Hyde
Legend
I love this convo, because I have always seen people touting that banded or assisted pullups are better than lat pulldowns to improve on pull ups because you are moving the body through space. However I always felt that assisted pullups via band or machine were not mechanically similar due to how the assistance affects the movement and feels nothing like a real pull up. For me they didn't carry over any better toward real pull ups than a lat pulldown. However negatives are the real deal, and seem more effective to me as well. I used them to get my wife doing pull ups when she was lifting with me.
By the way the wife's back, shoulder, arms oh hell whole physique is looking impressive. She looks like a powerhouse for sure!!!!
Yeah Lat Pulldown doesn’t transfer to anything strength-wise really in my experience except building upper back width. Definitely doesn’t help my pull-ups. Pretty much the only thing that helps that is losing weight and frequently training pull-ups lol
Thanks! She’s working hard to get back in the saddle.
For some of us, banded pull-ups are the only option. Just another tool in the box, though.
I can’t remember what you’re weighing currently, but there definitely is a threshold weight-wise where many guys often can’t build/won’t have enough upper back muscle without drugs to compensate for the increased bodyweight. I feel like it was around 235-240 for me even with drugs. So in your case, dropping 10lbs is usually the fastest way forward, BUT I would definitely encourage trying to hit a few heavy negatives where you jump up and control the descent a couple times a week before your band-assisted or other back work.
They are very fast to try incorporating and don’t have a giant recovery cost due to the super low volume.
