This thread kicks ass!
My own opinion and formulation on the subject, should anyone care to read is as follows: There are substances that have been employed over time for one reason or another and may have been shown to directly or indirectly exert some kind of anabolic/anti-catabolic effect on human or animal subjects. These such chemicals can be found by anyone who searches enough for them. "Seek and ye shall find." A chemist can analyze the structure of the molecule to determine what enzyme is responsible for activating/de-activating this compound, what receptor this acts upon, what base hormone this new compound represents, etc... If all looks possible, the raw chemical can be ordered and capped and passed out to a variety of weight-lifters....
Take into consideration the facts of the testing group:
1. The subjects are not confined to quarters under supervision. I know for a FACT that most people won't admit that they're taking other supplements. Real recent example: Me: "Hey man, you've got some good size. Are you taking any supplements?" Other person: "Nah, just some protein and a couple herbals." In his cabinet are bottles with a supplement company I've never heard of that stacks about 4 METHYLATED STEROIDS TOGETHER IN ONE FORMULA. I said, "s**t man..." and laughed.
2. Many subjects change their diet and other habits to make sure that they get the 'most for their buck' while taking a supplement.
3. Some subjects diets and habits just aren't consistent as they think or say ... or are different from what they may lead you to believe. I know for me that I gained 8 lbs of water weight from eating a few containers of strawberries when I took 2 hits of weed from my vaporizer. Granted, I ate a lot of strawberries, but I experienced glycogen super-compensation that led to 8 lbs of weight that lingered for a day or two in less than a half hour.
4. Placebo can get to the best of us, especially when we buy into a companies reputation and feed off of other people's logs and start to think that we are feeling what they are feeling. This isn't always true, but sometimes are goals, desires, and expectations manifest themselves psychosomatically.
5. Other compounds in the formula may be causing the results and confounding the test entirely. (ex. remember Myoblast? They threw a little 20-hydroxy-ecdysone and some people actually gained 2-3 lbs in 3 months! lol)
Look.... granted some compounds may do something, there are a lot of variables for one to look at and the consumer should be educated on these. The companies here at AM don't come across as companies that are trying to scam anybody. I think that maybe... MAYBE... the companies such as ALRI and AX release a couple products that they hope will yield the same results as those products banned in the major 'prohormone/prosteroid ban'... But in trying to come up with an alternative, you either become redundant and release yet another prohormone with lesser results... or release something that looks promising, but doesn't really do a damn thing at all. Both these companies have great products, but some of them appear to be flaky to say the least.
For this very reason, I have been using products now that are used in ancient eastern cultural medicine. Even these herbs are argued by some, so... you have to be educated and careful with no matter what you buy.
There's no harm in debating and raising questions on substances, however, there's no need for bashing anyone either. That's my 2 cents worth