Well it seems to me that pepole were questioning whether the new one was the same as the last one. He wans't getting results on the new one so to prove that the new one was the same as the old one he told the guy to use the old one. Now if he continue not to get anything in terms of results then you know the issue has to do with AR downregulation and NOT the substance in question. If the guy starts to gain like crazy then everyone and their mother knows their is a difference.
See the thread started off with comments like this:
"this is great,im sure people heard there was A PH that INCREASED libido and put on mass, and now, out of the blue, its re-released and no libido increasing.
Sledge is the man. trust is key in this industry."
So either the guy continues to not get results in wihch we know both substances are the same, or he gains like crazy off the old one and Author gets egg all over his face. Do you hionestly think he would set himself up like that if he KNEW they were different?
It seems he was actually trying to put the guys mind at ease but he gets ridiculed for that as well.