Guest viewing limit reached
  • You have reached the maximum number of guest views allowed
  • Please register below to remove this limitation

LOTR or Narnia?

LOTR or Narnia?

  • Total voters
    45
BigVrunga

BigVrunga

Well-known member
Most of you have read these books or seen the movies...so which is better in your opinion? The Lord of The Rings trilogy or The Chronicles of Narnia?
 
I never read the LOTR books, but I used to devour the Chronicles of Narnia books when I was younger so my vote goes to that. I remember sitting down for hours and reading some of those books. They were really something special. The movie was kind of a waste of time for me though.
 
I never read the LOTR books, but I used to devour the Chronicles of Narnia books when I was younger so my vote goes to that. I remember sitting down for hours and reading some of those books. They were really something special. The movie was kind of a waste of time for me though.
Click to expand...

I read all of LOTR when I was a kid and I remember reading a couple of the Narnia books. I liked the Narnia movie more than the LOTR flicks (even though they were great). I just started reading all of the Narnia books again...just as wicked as I remember :)

BV
 
LOTR is on a level that Narnia(a little kid's series) couldn't even begin to touch.

That being said, the 3 trilogies of The Thomas Covenant Chronicles, by Stephen R. Donaldson, is on a level far and beyond anything else out there.
 
An interesting fact about these two books - Lews and Tolkien were actually good friends, and used to work on stories together over a couple brews in the local pub..
 
Pocket protectors, or just use pencils instead?..Nah, just playing BV..I would have to cast the vote for both the movie, and books of J.R.R's being far better..However, as somebody else had mentioned, they are on two vastly different levels, because they were written for vastly different audiences
 
Pocket protectors, or just use pencils instead?..Nah, just playing BV..
Click to expand...

LOL I knew that was comming:)

I would have to cast the vote for both the movie, and books of J.R.R's being far better..However, as somebody else had mentioned, they are on two vastly different levels, because they were written for vastly different audiences
Click to expand...

True, I love both stories. I enjoyed the Narnia film more though - I was disappointed in the battle scenes in LOTR because the good guys just made it look so easy. In nearly every battle, 3 guys are wiping out leigons of evil monsters without so much as a scratch...I like the good guys to win but I wanna see a struggle of mythological proportions you know?:)

BV
 
LotR. Narnia has too many fascist undertones.
"Do not question authority"
"The only beautiful woman you see must be evil"
 
Robboe said:
I am suprised anyone puts Narnia ahead of LOTR.
Click to expand...
me too! I mean of course its all opinion but its not even a question for myself

I'm referring to the movies myself though. Never read the narnia books, though read LOTR.

I liked the narnia movie a lot, but lotr was way more involving, and narnia the movie seemed more kiddy to me

and with narnia i didnt really care for the characters like LOTR brought across the screen. I think that was the main reason.
 
I agree.

In fact, i really wanted Edward to die for being such a moron.

I didn't really want Boromir to die, despite being a pillock, but to be fair, he had an awesome death in the film.
 
Narnia was just a way he could tell the story of religion to his daughter. the undertones are ones of his religious beliefs.
 
Sir Foxx said:
LOTR is on a level that Narnia(a little kid's series) couldn't even begin to touch.

That being said, the 3 trilogies of The Thomas Covenant Chronicles, by Stephen R. Donaldson, is on a level far and beyond anything else out there.
Click to expand...
Donaldon's writing style can be a bit of a cumbersome read though. And Thomas Covenent, while excellent stories, are such DOWNERS. OMFG. About as depressing as it gets.

IMO, Donaldon's greatest and most etertaining books are his Gap series. I liked the characters in that series far better. I think he did a better job of defining them. Oh and if you think Thomas Covenant was an anti-hero, you should see what Angus is like. In The Real Story, he is immediately set up as having absolutely no redeeming qualities whatsoever. In fact, his character would be the perfect hollywood villain except for the fact that his sins and actions are too horrid for hollywood. He is basically evil in a human shell. He cares for no one, and will do literally anything he wants to get what he desires. He is the ultimate scum.

Yet Donaldon, the master he is, manages by the end to get the reader to actually sympathize with him. It's pretty disturbing actually. By the end of the final books, you will find yourself rooting for Angus, hoping he succeeds.


One thing I especially like about the Gap series is how well Donaldson paints a portrait of the environment of the times illustrated in the series (hundreds of years in the future). I also like how that all the science fiction elements are explained in very scientific terms. The devices and technology in his books are all theoretically possible and based on real physics, for example the Matter Cannon.


oh, and as for Narnia or LOTR, not even close: LOTR. I liked the Narnia movie, but disliked the books. WAY too preachy.
 
Nullifidian said:
Donaldon's writing style can be a bit of a cumbersome read though. And Thomas Covenent, while excellent stories, are such DOWNERS. OMFG. About as depressing as it gets.

IMO, Donaldon's greatest and most etertaining books are his Gap series. I liked the characters in that series far better. I think he did a better job of defining them. Oh and if you think Thomas Covenant was an anti-hero, you should see what Angus is like. In The Real Story, he is immediately set up as having absolutely no redeeming qualities whatsoever. In fact, his character would be the perfect hollywood villain except for the fact that his sins and actions are too horrid for hollywood. He is basically evil in a human shell. He cares for no one, and will do literally anything he wants to get what he desires. He is the ultimate scum.

Yet Donaldon, the master he is, manages by the end to get the reader to actually sympathize with him. It's pretty disturbing actually. By the end of the final books, you will find yourself rooting for Angus, hoping he succeeds.


One thing I especially like about the Gap series is how well Donaldson paints a portrait of the environment of the times illustrated in the series (hundreds of years in the future). I also like how that all the science fiction elements are explained in very scientific terms. The devices and technology in his books are all theoretically possible and based on real physics, for example the Matter Cannon.


oh, and as for Narnia or LOTR, not even close: LOTR. I liked the Narnia movie, but disliked the books. WAY too preachy.
Click to expand...



Oh, I love the Gap series. You're dead on about Angus. First book, he's the worst of the worst, by the last you're almost rooting for him.

Donaldson's Mordant's Need series is great also, hell everything the guy writes is incredible.

Have you started reading the 3rd Covenant Triology?
 
Sir Foxx said:
Oh, I love the Gap series. You're dead on about Angus. First book, he's the worst of the worst, by the last you're almost rooting for him.

Donaldson's Mordant's Need series is great also, hell everything the guy writes is incredible.

Have you started reading the 3rd Covenant Triology?
Click to expand...

I was kind of put off by the second series. It got bogged down. I did managed to finish it, but it was definitely a slow read. Not like the Gap series; that was fast reading at its best.

Lately I've been reading Robert Jordan. Just started his most recent Wheel of Time book. Books 1-9 were great (book 9 was an absolut masterpiece), book 10 was HORRIBLE though. Book 10 was just filler. He spent the majority of it describing what people are wearing and describing scenary instead of describing actions and moving the plotline. His editor should have cut book 10 down to 100 pages. Instead it was 800 pages. Ugh. I'm hoping book 11 is more like 9 and less like 10.
 
Lately I've been reading Robert Jordan. Just started his most recent Wheel of Time book. Books 1-9 were great (book 9 was an absolut masterpiece), book 10 was HORRIBLE though. Book 10 was just filler. He spent the majority of it describing what people are wearing and describing scenary instead of describing actions and moving the plotline. His editor should have cut book 10 down to 100 pages. Instead it was 800 pages. Ugh. I'm hoping book 11 is more like 9 and less like 10.
Click to expand...

Ive read the first 3 Wheel of Time books - riveting! Another great series are the Majipoor series by Robert Silverberg.
 
BigVrunga said:
Ive read the first 3 Wheel of Time books - riveting! Another great series are the Majipoor series by Robert Silverberg.
Click to expand...

Book 4 is ok. Book 5 is awesome. Book 6 is good but the ending is unrivaled until book 9. Book 7 was overal good. Book 8 I found lacking; too much Perrin but Matt is nowhere to be found anywhere in Book 8. Book 9 is, as I said, a masterpiece.

My two favorite books in the series so far are 6 and 9. While book 5 is arguably better for most of it than 6, the ending of 6 just blew me away. It had me literally jumping up and down in my seat while I was reading it. It was one of those endings that makes you feel all tinglely. Book 9 is another that has an ending like that, only as huge as the ending of book 6 was, the ending of book 9 was just ... well my only reaction was "holy ####!!!"


And while you'll find that even though Matt started off as a bit of an annoying troublemaker, he becomes by far the coolest character in the series once he gains his powers.
 
BigVrunga said:
Ive read the first 3 Wheel of Time books - riveting! Another great series are the Majipoor series by Robert Silverberg.
Click to expand...


Ah, Lord Valentine, that brings back some memories.
 
You guys ever read the 'Necroscope' series by Brian Lumley. That has to be the greatest Vampire-based story ever. A bit of a tanget from sci-fi/fantasy I guess, but still brings back good memories of when I had mad time to read:)

BV
 
since the topic has switched to books somewhat, any of ya'll read the dark tower series by stephen king? i've gotten up to book 6 so far.
 
Beelzebub said:
since the topic has switched to books somewhat, any of ya'll read the dark tower series by stephen king? i've gotten up to book 6 so far.
Click to expand...


Read it. The coda ending is a ***** at the end of the last book. King will warn you not to read the coda, but who is going to read all 7 books some 5-6000 pages and not read the afterward?
 
To get completely superficial about it - the effects and compositing in Narnia looked very weak to me compared with the LOTR movies, especially TT and ROTK.
 
To get completely superficial about it - the effects and compositing in Narnia looked very weak to me compared with the LOTR movies, especially TT and ROTK.
Click to expand...

LOTR was definitly breath-taking, but I actually liked Narna better. Maybe it was the talking animals:)
 
BigVrunga said:
LOTR was definitly breath-taking, but I actually liked Narna better. Maybe it was the talking animals:)
Click to expand...

its okay bv... its cool to be in the minority sometimes!

i agree with the entire book reviews.... as in how LOTR's were better than Narnia (i hated the narnia book....) but the narnia movie was so much more entertaining....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top