The Unofficial Ice Cream thread

The Solution said:
She probably got 100 other + emails stating the same thing on churro. It is either 100% goldmine, or a dud.. That is why I told you to only get 1 in your 10 pack :) Slutty and PB Fudge (which you tripled on) will be well worth it.
Click to expand...
Triple on slutty double on pb fudge and double funfetti. Good gracious looking forward towards those
 
Odd question, any of you gentlemen have a discount code or coupon for either Little Gs or Ample Hills?
 
Who makes the best chocolate with peanut butter ice cream ?? I'm looking to branch off from my all time favorite ...Ben and jerry peanut butter world...I don't think it's possible for any ice cream to be better that the PB world
 
Mrbolt84 said:
Who makes the best chocolate with peanut butter ice cream ?? I'm looking to branch off from my all time favorite ...Ben and jerry peanut butter world...I don't think it's possible for any ice cream to be better that the PB works
Click to expand...

Graeter's Buckeye Blitz, Little G's Chocolate PB Cup
If you think B&J is the best, you sir have a lot of ice cream to venture out on. That is more towards the bottom of the barrel as a mass brand. There are some hidden gems out there (Salt & Straw, Ample Hills, Little G's, Graeter's, Clemenine's). These companies take a little more time to refine their flavors, make their mix-ins in house from local ingredients to amp up the quality.
 
The Solution said:
Graeter's Buckeye Blitz, Little G's Chocolate PB Cup
If you think B&J is the best, you sir have a lot of ice cream to venture out on. That is more towards the bottom of the barrel as a mass produced item. There are some hidden gems out there (Salt & Straw, Ample Hills, Little G's, Graeter's, Clemenine's)
Click to expand...

I never said Ben and jerrys in the best ice cream. I was stating that imo peanut butter world is the best chocolate ice cream with peanut butter...I've had a tub almost every weekend for the last 2 years lol. I can't get enough of it.
I am open to venturing away from pb world...just need an amazing chocolate pb alternative lol
 
Mrbolt84 said:
I never said Ben and jerrys in the best ice cream. I was stating that imo peanut butter world is the best chocolate ice cream with peanut butter...I've had a tub almost every weekend for the last 2 years lol. I can't get enough of it.
I am open to venturing away from pb world...just need an amazing chocolate pb alternative lol
Click to expand...

Well its easy to venture from B&J, but you may have to pay some money to get it. Just like anything with quality it will cost a bit more then a local mass produced pint

Little G's PB Cup beats it. It has the PB Swirls, but has about 40 peanut butter cups added to the chocolate base
Invalid Link Removed

Graeter's Buckeye Blitz ask Driven2lift he just had it.. Clearly Graeter's top tier flavor and is a chocolate PB paradise with added cookie dough.
Invalid Link Removed

Plus the chocolate chip pieces are literally inches in length.

Graeter's PB Chocolate Chip
Invalid Link Removed

Ample Hills PB Wins the Cup:
Invalid Link Removed

Handel's SNIX
Invalid Link Removed

Handel's Buckeye
Invalid Link Removed

Handel's Chocolate PB Brownie:
Invalid Link Removed

Mrbolt84 said:
Who makes the best chocolate with peanut butter ice cream ?? I'm looking to branch off from my all time favorite ...Ben and jerry peanut butter world...I don't think it's possible for any ice cream to be better that the PB works
Click to expand...

Trust me.. there are plenty better then PB World. While it is a good flavor from B&J The quality of the above brands take their flavor, quality, and mix-ins up another level.
 
Mrbolt84 said:
Yes please for the little g. I'm gonna buy some today
Click to expand...

Shot ya a PM buddy.
Also gave you my suggestions because I know you want that Choc PB CUP. She also re-did the flavor and threw in a bigger swirl.

Invalid Link Removed
Invalid Link Removed

as you can see. ridiculous
 
Mrbolt84 said:
Im dying right now...currently doing cardio ..salivating over these pics
Click to expand...

If you grab the pack I told you to get. The Fudge brownie has a VERY thick swirl like above (just chocolate)
PB Brittle & Salted Fudge has a killer salty combo with thick pieces of brittle and fudge. one of my favorites from her.
Snack Attack x2 is a favorite because of the sheer amount of mix-ins (Candy, Pretzels, Chips) Sweet and Salty here
Choc PB Cup -- Because that is what you want.
Chocolate Milk & Cookies is her favorite. I know you want the Choc PB Cup in that pack, but I would not skimp this one. it is loaded to the brim with chocolate stuffed cookies.

but if you want more Choc PB then double up on it.
Its an absolute land mine of stuffed cookies (Oreo's) mixed into a chocolate base

Invalid Link Removed
Invalid Link Removed
 
The Solution said:
Shot ya a PM buddy.
Also gave you my suggestions because I know you want that Choc PB CUP. She also re-did the flavor and threw in a bigger swirl.

as you can see. ridiculous
Click to expand...

Alright, I’m convinced that I need to expand my ice cream horizons, I need some Little G’s in my life! Would I be able to use that promo code as well for Little G’s?
 
Mrbolt84 said:
Good lord the Buckeye blitz looks amazing !
Ordering asap
Have any promo codes solution???
Click to expand...

Where are you from? Graeters is carried in quite a few grocery stores and buckeye is pretty common
 
booneman77 said:
Where are you from? Graeters is carried in quite a few grocery stores and buckeye is pretty common
Click to expand...

California. I found it's available at Ralph's supermarkets. I've been online searching stores that are close to me.
No stores close to me have the buckeye blitz
 
Sometimes I find it labeled as Buckeye Blitz and others as Buckeye Chip or something like that, which is interesting.
 
I'll vouch for it if you can find it. I'm not a big contributor to this thread. I pretty much just lurk for the ice cream nudes...but I have had Buckeye Blitz and it is amazing.
 
I might be an outlier here but I personally think Graeters Buckeye is overhyped on this forum.

I have had it 3x and also tried BnJ PB World, PB Bites & PB Cookie Core, Handels Buckeye, 3 Little Gs PB variants, 2-3 Ample Hills PB variants and several other brands Choc PB cup pints.

Graeters is at best 3rd behind AH & Little Gs, depending on my mood I like BnJ better too
 
GNO said:
I might be an outlier here but I personally think Graeters Buckeye is overhyped on this forum.

I have had it 3x and also tried BnJ PB World, PB Bites & PB Cookie Core, Handels Buckeye, 3 Little Gs PB variants, 2-3 Ample Hills PB variants and several other brands Choc PB cup pints.

Graeters is at best 3rd behind AH & Little Gs, depending on my mood I like BnJ better too
Click to expand...

It's also 1/3 the price and much easier to procure ha
 
With how easy it is to find, and affordably it can he found, I am quite content with sticking to PB half baked or PB World

*shrug*

I will try the others once I can but even if I love them to death, 3x the price... A rare treat at best
 
Driven2lift said:
With how easy it is to find, and affordably it can he found, I am quite content with sticking to PB half baked or PB World

*shrug*

I will try the others once I can but even if I love them to death, 3x the price... A rare treat at best
Click to expand...

Good man..pb world is amazing
 
Plus when you're cutting a lot of pints taste like an "A" lol

Go a week clean eating in a deficit and have a pint of PB World, it's going to be right up there with a good orgasm
 
Mrbolt84 said:
Dude how much free ice cream do you get a month??? You can't be paying for all this right ??
Click to expand...

I pay for my ice cream. I have no affiliation with Little G, Salt & Straw, Ample Hills etc. I personally would rather pay the extra money for the quality. Just personal preference.
 
Can I ask how much what is in that photo cost?

I hear your point, and hey we all know you love your ice cream so you do you
 
Driven2lift said:
Can I ask how much what is in that photo cost?

I hear your point, and hey we all know you love your ice cream so you do you
Click to expand...

I got a $150 voucher on goldbely for $65 for the 10 pack through a special deal that was limited time.
I had credits + coupon that covered the MdoughW 6 pack

So all in all 16 pints at $65. Paying around $4/Pint
 
Well that is an easy choice I guess at $4/pint

Retail without those perks is then well over $150 though?
 
MidwestBeast said:
Yeah, huge difference lol
Click to expand...

Be a wise shopper and you get good deals.
Even without the coupons I would still buy 5-6 pints of Salt & Straw for $120, $110 for 6 Little G's, or 4 Pints of AH for $80 because the quality is worth every penny. Just got to play your cards right on what flavors your picking up.
That said I always have a coupon code for goldbely which would drop that price to $85

In a perfect world, it would be great to pick up these brands local from the shops, but not always the case.
 
Mrbolt84 said:
Just picked up some graeters double chocolate chip..it's all i could find at my local supermarket
Click to expand...

Still a good flavor, but IMO Buckeye, Cheese crown, Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, or CNC round off their top 4.
Should see another summer bonus flavor dropping next week for Graeters!
 
Ample Hills The Land of Milk & Honey
Grade: B
Invalid Link Removed

""A salty honey ice cream with pieces of cinnamon bun ButterCrunch matzo from our friends at The Matzo Project.""

Invalid Link Removed

The base is a salty honey ice cream which is very similar to Sweet as Honey and the Commodore. What I really enjoy is the amount of salt added to this flavor.

Invalid Link Removed

At first I had to google matzo to find it was a jewish flatbread. With the added cinnamon bun butter crunch this reminded me of eating cinnamon toast crunch infused into ice cream.
 
The Solution said:
Graeter's Buckeye Blitz, Little G's Chocolate PB Cup
If you think B&J is the best, you sir have a lot of ice cream to venture out on. That is more towards the bottom of the barrel as a mass brand. There are some hidden gems out there (Salt & Straw, Ample Hills, Little G's, Graeter's, Clemenine's). These companies take a little more time to refine their flavors, make their mix-ins in house from local ingredients to amp up the quality.
Click to expand...

I would take pb world over buckeye anyday I know u think I'm nuts but that cookie swirl 8s unbeatable
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top