How often do we eat carb sources alone? Because that is what the GI measures. The vast majority of the time we eat some amount of protein, carbs, and fats in a meal. GI is pretty damn crappy at predicting blood glucose response and unsulin response to foods when full meals (protein, fat, and carbs) are eaten. This isn't to say you can just eat table sugar for all your carbs. Just that the glycemic index sucks for judging carb source quality
While this is true, it can be most helpful for those people looking to add carbs pre, post or even intra training, when they may constitute a decent percentage of the ingredients, and a certain uptake duration is desirable.
What it doesn't take into account is an individuals metabolism or ability to process & shuttle that glucose (etc) around.
Another factor, and one which many people unwittingly get wrong daily, is the order by which they consume their foods. For best digestion, there's a reason we need to eat our veg, carbs and then proteins (particularly meat) in that order, especially for large meals. Yes eating a complete meal makes the GI index a pretty ineffective tool, but appropriate meal planning and consumption can make some use of it.
As an ectomorph with a raging metabolism, I just keep plowing into the carbs all day long, white & brown rice, potato, sweet potato, some oats. After my workout I like to add a 30-40gm scoop of a medium GI sugar like organic coconut palm sugar or rapadura (panela) to my post-workout shake, as it replenishes my glycogen stores quickly and prevents me from getting tired before my meal. Those sugars are far less processed than sources like dextrose, maltodextrin or waxy maize, and also have the benefit of being relatively high in minerals so it's like a little multi-vitamin boost. They taste good too :yumyum: