Yes, now I remember. I heard it from you and it made sense. Pulling slowly / squeezing on top -then fast release should be optimal.
About my pull ups / chin ups being crossfit style...well, I don't use momentum to go up -but yes, I arch the back...so what? As long as I don't do swimming froggy-motions with the legs (like
HIT4ME ), it should count, right?
Hey now. If all grips are OK for pull ups, what's wrong with the froggy-lets?
Actually - I was watching a video on the leg positioning, because now that I've reached constant exhaustion in my back from doing the pull up challenge, I am noticing I actually tend to pull my legs forward a little. No swinging, more like I do a leg raise as I'm doing the pull up, just a little bit. But for the most part, my legs get in front of me and stay there.
Some people seem to think this gives a better stretch on the lats keeping the legs in front. Keeping the legs behind you seems to contract the muscle more. Not sure if one way or the other is better...or cheating...
Absolutely, and he was just pulling your leg there, or is a form Nazi x2.
Anything you do differently than
HIT4ME is an improvement.

okey:

okey:

okey:
That is good advice for all things in life. Don't be like Hit4me. Just keep letting him be one-of-a-kind.
Surprised to hear that slow negatives for rows are bad.
Yeah, I hear a lot of things. This is good, no it's bad, no it's not good again.
The trick is to be aware of the positives and negatives. I get what people are saying about slow negs on a bent over row...or a deadlift, and maybe even a squat or leg press for that matter - using extremely heavy weights in positions that could compromise you and then trying to lower it slowly really seems like a good way to hurt yourself. But then again, so is letting it drop and jerk on you. I still control decents, even on deadlifts, but I don't stick hardfast to my 3-4 seconds down that I use for a lot of exercises.
It reminds me of dumbbell curls - cheating is bad! Don't ever do it! But cheat curls build the biggest arms! At the end of the day, good form is great, but cheating can be a tool if it is used to allow for more work and is used as carefully/safely as possible while understanding that you are taking on some risk. I kind of thing the slow negative on bent over rows may be similar.