BCAAs

eddieSt.james

eddieSt.james

Member
Hey guys, are all BCAA products created equal? I've been using Allmax Aminocore (and love it), but it's sometimes hard to find. Are Modern BCAAs a good backup? Or BSN's Aminos? Thoughts?
 
When looking for a BCAA supp, all you need is a ratio of 2:1:1. More leucine does not mean the product is better. So, when you see ratios of 3:1:1 or even 12:1:1, it does not mean anything significant. The higher leucine content can also cause mixability issues. Also, as far SAA vs. BCAA, from what I have read, there is not going to be a difference in recovery or performance. I will let someone else chime in on that though since I am not quite up to date with that. Also, depending on the type of training you're doing, EAA might be more beneficial.
 
Yeah I prefer amino Iv because of the hica, eaa's, and a good amount of leucine. Also really enjoy purple wraath. Those are the only two I really use. all aminos are definitely not equal. Check out Iv or I linked wraath below.

Invalid Link Removed
 
Great write-up on Amino IV here Invalid Link Removed. All BCAA products are definitely not created equal. Can't forget the importance of EAA as well!
 
Yea theres tons of good BCAA's you just have to find one that has quality ingredients and tastes good.
 
Afi140 said:
Yeah I prefer amino Iv because of the hica, eaa's, and a good amount of leucine. Also really enjoy purple wraath. Those are the only two I really use. all aminos are definitely not equal. Check out Iv or I linked wraath below. Invalid Link Removed
Click to expand...

Boom! Purple Wraath is a great product. BCAA/EAA plus the addition of TMG/beta alinine/Citmal and some extras.
 
I just use Scivation Xtend because it has a lot of servings per price and it has an orange flavor, but profile-wise, the ultimate/complete Amino Acid product easily goes to PES Amino IV.
 
I am a fan of SAA myself (See: Invalid Link Removed).

Our Fruit Punch, Apple Fusion. And Blue Razz flavors of FINAFLEX BCAA/SAA are very good, too.

PM me if you're interested, I may have a decent discount for you.
 
I like the FinaFlex BCAA/SAAs taste great and seam to work very well.

Invalid Link Removed
 
schizm said:
PES AminoIV and USP Modern BCAA are my go to amino's...both great for fasted training..
Click to expand...

Aleksandar37 said:
Great write-up on Amino IV here Invalid Link Removed. All BCAA products are definitely not created equal. Can't forget the importance of EAA as well!
Click to expand...

What they said. People don't realize EAAs are what you want intra workout, and they can make a difference. Amino IV combines BCAAs, EAAs, with the muscle sparing HICA, the bad-ass ingredient Lemon Verbena, and Taurine!
 
Synapsin said:
What they said. People don't realize EAAs are what you want intra workout, and they can make a difference. Amino IV combines BCAAs, EAAs, with the muscle sparing HICA, the bad-ass ingredient Lemon Verbena, and Taurine!
Click to expand...

ive gotta try that stuff!!

used to always use EAAs.. but this lemon verbena is too cool.. i got several bottles of thermoxyn on hand which has it too
 
Taste is always an issue with BCAA's. I've bought some that smelled like dead bodies. Others that were chalky, some that didn't dissolve well no matter how much you shake them. One of the best tasting is the Apple Fusion by FINAFLEX. I love the Blue raspberry taste as well(probably my favorite) but I have to shake it for 90 seconds for it to completely dissolve.
And I agree the 2:1:1 is where it's at. I personally like the SAA's too but there are mixed studies floating around out there.
 
BCAA Wise -->
Core ABC, Scivation Xtend, Modern BCAA

BCAA/EAA Mix -->
Intra-MD, Amino IV

EAA -->
Purple Wraath

Remember this

BCAA's would only benefit you for fasted AM Training dosed pre-workout or as a bolus between meals 4-6 hours apart

Invalid Link Removed
Invalid Link Removed


WHY EAA's more important than BCAA intra-workout:
but EAAs may impart some endurance-like effects that BCAAs simply cannot.

Invalid Link Removed

This is the only study done in trained humans consuming EAAs during the workout. These are legit, military-trained personnel doing both resistance and endurance work.

The findings?

"In summary, consumption of a 10-g dose of EAA enriched with leucine during moderate endurance-type exercise stimulated increased MPS when compared with an isonitrogenous EAA supplement with an amino acid profile consistent with high-quality proteins. These data indicate that increasing leucine availability during steady state exercise promotes skeletal muscle protein anabolism and spares endogenous protein."


Cliffs:

These EAAs increased postworkout MPS by 33% when consumed during exercise
The drink with the highest leucine content spared muscle to the greatest degree
 
I take it those are just "your" favorites? No offense to Scivation but did not care for it at all.
Amino IV was just "OK" in my book.
 
turff49 said:
I take it those are just "your" favorites? No offense to Scivation but did not care for it at all.
Amino IV was just "OK" in my book.
Click to expand...

So what makes a SAA product better due to the fact most of the research has been done on insects.
Quite Curious.
 
The Solution said:
So what makes a SAA product better due to the fact most of the research has been done on insects. Quite Curious.
Click to expand...
I don't know is my easiest answer and that's why I stated my reply the way I did. I work out fasted and use my BCAA's prior to workout. On leg day I use it pre and intra. I have better response with the BCAA/SAA(Finaflex) than I did with Amino IV. I also have had great response with purple Wrath. I can't remember on Modern. Could there be other reasons? Sure. But I used each one for a full 30 days. Just my personal observations.
I wasn't trying to put down EAA's or say SAA's are superior or anything like that. Was just asking if those you listed are the ones you like in those categories you listed.
 
xR1pp3Rx said:
ive gotta try that stuff!!

used to always use EAAs.. but this lemon verbena is too cool.. i got several bottles of thermoxyn on hand which has it too
Click to expand...

Definitely try it out man! Tastes delicious, and more importantly, backed by science.

turff49 said:
I don't know is my easiest answer and that's why I stated my reply the way I did. I work out fasted and use my BCAA's prior to workout. On leg day I use it pre and intra. I have better response with the BCAA/SAA(Finaflex) than I did with Amino IV. I also have had great response with purple Wrath. I can't remember on Modern. Could there be other reasons? Sure. But I used each one for a full 30 days. Just my personal observations.
I wasn't trying to put down EAA's or say SAA's are superior or anything like that. Was just asking if those you listed are the ones you like in those categories you listed.
Click to expand...

SAAs are not scientifically proven and pale in comparison to BCAAs and EAAs.
 
AntM1564 said:
When looking for a BCAA supp, all you need is a ratio of 2:1:1. More leucine does not mean the product is better. So, when you see ratios of 3:1:1 or even 12:1:1, it does not mean anything significant. The higher leucine content can also cause mixability issues. Also, as far SAA vs. BCAA, from what I have read, there is not going to be a difference in recovery or performance. I will let someone else chime in on that though since I am not quite up to date with that. Also, depending on the type of training you're doing, EAA might be more beneficial.
Click to expand...

This is false. There is much more data showing leucine is the key BCAA than there is showing a 2:1:1 ratio is best. 3-5g leucine is key, the rest of the BCAAs are nice but don't contribute much besides aiding metabolism
 
turff49 said:
I don't know is my easiest answer and that's why I stated my reply the way I did. I work out fasted and use my BCAA's prior to workout. On leg day I use it pre and intra. I have better response with the BCAA/SAA(Finaflex) than I did with Amino IV. I also have had great response with purple Wrath. I can't remember on Modern. Could there be other reasons? Sure. But I used each one for a full 30 days. Just my personal observations.
I wasn't trying to put down EAA's or say SAA's are superior or anything like that. Was just asking if those you listed are the ones you like in those categories you listed.
Click to expand...

Well there are other reasons because AMino IV is everything in purple wraath + more, for all intents and purposes
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top