Guest viewing limit reached
  • You have reached the maximum number of guest views allowed
  • Please register below to remove this limitation

The Unofficial Ice Cream thread

Aldi was stocking a few of their flavors for $3.99

Side note, any of you guys try the Kroger (simple truth) variation of Halo top? Invalid Link Removed

Tried the lemon cake one last night. It's really good... except if you remember when halo top first came out and you had to leave the ice cream out for 5-8min to soften it, that's how this is. It's not as creamy as halo top. But, it's only $2.99 a pint.

SM Reviews state they are better.
Skinny Cow is also making low fat ice cream right now too. So don't be surprised to see every company under the sun to join the bandwagon.
 
Just saw those when we picked up groceries today. Will definitely check them out. Also fully expect them to go on sale semi regularly like Kroger does on most of their stuff. Agreed with Dan that their in-house stuff is great (❤ CarbMaster).
 
Just saw those when we picked up groceries today. Will definitely check them out. Also fully expect them to go on sale semi regularly like Kroger does on most of their stuff. Agreed with Dan that their in-house stuff is great (❤ CarbMaster).

Send me 50 carbmasters. Starting to run low :)
 
Little G Slutty MdoughW Review
Grade: B
Invalid Link Removed

"vanilla bean ice cream with chocolate chunk brownie mdoughw pieces and chocolate sandwich cookies."

Invalid Link Removed

The vanilla bean base has been improved. Grace took and added plant stabilizers from her previous flavors to increase the density and prevent freezer burn. With that said the flavor is stronger, and has a bolder kick in the aftertaste to the vanilla bean taste

Invalid Link Removed

The Sandwich cookies as I have wrote about are the highlight of the pint. Every flavor she includes them in you get around 4-5 whole oreo cookies worth. They are chunked up into huge portions and have a fantastic crunch to the outside with a sweet cream filling
The only downside in this pint was the MdoughW pieces. I got a total of 2 of them throughout the entire pint. While they are absolutely incredible (Brownie/Cookie Hybrid) it just is not enough to judge them.
 
Little G has a questionnaire on her Instagram story for old flavors to come back to the OG line and a releas of new flavors.

Here were mine

Invalid Link Removed

Invalid Link Removed


Invalid Link Removed
 
Is she even in production though ?


I would like to see Frozen Joy & Strawberry Shortcake, especially the latter. She makes a lot of chocolate & pb focused pints. Need more fruit ones.
 
Is she even in production though ?


I would like to see Frozen Joy & Strawberry Shortcake, especially the latter. She makes a lot of chocolate & pb focused pints. Need more fruit ones.

Fruity flavors usually freeze very easy and become very icy and nasty that's why a lot of those flavors are a miss on the market. Swirls and mix in wise unless they are puréed.

She should be back in production soon she is probably getting a feel on what is most popular to her consumers to modify her lineup prior to production.

Never had a QC issue with cowboy, choc mint, fluffer, PB brittle and salted fudge or choc milk and cookies off her lineup before so I hope they all come back ... a lot likes movie night due to mix ins. The buttered popcorn base was lacking in flavor IMO

She needs to just do a base amount of regular flavors before making new ones because we clearly saw the more new flavors she put out the worse her QC got. She would be smart to just put out 8-10 regular flavors she has made before , and then consider new flavors in the future . Not now
 
Is she even in production though ?


I would like to see Frozen Joy & Strawberry Shortcake, especially the latter. She makes a lot of chocolate & pb focused pints. Need more fruit ones.

Agree on this... I will buy
 
Little G Funfetti MdoughW:
Grade: B+
Invalid Link Removed

"Cake batter ice cream with funfetti MdoughW pieces and buttercream frosting."

Invalid Link Removed

The cake batter ice cream is phenomenal. I thought coldstone had one of the best in the game, but after trying this we have a new queen in town. The cake batter is identical to taking a glorified vanilla, but with a luscious and sweet vanilla cake aftertaste.

Invalid Link Removed

First off the buttercream swirl could be my new favorite from the Little G line. The swirl is identical to eating the frosting of a cupcake or fresh cake. The pure buttercream taste is made for those who love stuffed sandwich cookies (my favorite mix in), and lots of frosting on their desserts.
 
Little G Funfetti MdoughW:
Grade: B+
Invalid Link Removed

"Cake batter ice cream with funfetti MdoughW pieces and buttercream frosting."

Invalid Link Removed

The cake batter ice cream is phenomenal. I thought coldstone had one of the best in the game, but after trying this we have a new queen in town. The cake batter is identical to taking a glorified vanilla, but with a luscious and sweet vanilla cake aftertaste.

Invalid Link Removed

First off the buttercream swirl could be my new favorite from the Little G line. The swirl is identical to eating the frosting of a cupcake or fresh cake. The pure buttercream taste is made for those who love stuffed sandwich cookies (my favorite mix in), and lots of frosting on their desserts.

Ugh sounds amazing
 
Forgot to mention that I tried out the bday cake version of the Kroger brand halo top (slow cow). Texture was almost identical to halo, on the creamier side. Taste isn't super sweet but definitely good. There's also a bunch of little sprinkles/crunchies which are good/fun. Worth a few bucks and the low cals for sure.
 
[SUP][/SUP]Graeters chunky chunky hippo --- initial review

Invalid Link Removed

Grade: B+
.
?" Toffee ice cream base, salted roasted peanuts, and milk chocolate caramel truffles"
.
Available in Cincinnati and Dayton area Graeter's store by the scoop only. Available by the pint exclusively online while supplies last*. The best part is a portion of proceeds benefit the Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden.
.
Base: The toffee ice cream is very similar to the toffee chocolate chip flavor off the OG Graeter's line. Graeter's takes their luscious vanilla and combines heath bars to form their toffee base. This packs a punch and the density of the Graeter's ice cream just enhances the flavoring. If you enjoy a chocolate/nutty combo for a base flavor this is spot on!
.
Mix-Ins: The salted roasted peanuts help enhance the toffee base. They are not very big in size, but are consistent from top to bottom. The star of the show is the milk chocolate caramel clusters. These clusters have a thick glaze of caramel packed inside the center, and a soft outside coating. If you ever had the clusters off the discontinued Gelato line you know exactly what I am talking about.
 
Graeters Vanilla Malt Chip -- initial review
Grade -- B

Invalid Link Removed

��"Intense Vanilla malt flavored ice cream with milk chocolate chips"
.
Available: This will be available for 2 weeks as the last summer bonus flavor. You will have to visit your local Graeter's Scoop shop or order line (While Supplies Last).
.
Base: The vanilla Malt is a spin off the OG chocolate chip flavor. The vanilla ice cream from Graeters is one of the best in the ice cream game. Now the addition of Malt takes the luscious vanilla base and adds a bold twist. The malt is not overpowering but present. The best way to describe the base is a mix of the OG sugary vanilla and vanilla Malt combination. The dual vanilla aspect makes this one different then the OG chocolate chip and an improved upgrade.
.
Mix-Ins: Graeter's are known for their signature chocolate chips and that is what the last bonus flavor involves. If you have never had Graeter's Chocolate chips they are absolutely massive in size and pack a punch of rich milk chocolate flavor. There is a reason the chocolate chips are "Signature" as some of them can eclipse over 1/2 - 1" in size. Easily the best chocolate chip mix-in on the market.

Super simple but executed well... the milk choc chips instead of the dark chocolate chips were a strong move
 
Graeters Vanilla Malt Chip:
Grade: B

"Intense Vanilla malt flavored ice cream with milk chocolate chips".

Invalid Link Removed

Invalid Link Removed

The vanilla Malt is a spin off the original chocolate chip flavor. The vanilla ice cream from Graeter's is one of the best in the ice cream game. Now the addition of Malt takes the luscious vanilla base and adds a bold twist

Invalid Link Removed

Graeter's are known for their signature chocolate chips and that is what the last bonus flavor involves. If you have never had Graeter's Chocolate chips they are absolutely massive in size and pack a punch of rich chocolate flavor. There is a reason the chocolate chips are "Signature" as some of them can eclipse over 1/2 - 1" in size
 
Tried out some of the new halo tops last night:

Chocolate covered banana - tastes like banana runts with a hint of chocolate. If you had the b&j one love the base in halo is similar flavor just way stronger. Really good if you like the "fake" banana flavor.

Rainbow sherbet: exactly like it should (I thought this was a dumb flavor since regular sherbet is already pretty low cal ha. Gf wanted it tho)

Cinnamon roll: a very simple cinnamon/vanilla base. Not bad but nothing spectacular. The chunks do make it better but overall underwhelming.

None of them top my current favs
 
Tried out some of the new halo tops last night:

Chocolate covered banana - tastes like banana runts with a hint of chocolate. If you had the b&j one love the base in halo is similar flavor just way stronger. Really good if you like the "fake" banana flavor.

Rainbow sherbet: exactly like it should (I thought this was a dumb flavor since regular sherbet is already pretty low cal ha. Gf wanted it tho)

Cinnamon roll: a very simple cinnamon/vanilla base. Not bad but nothing spectacular. The chunks do make it better but overall underwhelming.

None of them top my current favs

calling BS on this ;)
 
Tried out some of the new halo tops last night:

Chocolate covered banana - tastes like banana runts with a hint of chocolate. If you had the b&j one love the base in halo is similar flavor just way stronger. Really good if you like the "fake" banana flavor.

Rainbow sherbet: exactly like it should (I thought this was a dumb flavor since regular sherbet is already pretty low cal ha. Gf wanted it tho)

Cinnamon roll: a very simple cinnamon/vanilla base. Not bad but nothing spectacular. The chunks do make it better but overall underwhelming.

None of them top my current favs

Wife grabbed the pancake one. Will report back
 
Wife grabbed the pancake one. Will report back

Definitely interested to hear. My Giant Eagle has labels for them in the freezer section but no ice cream yet. Candy bar is supposed to be very good. I'm also looking forward to pumpkin and gingerbread
 
Definitely interested to hear. My Giant Eagle has labels for them in the freezer section but no ice cream yet. Candy bar is supposed to be very good. I'm also looking forward to pumpkin and gingerbread

Gingerbread? I only heard pumpkin
 
Was at Kroger to pick up groceries for our shift this morning and saw the Low Cow or whatever pints listed as 10 for $10 -- doubled back to check the sign and it said sale til 9/13, so I'll be going tomorrow off work to grab 10 of them for research purposes lol
 
Gingerbread? I only heard pumpkin

Gingerbread is coming out for winter. It's been confirmed on several of the food porn IG accounts I follow! I went to Giant Eagle today and they literally had one pint of Waffles and Syrup. No other flavors are in yet, unless they sold out of all of the new ones in like 2 days! I bought said pint, of course.
 
Graeter's 8 summer bonus flavors from best to worst (Full review on hippo tomorrow)

1. Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

Invalid Link Removed

2. S'mores

Invalid Link Removed

3. Chunky Chunky Hippo

Invalid Link Removed

4. Dark Chocolate Fudge Brownie

Invalid Link Removed

5. Peanut Brittle

Invalid Link Removed

6. Vanilla Malt Chocolate Chip

Invalid Link Removed

7. Butterscotch Latte

Invalid Link Removed

8. Caramelized Chocolate

Invalid Link Removed

Few days till S&S Drops September which should be epic.
 
Gingerbread is coming out for winter. It's been confirmed on several of the food porn IG accounts I follow! I went to Giant Eagle today and they literally had one pint of Waffles and Syrup. No other flavors are in yet, unless they sold out of all of the new ones in like 2 days! I bought said pint, of course.
Review on waffles and syrup?
 
Review on waffles and syrup?

So it's actually Pancakes and Waffles (my bad). I only had a few bites, but it is spot on. I let it temper and the consistency is nice and creamy (for a low fat/high protein ice cream). Although I think most HT flavors have a good consistency. Anyway, this is very buttery and tastes just like waffles. Not as much maple as I'd like, but I'm going to put some low cal maple syrup on it tomorrow. It's good, but not one of my favorites.
 
So it's actually Pancakes and Waffles (my bad). I only had a few bites, but it is spot on. I let it temper and the consistency is nice and creamy (for a low fat/high protein ice cream). Although I think most HT flavors have a good consistency. Anyway, this is very buttery and tastes just like waffles. Not as much maple as I'd like, but I'm going to put some low cal maple syrup on it tomorrow. It's good, but not one of my favorites.

Awesome... sounds like a nice unique flavor that even at average execution would be unique enough for a special trip
 
Awesome... sounds like a nice unique flavor that even at average execution would be unique enough for a special trip

I just saw the candy bar one at the hyvee by my place. Wife hasn't dug into her pint of pancake one yet... when she does I'll get a taste of it as well.
 
��Graeter's Chunky Chunky Hippo��
��Grade: B+
��" Toffee ice cream base, salted roasted peanuts, and milk chocolate caramel truffles"
Invalid Link Removed

Invalid Link Removed

The toffee ice cream is very similar to the toffee chocolate chip flavor off the Original Graeter's line. Graeter's takes their luscious vanilla and combines heath bars to form their toffee base. This packs a punch and the density of the Graeter's ice cream just enhances the flavoring

Invalid Link Removed

First up lets talk about the salted peanuts. They are not very big in size, but are consistent from top to bottom. The enhanced salt really brings out the base and blends well the flavor it provides. The star of the show is the milk chocolate caramel clusters. These clusters have a thick glaze of caramel packed inside the center, and a melt in your mouth milk chocolate coating. If you ever had the clusters off the discontinued Gelato line you know exactly what I am talking about.
 
Invalid Link Removed

6 flavors of Low Cow:
- chocolate
- vanilla
- lemon cake
- bday cake
- mint choc chip
- sea salt caramel

Picked up 1 of the first 2 and 2 of the last 4; 10 for $10 (they bumped the price to $4.19, but the manager hooked me up).

3 lemon cake Halo Top, 1 Pistachio, 1 new pancakes.

The former were closeout ($1.74/pint if you buy 5). I bought the last 4 total and the new flavor made 5 to get me the discount.

$20 for 15 pints of ice cream ?
 
Invalid Link Removed

6 flavors of Low Cow:
- chocolate
- vanilla
- lemon cake
- bday cake
- mint choc chip
- sea salt caramel

Picked up 1 of the first 2 and 2 of the last 4; 10 for $10 (they bumped the price to $4.19, but the manager hooked me up).

3 lemon cake Halo Top, 1 Pistachio, 1 new pancakes.

The former were closeout ($1.74/pint if you buy 5). I bought the last 4 total and the new flavor made 5 to get me the discount.

$20 for 15 pints of ice cream ?
I swear these are like $10-12+ in Australia for a single tub.
 
Little G's Peanut Butter Fudge MdoughW
Grade: B
Invalid Link Removed

"Peanut butter ice cream with triple chocolate fudge MdoughW pieces and a fudge swirl."

The flavoring is not as strong as eating peanut butter out of a jar, but congeals the creaminess and flavor of peanut butter very well. The only small factor that is missing is a salty aftertaste found in true peanut butter.

Invalid Link Removed

The triple chocolate fudge mdoughw pieces are very heavy in flavor. While there was not a lot (just like all the flavors in the pack) the flavoring is top notch. You get a glimpse of every chocolate (milk, dark, and swiss) in each bite, and they also have the dense and chewy consistency that resembles a cookie and brownie.

Invalid Link Removed
 
Low Cow bday cake delivers.

Been a while since I had Halo Top's, but I believe there are more mix-ins and s comparable flavor.
 
Low Cow bday cake delivers.

Been a while since I had Halo Top's, but I believe there are more mix-ins and s comparable flavor.

Agreed. The little crunchy sprinkle bits were fun and plentiful. Creaminess on or or better too
 
Little G's Ice Cream Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Grade: A-
Invalid Link Removed

"chocolate ice cream + peanut butter caramel swirl + peanut butter cups".

Invalid Link Removed

I have had some incredible chocolate bases over the years (Jeni's and Salt & Straw come to mind as my top 2) and this is good but does not take the throne. Jeni's before the listeria craze was hands down the GOAT (Greatest of All Time) with how dense, premium, and bold their chocolate flavor was. What I like about Little G's is that is has a 60/40 mix of dark and milk chocolate combined together.

Invalid Link Removed

The Peanut Butter Caramel Swirl in Little G's Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is now glorious. I thought my cowboy cookie and Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel swirls were massive, this may take the cake. The peanut butter aspect is basically eating a jar of fresh peanut butter. The kicker here is the aftertaste of caramel.

Combine the sweetness and luscious thick filling of caramel on top of peanut butter and it is genius. The peanut butter cups were chunked up from top to bottom and in every single bite.

Simple yet on point..this revamped version was Solid
 
Little G's Maple Oatmeal Cookie Dough
Grade: B+
Invalid Link Removed

"Maple Ice Cream with oatmeal cookie dough chunks & Candied Walnuts"

Invalid Link Removed

The Maple is pure and reminds me of the aftertaste of maple syrup. It packs a lot of flavor and leaves a long lingering taste that has you going back for more. This is easily one of her best unique bases she offers off of Little G

Invalid Link Removed

I am not a huge fan of the candied walnuts that are featured in Carrot cake, and the white chocolate MdoughW. If you actually read my reviews I downgraded both of those flavors due to how large and hard they were. Luckily in this pint I did not get any of them (which played in my favor). Instead I was presented with one inch size chunks of oatmeal cookie dough which was glorious. The texture of the cookie dough is very soft which almost reminded me of the S&S Chunks provided in their flavors
 
Little G's Peanut Butter & Jelly:
Grade: B-
Invalid Link Removed

"Peanut Butter Ice cream with a homemade raspberry jam swirl & honey roasted peanuts."

Invalid Link Removed

The Peanut butter base flavoring is not as strong as eating peanut butter out of a jar, but congeals the creaminess and flavor of peanut butter very well. The only small factor that may be missing is a salty aftertaste found in true peanut butter. Grace may have been going with a bold peanut butter when formulating this base, and with that said she did a good job.

Invalid Link Removed

The homemade raspberry jam swirl is great! The flavoring is very bold and actually overpowers the peanut butter base when you combine both elements together. With how much strength she packed into the flavor of that swirl it really is remarkable to know how she made it herself and what recipe she did use. Some people like grape over raspberry when it comes to PB&J, but with how dense the swirl was I do not think anyone would be mad about what flavor she decided to use. The honey roasted peanuts did not have much to offer besides being there in the pint.
 
Little G PB Marshmallow
Invalid Link Removed
Grade: B

"Peanut Butter Ice cream with a marshmallow swirl and mini peanut butter cups."

The Peanut butter base flavoring is not as strong as eating peanut butter out of a jar, but congeals the creaminess and flavor of peanut butter very well. The only small factor that may be missing is a salty aftertaste found in true peanut butter. Grace may have been going with a bold peanut butter when formulating this base, and with that said she did a good job

Invalid Link Removed

The marshmallow swirl has a very sweet aftertaste and a bold flavor that really strikes you after digging into the peanut butter base. The swirl was heavy on the first portion of my pint, but soon after faded away pretty fast. I would of liked to of seen it stay strong throughout the entire experience, but that did not happen. The mini peanut butter cups she did reformulate and do from previous batches of flavors and it was for the better. These are melt in your mouth soft and have a very nice milk chocolate outer coating and sweet peanut butter filling.

Invalid Link Removed
 
Graeter's Blueberry Pie is back for Cones for Cure (Proceeds go to a young girl who's tragic battle with pediatric brain cancer inspired the creation of The Cure Starts Now Foundation )

Invalid Link Removed

I got a pack being shipped to me from the company for review. Last time I had it was 2013
 
Graeter's Elena's Blueberry Pie:
Grade: B+
Invalid Link Removed

"blueberry flavor ice cream loaded with real blueberries and pie crust pieces".

Invalid Link Removed

Graeter's has revamped this limited edition flavor to a blueberry ice cream. Just like the other fruit flavors on the line the density of the base ice cream really shine .A huge problem with fruity flavors on the market is they can taste overbearing and fake. Graeter's found a pure blueberry flavor that leaves a savoring luscious aftertaste.


Invalid Link Removed

Graeter's wanted to amplify the base by adding in real blueberries, and a complimenting pie crust pieces as the mix-ins. uckily Greater's did a great job with the french pot process and found a way to keep the blueberries tasting garden-fresh. The pie crust pieces were flaky and packed a sugary aftertaste. The pieces were more like chunks which were consistency from top to bottom in almost every single bite.
 
Possible new gelato fiasco for 2018....sign me up!!




Sunken Treasure: brown butter gelato, salty pretzel booty, fudge bits, swirl
Bourbon Butter Pecan: butter pecan gelato, nip of bourbon, buttered pecans
Deep Maine Woods: chocolate gelato, smoky caramel swirl, honeycomb candy
Double Caramel Cookies & Cream: caramel gelato, salted caramel swirl, chocolate cookies
Doughing Me, Doughing You: peanut butter cookie dough, chocolate chip dough, brownie dough (& fudge truffles)
A Big 'Ole Peanut Butter Pint: salted creamy peanut butter base, rippled peanut butter swirl, chopped chocolate peanut butter cups
 
Possible new gelato fiasco for 2018....sign me up!!




Sunken Treasure: brown butter gelato, salty pretzel booty, fudge bits, swirl
Bourbon Butter Pecan: butter pecan gelato, nip of bourbon, buttered pecans
Deep Maine Woods: chocolate gelato, smoky caramel swirl, honeycomb candy
Double Caramel Cookies & Cream: caramel gelato, salted caramel swirl, chocolate cookies
Doughing Me, Doughing You: peanut butter cookie dough, chocolate chip dough, brownie dough (& fudge truffles)
A Big 'Ole Peanut Butter Pint: salted creamy peanut butter base, rippled peanut butter swirl, chopped chocolate peanut butter cups

Doughing Me is not new, but it was the best of the last seasonal pack including it
Invalid Link Removed
Invalid Link Removed

The last seasonal pack including that flavor was decent... Would not repurchase. They have some clever names, but lack on the quality front with the mix-ins and consistency.

Truffles in River City B-
The Goods B-
Supernatural Spirit B-
Biddy Babka B
Donut Cry for Me B (only had 2 pieces of mix-ins)
Invalid Link Removed

Was really hoping for that babka to be so much better. Someone needs to take TJ's Babka and put it into ice cream.
 
Little G's Bangin Baklava
Grade: C-
Invalid Link Removed

"honey ice cream with baklava chunks, candied pecans, roasted pistachios, and honey caramel swirl."


The honey ice cream is indeed pure and very true to its name. Think about going to a bee farm and buying fresh honey from a market. The richness of the flavor was on point. The density of little G's ice cream was good, but there is a problem when you use a lot of honey in ice cream it melts fast, and by fast I mean in minutes

Invalid Link Removed

For the mix-ins my swirl was the entire bottom half of the pint. Others had this happen to theirs as well which was not evenly distributed or consistent from top to bottom. My pint did not have a lot of candied pecans or roasted pistachios, but her candied pecans are her best nut mix-in. They provide a nice cinnamon sugar aftertaste and are abundant in size. The baklava chunks were easily the star of the show as they packed incredible flavor. The outside of the baklava had a thin layer and the inside enhanced the nut mix-ins and honey ice cream base.

Invalid Link Removed
 
You're right that one is not new....but it is new in the sense it will be readily available.
..before it was in a pack that you only had two chances to order....plus, the others sound great and gelato fiasco os much more cost efficient
 
You're right that one is not new....but it is new in the sense it will be readily available.
..before it was in a pack that you only had two chances to order....plus, the others sound great and gelato fiasco os much more cost efficient

a 6 pack will be around $90.
I would rather spend the money and get some superior ample hills pints, instead of getting some busts.

No Sleep Till Pumpkin is churnin, should be available for online ordering soon if you did not get it last year from AH
S&S Will be back with The Great Candycopia next month
 
Back
Top