To take this full circle, I listen to Dark Side of the Moon on my dad's vinyl. The subtle crackle enhances my Dark Side experience. It adds to the atmosphere for me.
But I cannot say that is true for any of the other albums we own. I have my dads original Deep Purple, Santana, Beatles, Stones, Zep, Hendrix on vinyl. They all sound better on CD and most even better on my phone with $20 mpow ear buds LOL And after all that, I dont have a strong preference for any particular music medium to be honest.