NutraBio calling out JYM for false protein claims

[The_Old_Guy]

We are not trying to make the same point I am not specifically speaking of protein quality, although personally I try to skip the products with non-dairy creamer, I was speaking to the cost/gram of protein in regards to your comment that one would be paying more for Muscle Matrix than ProJym. Cost per ~2lb container, yes Muscle Matrix is almost 25% more expensive than ProJym however on a cost/gram of protein basis, a number that is personally more important to me than the cost of a given sized container, it only about 5% more expensive. A negligible amount IMO.

Can you put up the math? I don't want to have to go digging

 

[JP10]

Way I look at it Nutrabio is around $1.25 per scoop for 25g protein each, Jym is around $1.40 per scoop for 24g protein each. If I had to choose I would pick nutrabio, but I wouldn't buy either at that price, ridiculous.

 

[USPlabsRep]

We are not trying to make the same point I am not specifically speaking of protein quality, although personally I try to skip the products with non-dairy creamer, I was speaking to the cost/gram of protein in regards to your comment that one would be paying more for Muscle Matrix than ProJym. Cost per ~2lb container, yes Muscle Matrix is almost 25% more expensive than ProJym however on a cost/gram of protein basis, a number that is personally more important to me than the cost of a given sized container, it only about 5% more expensive. A negligible amount IMO.

I agree and at 5% difference it becomes a preference...

In ModernProtein, we have a custom Micellar casein encapsulated fat instead of a traditional creamer with sugars.

 

[1Fast400]

If I were supplementing with a protein powder and I didn't suffer with lactose issues, I'd never take a whey isolate. Give me the most intact low percentage protein possible, for overall health benefit. I'll stay away from the other stuff, but you just have to be careful when doing video's like this, they can come back to bite you. Ever wonder why you've never seen me do a video?

 

[USPlabsRep]

If I were supplementing with a protein powder and I didn't suffer with lactose issues, I'd never take a whey isolate. Give me the most intact low percentage protein possible, for overall health benefit. I'll stay away from the other stuff, but you just have to be careful when doing video's like this, they can come back to bite you. Ever wonder why you've never seen me do a video?

there some video out there that will haunt some people forever. It's the "celebrity" in them not there intelligence that drives it.

 

[danielmoo]

Nutrabio seems like a great company. I have seen their formulas before and was impressed, this should only be good publicity for them.

 

[JG93]

This has become a piss shooting contest...
We are arguing over facts that we want to reprove or disapprove.
The math is right, the facts are right.

It's just like anything, the more additives, the less of the product you get.
Quality is key here. Both are of decent qualities. I wouldn't purchase either. But I'm laughing at how we keep reiterating the same thing lol.

Now, here is a topic.

Best protein isolate.

Rules:
You can name 2.
If you disagree with someone you can use 3 sentences to say why.
Make it count.


This is a more valid argument for me to read on.

 

[Jiigzz]

the amounts of lactose and fats have no correlation to a protein powders quality? the usp labs protein write up begs to differ.

he compared fact panels tic for tack, and emphasized what made a protein clean and transparent, which although can be semantics, keeping in context who started this ordeal would yield a better depiction of why it was made out this way. that was probably the most objective product comparison ive seen, how it was misleading is beyond me.

He means specifically the quality if the protein within the protein powder blend.

He's saying that the quality of protein used is equal, not that the blends of both are.

 

[ryane87]

there some video out there that will haunt some people forever. It's the "celebrity" in them not there intelligence that drives it.

"I want to be the guy that brings Jym down" and at the same time you now bring some maybe unwanted scrutiny to yourself