Good point (thanx btw)... BUT, these guys also surround themselves w/ the best coaches, dietary gurus, and w/o equipment or gym, and are doing these transformations for roles that are gonna net them millions of $. So there's a lot of things that offset the schedules these guys keep.
Little ol' me just plugs away in my garage, on my own, learning by trial & error and what I read on boards like these. I do have a time schedule that is very conducive to eating/trainning properly; I like to think I make the most out of what I'm surrounded with.
I'm by no means implying these Hollywood guys are clean (I aready said -- HGH!!) but sometimes folks just caried away with pointing fingers and knocking the achievements of others, all because they don't have what it takes to mentally put in the effort, don't have the knowledge, or are too busy making excuses for their own lack of progress that someone else who DOES something significant HAS to be cheating somehow. (I believe this is called "a hater?")
That being said, I originally voted YES to the thread's poll, but I now change my vote. Seeing Butler's before pics, he could most certainly have achieved this in a 5-month timeframe naturally.. I don't want to be "a hater" myself!