Guest viewing limit reached
  • You have reached the maximum number of guest views allowed
  • Please register below to remove this limitation

Dmaa products on nutraplanet

allday54

Member
What's the status of all the product containing dmaa on Nutraplanet? Has they been pulled? If not how long will you give it before they are?
 
allday54 said:
What's the status of all the product containing dmaa on Nutraplanet? Has they been pulled? If not how long will you give it before they are?
Click to expand...

Don't take chance. Stock up until it says out of stock. I got emails from other websites and Rey all have huge sales. Jack3d is 22 on some sites OEP is 30. Don't wait just stock up on what you can. I bet a lot of places are gonna be sold out tomorrow. Watch the news. I might make it there tlmorrow
 
allday54 said:
What's the status of all the product containing dmaa on Nutraplanet? Has they been pulled? If not how long will you give it before they are?
Click to expand...

Invalid Link Removed
 
strategicmove said:
Invalid Link Removed
Click to expand...

So what is your take on it all, Ike? I know it says it's lawful and I know that even if 1,3 dmaa was pulled, from what I read, it was the synthetically created form that would be illegal and naturally occurring states from geranium would be fine. Granted, how that's proven could be a nightmare and be enough for most companies to move on and scrap it. Regardless of all of that, though, it wouldn't be the first time the government did something that completely went against what was lawful or right.

I'm curious what someone with your knowledge and someone in your position thinks will unfold. Other e-tailers have definitely been trying to unload products containing 1,3 dmaa.
 
MidwestBeast said:
So what is your take on it all, Ike? I know it says it's lawful and I know that even if 1,3 dmaa was pulled, from what I read, it was the synthetically created form that would be illegal and naturally occurring states from geranium would be fine. Granted, how that's proven could be a nightmare and be enough for most companies to move on and scrap it. Regardless of all of that, though, it wouldn't be the first time the government did something that completely went against what was lawful or right.

I'm curious what someone with your knowledge and someone in your position thinks will unfold. Other e-tailers have definitely been trying to unload products containing 1,3 dmaa.
Click to expand...

I cannot comment freely on the matter, due to my affiliation with USPlabs. As things stand, however, there is no ban yet. The companies involved have a brief time window to react.
 
strategicmove said:
I cannot comment freely on the matter, due to my affiliation with USPlabs. As things stand, however, there is no ban yet. The companies involved have a brief time window to react.
Click to expand...

I gotcha, man. No worries. I wasn't trying to bait you into anything lol, but I certainly can understand and respect the inability to comment.
 
MidwestBeast said:
So what is your take on it all, Ike? I know it says it's lawful and I know that even if 1,3 dmaa was pulled, from what I read, it was the synthetically created form that would be illegal and naturally occurring states from geranium would be fine. Granted, how that's proven could be a nightmare and be enough for most companies to move on and scrap it. Regardless of all of that, though, it wouldn't be the first time the government did something that completely went against what was lawful or right.

I'm curious what someone with your knowledge and someone in your position thinks will unfold. Other e-tailers have definitely been trying to unload products containing 1,3 dmaa.
Click to expand...

Even if it is a constituent of geranium oil, which is iffy, i believe there is no way no how that the total worldwide growth of geraniums for a year would yield as much DMAA as sits in one G.N.C. store.

I sort of get the FDA's point though. If you have to take in (just throwing a number out) 2000 pounds of geranium petals to get the 25mg of DMAA, its reasonableness as "part of the food chain" isn't there. What is considered a standard dose is impossible to reach dietarily, 1% of standard dose is impossible to reach dietarily.

I'm not saying i agree with them doing it, but I understand it. I think what will happen is there will be no real direct ban on DMAA, but that the FDA will hassle all the major companies enough that it will disappear out of major retailers and only small companies will risk making a product with it.
 
EasyEJL said:
Even if it is a constituent of geranium oil, which is iffy, i believe there is no way no how that the total worldwide growth of geraniums for a year would yield as much DMAA as sits in one G.N.C. store.

I sort of get the FDA's point though. If you have to take in (just throwing a number out) 2000 pounds of geranium petals to get the 25mg of DMAA, its reasonableness as "part of the food chain" isn't there. What is considered a standard dose is impossible to reach dietarily, 1% of standard dose is impossible to reach dietarily.

I'm not saying i agree with them doing it, but I understand it. I think what will happen is there will be no real direct ban on DMAA, but that the FDA will hassle all the major companies enough that it will disappear out of major retailers and only small companies will risk making a product with it.
Click to expand...

I agree with everything you said.

I don't think that means the government has any right to pull it, but as far as its classification as a food or not, I can understand that argument.
 
MidwestBeast said:
I agree with everything you said.

I don't think that means the government has any right to pull it, but as far as its classification as a food or not, I can understand that argument.
Click to expand...

Its an area the DSHEA was not entirely clear on, it doesn't specify that the natural supplement has to be such that the same dosage could be gotten from eating, but it doesn't specify that the dosage can be a dosage that you couldn't hit if you ate the food item for a week straight either. previously it was treated as "if its in the food chain, its good" regardless of dosage. But then again, that was under the FDA chief who was actively trying to make the DSHEA fail so that it would end up being repealed. Thats why the gray market designer steroids lasted as long as they did. So this may have been along the same lines.
 
I really think it's going to be a shame if all these companies pull it when this is clearly just a scare tactic.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top