I understand what you are saying. But at the same time, we all react differently to various products. Some May thing product A is best while others enjoy product B better. You have to try them and see results (or lack thereof) for yourself. Just because somebody gained 5 pounds using product A doesn't mean you will. Diet and training will be a key factor in many (not all) results somebody sees from a certain product.You miss my point. I am saying that there may be many products for the same goals, intended to have the same effects, but that doesn't mean that there can only be one good one, or even that there is one best one. More good products is a good thing, as some people prefer certain ingredients/philosophies/etc, and, as you yourself have seen, some people just don't respond well to certain products.