy other protein flavors (except for ON which I can get local for cheap) for the next 9 months (till wife releases the purse strings again...). The plan will be to ration/cycle these with ON....
 
AKM007 said:
Thanks man for the suggestions! I have experience of just one flavor...ON's Double Rich Chocolate...for the last 8 or 9 months.. At this point anything would taste good but I am severely limited by the shipping rates. I think I am set on one tub of Beverly CnC (who wouldn't love oreo milkshakes)! Its the other one that I am not sure off.

SOLUTION If you could buy only one last protein tub regardless of the type of flavor, what would it be? Is it XF Lemon cream pie?

Please note, apart from this splurge - I will probably not be able to buy other protein flavors (except for ON which I can get local for cheap) for the next 9 months (till wife releases the purse strings again...). The plan will be to ration/cycle these with ON....
Click to expand...

Bold = Correct

Don't get me wrong. I am a cookie and peanut butter fiend. also i am the biggest basic bitch in the world and love pumpkin.. but Lemon cream Pie is an experience everyone has to have once in their life. Especially if you are treating yourself. Lemon is honestly one of the thing I despise most. But you get the true aspect of lemon meringue pie + the buttery crust all in one protein shake.
Its incredible.

I even made a Lemon Meringue Pie with it.. came out F'in Bomb.com

I know it may be costing an arm and a leg, but again your treating yourself. There are tons of other in the sea that are good, but these are top tier IMO. For many that have had XF 2.0 Lemon Cream Pie. They will vouch it is in another league of its own

Invalid Link Removed
 
AKM007 said:
SOLUTION If you could buy only one last protein tub regardless of the type of flavor, what would it be? Is it XF Lemon cream pie?
Click to expand...

OP, if you like Lemon Meringue Pie this is an excellent choice.

If you like Banana and chocolate, Blue Star Chocolate Covered Banana is tremendous.

If you like blueberry muffins, you can't go wrong with iForce's bb muffin.

If you like Pumpkin Pie, MTS Pumpkin Pie is top notch.

But if I had to drink only one protein for the rest of my life: XF Cinnamon Roll. It is literally the taste of a cinnamon bun: filling, icing, dough and all with UP 2.0's buttery texture.
 
I can say I have tried pretty much every flavor out there except MTS' new Bday Cake and thank The Solution for the youtube review on that

Favorites I have had and keep in my line up and keep in mind I am a sweet fiend

AI Birthday Cake
Mutant Pro 100 Birthday Cake
Animal Franks Birthday Cake - discontinued
Axis Labs - French Toast
IFN - Blueberry Muffin
IFN - BSMOC
PES - Snickerdoodle
Quest All purpose Baking Mix - for certain situations

Honorable mention - Species Cinnamon Donut
 
Darkhorse192 said:
I can say I have tried pretty much every flavor out there except MTS' new Bday Cake and thank The Solution for the youtube review on that

Favorites I have had and keep in my line up and keep in mind I am a sweet fiend

AI Birthday Cake
Mutant Pro 100 Birthday Cake
Animal Franks Birthday Cake - discontinued
Axis Labs - French Toast
IFN - Blueberry Muffin
IFN - BSMOC
PES - Snickerdoodle
Quest All purpose Baking Mix - for certain situations

Honorable mention - Species Cinnamon Donut
Click to expand...

Grab Red Velvet from Iforce its pretty solid if you like Red Velvet.
 
The Solution said:
Grab Red Velvet from Iforce its pretty solid if you like Red Velvet.
Click to expand...

Just was your MTS powder video. I'm tempted to get Apple Pie or Bday Cake but I don't like super sweet. I've had my super sweet lemon meringue one for a year now. :/
 
No idea how anyone finds PES Snickerdoodle "good". I ordered a tub from bb.com, and has an absurd chemical aftertaste. Probably the worst I've had. Lot of people just hyping it up. Either that, or these people legit have had much ****tier tasting proteins before PES. Im sure some people like it. I've tried ON, Dymatize, etc and this is by far, the worst tasting for me. Not the taste actually, but the after taste.
 
khelzy said:
No idea how anyone finds PES Snickerdoodle "good". I ordered a tub from bb.com, and has an absurd chemical aftertaste. Probably the worst I've had. Lot of people just hyping it up. Either that, or these people legit have had much ****tier tasting proteins before PES. Im sure some people like it. I've tried ON, Dymatize, etc and this is by far, the worst tasting for me. Not the taste actually, but the after taste.
Click to expand...

You're a big minority in that brother, I'm sorry to hear we weren't for your tastebuds specifically :(

If you ever get a chance to try it out again, try out CPBC or Gourmet Vanilla,
They are so many miles ahead od what you listed, IMO
 
khelzy said:
No idea how anyone finds PES Snickerdoodle "good". I ordered a tub from bb.com, and has an absurd chemical aftertaste. Probably the worst I've had. Lot of people just hyping it up. Either that, or these people legit have had much ****tier tasting proteins before PES. Im sure some people like it. I've tried ON, Dymatize, etc and this is by far, the worst tasting for me. Not the taste actually, but the after taste.
Click to expand...

I don't think I've ever read a bad review of Snickerdoodle before, this is a first for me. Definitely try out the other PES flavors though - the texture and taste of all of their flavors are far beyond other brands, especially ON and Dymatize IMO
 
john.patterson said:
I don't think I've ever read a bad review of Snickerdoodle before, this is a first for me. Definitely try out the other PES flavors though - the texture and taste of all of their flavors are far beyond other brands, especially ON and Dymatize IMO
Click to expand...

I like Snickerdoodle, but I can see where people are coming from. It's got a VERY sharp taste, especially in water, so that can be off-putting to some.
 
Interesting. I thought Snickerdoodle was excellent in a variety of uses.
 
carmaf said:
I like Snickerdoodle, but I can see where people are coming from. It's got a VERY sharp taste, especially in water, so that can be off-putting to some.
Click to expand...

Yeah I guess I can see it. But its such a good snickerdoodle taste. I feel like you'd have to not like anything snickerdoodle to not like the Select flavor haha. To me that stuff is like crack, I can eat the powder straight out of the tub lol
 
khelzy said:
No idea how anyone finds PES Snickerdoodle "good". I ordered a tub from bb.com, and has an absurd chemical aftertaste. Probably the worst I've had. Lot of people just hyping it up. Either that, or these people legit have had much ****tier tasting proteins before PES. Im sure some people like it. I've tried ON, Dymatize, etc and this is by far, the worst tasting for me. Not the taste actually, but the after taste.
Click to expand...

Yeah I don't like it either. Doesn't taste anything like a snickerdoodle cookie either.
 
I liked PES Snickerdoodle, but thought it a bit overly sweet. the poor aftertaste you're describing is probably from the artificial sweeteners...most people have become immune because they consume so much of them.
 
Just discovered bpi whey HD, vanilla caramel tastes good and thick, I like the fact that there whey is micro filtered and certified vs. and ion exchange like a lot of crap out there...
 
bashar said:
Just discovered bpi whey HD, vanilla caramel tastes good and thick, I like the fact that there whey is micro filtered and certified vs. and ion exchange like a lot of crap out there...
Click to expand...

The new BPI flavors are on point, I would definitely agree. I forgot about them to be honest. The Peanut Butter Ice Cream Bar is fantastic.
 
I found vanilla caramel gross.
Not for me.

Strawberry Cake on the other hand, they did a good job with
Invalid Link Removed
 
I just ordered some MTS Key Lime Pie after reading through the thread. Next up are IForce Blueberry Muffin and something birthday cake flavored. Did Cellucor stop their flavor altogether?
 
jamesm11 said:
I just ordered some MTS Key Lime Pie after reading through the thread. Next up are IForce Blueberry Muffin and something birthday cake flavored. Did Cellucor stop their flavor altogether?
Click to expand...

Which flavour?

@bkupniewski can probably help you in PM
 
HITFrank said:
I enjoy Quest Protein! Strawberry, Vanilla, Peanutbutter and Chocolate all tasted great.
Click to expand...

Hear good things on PB, but Select CPBC has my tastebuds exceptionally covered there.

Grabbed the strawberry, it's ok, I still liked it but it was no USPlabs
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top