Thinking about ordering from here.

handzilla

Active member
I'm thinking about placing an order. I've used ONs 100% whey for a long time now. I saw that the concentrate/isolate blend is the same thing for less.

My question is has anyone switched from ON to allthewhey and if so how would you compare the 2?
 
I used to use ON pretty much exclusively...I have been very pleased since switching. Good taste, easy to mix and great price. I have not ordered ON again since switching and dont plan on doing so...
 
Same here, I can't stand ON 100% anymore. ATW orange was a nice change. Hopefully ATW keeps coming out with new flavors so we don't get bored with them.
 
trd277 said:
I used to use ON pretty much exclusively...I have been very pleased since switching. Good taste, easy to mix and great price. I have not ordered ON again since switching and dont plan on doing so...

What did you switch to?
 
It's the price that's getting me b/c I need to up my protein intake ths year. Also I don't wanna keep dropping 47 bucks on ON 100% that might last me only a month.

Any other comments from those who have switched?
 
I use to use ON 100% because it was decent and I could get it relatively cheep (around 30-35 for 5lbs I think, Its been a while) I switched over to ATW's Blend because its a lot cheeper and the tast (at least to me) is prettymuch the same. I cant tell any differece in the chocolate, or Strawberry flavors and I think the vanilla is a little better tasting actually.

ATW's mixabilty and consistancy is the same as ON 100% (at least for the batches that I have recieved, There have been threads in which some people have gotten some bad [poor mixability] batches.)

I have never had any problems with their product or service, however like I said above there have been several threads stating that people have recieved a "bad" batch. ATW responded to them saying they they stand behind the product and if the person wanted to they could return it for an excange.

I mostly use thier blend however I have used their Isolate and it is very good as well.

So in short, I am happy with their product and will continue to use it. ( I Just wish they would get a rasberry or fruit punch flavor :) )

SR
 
Stingray said:
I use to use ON 100% because it was decent and I could get it relatively cheep (around 30-35 for 5lbs I think, Its been a while) I switched over to ATW's Blend because its a lot cheeper and the tast (at least to me) is prettymuch the same. I cant tell any differece in the chocolate, or Strawberry flavors and I think the vanilla is a little better tasting actually.

ATW's mixabilty and consistancy is the same as ON 100% (at least for the batches that I have recieved, There have been threads in which some people have gotten some bad [poor mixability] batches.)

I have never had any problems with their product or service, however like I said above there have been several threads stating that people have recieved a "bad" batch. ATW responded to them saying they they stand behind the product and if the person wanted to they could return it for an excange.

I mostly use thier blend however I have used their Isolate and it is very good as well.

So in short, I am happy with their product and will continue to use it. ( I Just wish they would get a rasberry or fruit punch flavor :) )

SR

Hi,

We guarantee our products. We pay for return shipping. We offer the choice of a full refund or exchange.

Concerning the mixing issue, everybody has the same problem. This link is dead, Invalid Link Removed, but here's a quote:

Big Phill
Freakz Rookie

it is natures best. isopure..... but it also happend to one of my bottles of On's 100% whey... so i have no idea whats goin on. The first bottles are great but the second and on they are just chunky and nasty!

Every once in a while, even though in spec, the mixing property can just be in spec. So, it'll clump. It happens less than 1% of the time. It can always be shaken.

Please keep in mind that some boards don't like us, because we wouldn't advertise with them.

Thank You
 
Do you then flavor it with anything and how do your order the 50lbs for $129?
 
dtricome said:
Hi,

We guarantee our products. We pay for return shipping. We offer the choice of a full refund or exchange.
.....
Really??? I ordered a flavorless and when I found out how horrible it was, I asked if I could do some sort of exchange or something--I was told no. I still have the e-mail. I was pretty bumbed on that...especially since I just wanted to exchange --paying the difference of course-- for a flavored isolate. I was broke as hell at the time and ended up not having any protein shakes for about 1.5 months :(

Anyway, I did, however, recieve a vanilla sample pack, and it mixes better than ON 100% and tastes good, too. I've never seen a powder that mixes so well.
 
kwyckemynd00 said:
Really??? I ordered a flavorless and when I found out how horrible it was, I asked if I could do some sort of exchange or something--I was told no. I still have the e-mail. I was pretty bumbed on that...especially since I just wanted to exchange --paying the difference of course-- for a flavored isolate. I was broke as hell at the time and ended up not having any protein shakes for about 1.5 months :(

Anyway, I did, however, recieve a vanilla sample pack, and it mixes better than ON 100% and tastes good, too. I've never seen a powder that mixes so well.

Hi,

Please contact me, because I need to know what happened. I think I do. Regardless, I'm very sorry, and I'll send you product or money.

If you don't mind pming me, I'd appreciate it. Everytime I post my email address, I get spam.

Thank You
 
kwyckemynd00 said:
Really??? I ordered a flavorless and when I found out how horrible it was, I asked if I could do some sort of exchange or something-

Every once in a while, the unflavored is bitter or sour. Like the mixability, this property is variable, and is hard to keep exact. Everybody has this problem.

The protein is still a high quality.
 
dtricome said:
Every once in a while, the unflavored is bitter or sour. Like the mixability, this property is variable, and is hard to keep exact. Everybody has this problem.

The protein is still a high quality.
That makes sense...I'm sure if my powder wasn't the rare exception, you probably wouldn't produce the unflavored, lol :D

I've still never seen any protein mix like that....my ON100% doesn't mix well. I always have little clumps. It mixes better than most, but the ATW iso/conc blend mixed way better, IMHO.

I will say, that after I had it for about 2.5 months or however long, the solubility decreased, but it took a while for that to happen.
 
Back
Top