Petition for Supplement Science section

Admin said:
Come up with some rules. Make them simple and to the point.
Click to expand...

I think the essence is "This area is for scientific discussion. Personal experiences can be shared but understand that success in a group size of 1 without a control and with many other variables is not science. New threads can either be a question about the science behind an ingredient/dietary strategy or can be sharing a study / other science based piece of writing. Inappropriate responses and inappropriate new threads will be removed."
 
That was amazing :) thanks Admin and congrats Easy!
 
Nice! :thumbsup:
 
Admin said:
If you don't post in there and it becomes dead, you're all banned :D
Click to expand...

That's awesome! Thank you sir!
 
Awesome! Any chance on getting some of GDA threads moved there?

Either way, this is appreciated AM!
 
rob112 said:
Awesome! Any chance on getting some of GDA threads moved there?

Either way, this is appreciated AM!
Click to expand...

I'd sort of rather see the first or main posts in it just re-created there since so many of those threads end up with a bunch of BS in them. But if there are a few that are clean and dont' have much in the way of "I could feel the difference in nutrient partitioning when I took X product instead of Y product" then we can move em
 
EasyEJL said:
I'd sort of rather see the first or main posts in it just re-created there since so many of those threads end up with a bunch of BS in them. But if there are a few that are clean and dont' have much in the way of "I could feel the difference in nutrient partitioning when I took X product instead of Y product" then we can move em
Click to expand...

That would def be cool too. There are some really good threads floating around here.
 
rob112 said:
That would def be cool too. There are some really good threads floating around here.
Click to expand...

I'm resisting the temptation of re-posting some of Josh's articles in there, I actually learned a lot from them.
 
Ima throw up a fat loss adjuvants thread in a bit ;)

Or better yet maybe a BCAA blend thread? Compare these high leucine blends against your standard 2:1:1 blend and see what the evidence has to say about it. This one I am sure will spark some controversy
 
Is this section limited to supplements? Can we start advanced discussions on topics such as nutrition (example: low gi vs high gi carbs post workout) and on training and its effect on running speed (high reps vs heavy low reps) ?

Or is this limited to supplements only?
 
JudoJosh said:
Ima throw up a fat loss adjuvants thread in a bit ;)

Or better yet maybe a BCAA blend thread? Compare these high leucine blends against your standard 2:1:1 blend and see what the evidence has to say about it. This one I am sure will spark some controversy
Click to expand...

The problem with the ratios one is the science is very limited, and nothing that I'm aware of has ever really looked at all the 8:1:1, vs. 4:1:1, 2:1:1, etc.
 
JudoJosh said:
Ima throw up a fat loss adjuvants thread in a bit ;)

Or better yet maybe a BCAA blend thread? Compare these high leucine blends against your standard 2:1:1 blend and see what the evidence has to say about it. This one I am sure will spark some controversy
Click to expand...
I would love for this one Josh honestly...I am tired of only annecdotal comments (even my own) that say: "I feel this ratio makes me more anabolic than other!" "This one is best for cutting!" PLEASE post it up.
JudoJosh said:
Is this section limited to supplements? Can we start advanced discussions on topics such as nutrition (example: low gi vs high gi carbs post workout) and on training and its effect on running speed (high reps vs heavy low reps) ?

Or is this limited to supplements only?
Click to expand...
Interesting...Post it up, Easy can decide I guess.
 
Geoforce said:
The problem with the ratios one is the science is very limited, and nothing that I'm aware of has ever really looked at all the 8:1:1, vs. 4:1:1, 2:1:1, etc.
Click to expand...

While there isnt any on a.specific blend there are infact a handful on extra leucine added to a diet. Admitedly the andwer here is FAR from clear but considering the authoratative tone of some of people on which is better, i think it would make for an interesting discussion.
 
Admin said:
You're a mod of the forum. You decide :D

Just no AAS talk.
Click to expand...

He is a mod...well as an avid Giants fan, and a fan of good discussion on ingredients I applaud this notion :D
 
EasyEJL said:
I'd be for it, but it has been brought up before. The issue is that it sort of needs to be a more strongly moderated area than the rest. Its almost impossible to try and have a more serious scientific conversation without control of the threads. You know, you'll get the broscience wizards involved with "you've got to have 6-8 meals a day spaced no more than 180 minutes apart", and the d!ck jokes, etc.
Click to expand...

Count me in for the D!ck jokes!!!
 
JudoJosh said:
While there isnt any on a.specific blend there are infact a handful on extra leucine added to a diet. Admitedly the andwer here is FAR from clear but considering the authoratative tone of some of people on which is better, i think it would make for an interesting discussion.
Click to expand...

Agreed. FWIW I haven't heard too many lay people speak authoritatively about the ratios. It's mainly the dudes who sell the supplements who come in and go diehard for a certain ratio.
 
Thought this was a much needed addition to this thread. Was going to post it in the actual section but I didn't want to get in trouble since its technically not "supplement science." Congrats for getting this done Mr. Cooper!

Invalid Link Removed
 
DJBeanPole said:
Thought this was a much needed addition to this thread. Was going to post it in the actual section but I didn't want to get in trouble since its technically not "supplement science." Congrats for getting this done Mr. Cooper!
Click to expand...

Nice meme bro
 
DJBeanPole said:
haha I could make these things all day :)
Click to expand...

Make.more lol
 
I'll go 4 it....
^ my e-sig.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top