I had posted about Lemon Myrtle in a different thread and I'm going to copy and paste my replies into this post, so if any part of them seems a little out of context, that's why - but I wanted to put the information in here.
Study: :
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8912364/
Patents:
https://patents.google.com/patent/US10729737B2/en
(Patent page can be misleading bc it looks like its only the info at the top - scroll down)
Kaneka corp. has the patents on this pretty well wrapped up for anything related to muscle it seems.
Now, here is something interesting from the study:
"A.Y., S.H., M.O. and M.K. are employees of the Kaneka Corporation; and R.T. is an employee of the Kaneka Techno Research Corporation. There are no conflicts of interest to declare."
^^^ It is very common for researchers employed by large raw material and branded ingredient companies to be involved in studies on ingredients they have a financial interest in, but I have to admit that I literally laughed out loud at them writing that there was no conflict of interest. I guess technically there may not be a conflict of interest so much as a definite interest.
I also think its very relevant to point out that this study was published March 4th, 2022 and the patent application from Kaneka was filed on on 10-6-2016 and published on 3-7-2019 and granted on 8-4-2020; so all the dates involved in that preceded the study. So, it would seem like they did not get a patent on this based off of the results of this study but that this study was done on something that they already had a patent on - so that may lead one to question it a little more.
Kaneka is legit, I'm not doubting them; I'm just saying that this doesn't appear to be as random of a study as many people are saying and thinking.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My first thought that I had posted on it in the other thread:
I think that there is a lot more to the situation with this ingredient than most people are familiar with; I just posted a little about that in the above post.
I think that is has good potential IF the correct extracts are used but that a lot more research is needed to be conclusive as to how well it works and also to see if it works in the real world in the athletic/bodybuilding population. There are some great options for helping support decreased muscle loss in aging individuals that don't necessarily pan out in terms of bodybuilding type results. Some do, some don't and it normally takes real world trial and error to establish which ones do and don't.
I think that we're already seeing this ingredient be way overhyped and being touted as the next holy grail of bodybuilding ingredients and my fear is that the hype marketing is going to create unrealistic expectations with it that even if it turns out to be great, that nothing natural would be able to live up to if that makes sense. And when this happens, there's almost always a backlash against the ingredient and people say - oh, such and such doesn't work - when the reality is that yes, it may work but it works the way it works, not the way people and companies overhyping it say it works.
For example, Phosphatidic Acid is an awesome ingredient and I love it, people love it, and Phosphatidic Acid XT is probably one of our most anticipated releases ever. But if you remember back to when it was first brought to market, there was backlash against it bc some companies promoted it for d-bol like gains and when people didn't gain 10 to 15 lbs in a month, they said it didn't work; when in reality it works great, it wasn't the supplements fault it was mis-marketed. The truth is that PA is a great ingredient for consistent gains and can be used long term for great continuous consistent gains but needs time to build up in your system for best results (the complete opposite of the way it was originally marketed).
I hope all that makes sense.
If I had to guess, and its only a guess, but I would say that this is going to turn out to be an okay ingredient but would be more of a supporting role ingredient, like something that would be a great addition to an already good formula but likely wouldn't be the best candidate the main all-star ingredient of one.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My follow up thought after researching the patents more:
I wanted to follow up on my posts above. I had done a lot of looking into this awhile back and went over my notes to refresh myself on it, and I doubt that you'll be seeing Lemon Myrtle at a proper extract used by any legitimate supplement companies unless Kaneka decides to offer it as a branded ingredient because they appear to have the patents wrapped up pretty good on this.