Ok, so it's a taste/preference thing, not that the actual protein source/content is listed out to the 1/10th of a gram for all four types. I believe your favorite protein (that I love too...for $10/Lb) doesn't give you any gram/milligram amounts for each source/peptide - at all
As far as the fillers, there really isn't much difference - (Comparing Vanilla) there is non-dairy creamer, which is 8 ingredients in itself. Then Silicon Dioxide, but that's a wash with Brand B's Sodium Chloride. That's it.
I would never buy ProJym again because I think it, like all other quality protein is expensive **when compared to RawDynamix/TrueNutrition** - but I loved the taste of ProJym and didn't get bloated/gas. And you know exactly how much of what, you are drinking. Different strokes...
I don't want to turn this thread into a Pro Jym bash thread, and I will give credit to Jym for opening up his protein label as well, but comparing the two is insulting to Select and a bit disingenuous IMO.
Coop and other PES reps have pretty much verified that Select is a 50/50 Casein/Whey blend, or very close to it, so that's good enough for me. Coop even hinted at how much of the Leucine peptides were added in as well. It also doesn't matter what the breakdown is end of the day when the only thing I really want in the PJ is the MPI. Open label means nothing if the product is bad.
Select is MUCH cheaper than PJ(for a Canadian at least), MPI is the finest/most expensive protein around and it makes up a majority of Select along with the very expensive Pepform addition, Select tastes better, it has a handful of ingredients which I can pronounce/recognize(in comparison to PJ CnC which looks like a small novel was put in the place of an ingredients panel, and I'm not putting that gunk in my system day in day out), almost no lactose & doesn't give me the sh*ts like PJ did(that may be due to the egg protein though) and mixes better too.
PJ doesn't even go on sale whereas with Insiders and some promotions on the double B that PES takes part in, you can find Select for an even lower price, further destroying PJ on the price front. I recently got it for 30% off which is a price point that you will never see with Pro Jym.
Forget about me buying a good number of supplements from PES, this isn't a taste/preference thing. Select beats out PJ in every way except open label and taste which is debatable obviously. I respect your posts and you seem very well informed so I don't see how you can say that they have an even comparable amount of filler.
I don't want a non-dairy creamer in a protein I'm not using as a dessert for special occasions, as I believe in not putting in a bunch of processed junk into your body everyday regardless of its macros; but that's not all, it also has a "cookie bit complex" and other such nonsense, compared to Select that just has "Sodium Chloride, Ground Vanilla Beans, Guar Gum, Sucralose, Acesulfame Potassium". Come on.
Price(which is huge), availability(many diff vendors), flavour variety, digestion, macros, quality/cost of ingredients and more. End of the day I don't even use shakes day to day, I get my protein from food, so I'm not a shake evangelist, but if you want to just talk product, and put the products back to back blow for blow, there is no comparison.