Both are good choices. I'd do my training ib blocks of 4-6 weeks, going be how I felt and the progress I was making. A routine goes stale on me in about 4 weeks or so. Then it's time to change it up a bit or just add some various intensity methods, etc.
I def train 2x a day, each WO about 1hr. to 1 1/2 hrs. And that would be everyday. Sometimes taking a day off if feeling a little burned out.
Currently following Size Surge, phase 2. POF = positions of flexion. It's fun, something different and making great gains thus far. After this might so what's called the "Super Routine". It's a split hitting each group 3x a week. Pretty intense, will do for 2-3 weeks with some flexing thrown in for good measure....and it's summer. Ha.