Guest viewing limit reached
  • You have reached the maximum number of guest views allowed
  • Please register below to remove this limitation

The Unofficial Ice Cream thread

Never had mcconells either but that pb does sound awesome
 
McConnells is one of the best on the market
Straight from California
PB, Sweet Cookies and Cream and Peanut Brittle are 3 killer flavors.

Salt & Straw, McConnells would be two of the best out there. Quality is pretty good and similar to Handel's .
 
McConnells is one of the best on the market
Straight from California
PB, Sweet Cookies and Cream and Peanut Brittle are 3 killer flavors.

Salt & Straw, McConnells would be two of the best out there. Quality is pretty good and similar to Handel's .

[video=youtube;qFVRlyJaTYI]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFVRlyJaTYI[/video]

easy A

Invalid Link Removed
 
Trader Joes Pumpkin Ice Cream:

Invalid Link Removed


Invalid Link Removed

If you are a person who loves pumpkin, and will go head over heels for a basic pumpkin ice cream this will be a wise investment. For someone who needs a mix-in or compliment to a pumpkin ice cream I would pass. Many enjoy a graham cracker swirl, marshmallow ripple, or a heavy dose of pumpkin spice to put together the pieces to a perfect pumpkin ice cream. While this may not crack my top 5 overall pumpkin ice creams I have had in the past, there could be room for improvement. If Trader Joe's decided to throw in a swirl (why turkey hill got the edge), or other mix-ins this would get a higher grade. I ended up mixing a few Jo Jo's into the last few scoops to give it a nice upgrade.

Grade: C+


My Updated Pumpkin Rankings:

1. Handels
2. Jeni's
3. Coldstone
4. Talenti
5. Perry's
6. Turkey Hill
7. Trader Joe's
8. Ben & Jerry's
9. Dairy Queen
10. Graeters
 
breezy11 said:
Fresh Market had a bunch of the line.
Click to expand...

Correct
or else you are going to pay 80$ for shipping for 6 pints.

some more on Mcconnells

[video=youtube;Oywr4sAr7IQ]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oywr4sAr7IQ[/video]

Invalid Link Removed
middle is similar to HD Peanut Butter Pie with huge chunks of peanut butter and flecks of chocolate

Invalid Link Removed

[video=youtube;UMJriI9daN4]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMJriI9daN4[/video]

my buddy in columbus grabbed me a pint of the PB and the sweet cream and cookies which are supposed to be their #1/#2 best.
 
The Solution said:
I see me and you are limited on our Fresh Market runs. Makes 2 of us :(
They do stock Gelato Fiasco as well which has some killer flavors. Highly suggest looking into some of those too boone.
Click to expand...

Yup. I grabbed their toasted s'mores or whatever it's called.
 
The Solution said:
I see me and you are limited on our Fresh Market runs. Makes 2 of us :(
They do stock Gelato Fiasco as well which has some killer flavors. Highly suggest looking into some of those too boone.
Click to expand...
I went to a Fresh Market in Texas ... I love that store and they had an amazing selection of premium pints.
 
The Solution said:
GNO

I know you said you picked up birthday cake

Invalid Link Removed

^^ From a guy on another forum
Cotton Candy is just as good.
Click to expand...

Hell yeah!! I actually have both :) I might eat Bday Cake on my actual birthday later this month - I know I am a nerd lol
 
I was able to grab 6 Handel's pints from a road trip my boyyyyy mkretz made to the scoop shop. I started off with Oreo Dough which is vanilla ice cream with Oreo cookie pieces and cookie dough. The Solution has a review of his own of this flavour on ICI and he got it spot on... It sounds so simple, but it is so good. With the amount and the quality of the mixins Handel's uses this is an A+. Easily cracks my top 5 pints, beating Graeter's Buckeye.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    31 KB · Views: 255
GNO said:
I was able to grab 6 Handel's pints from a road trip my boyyyyy mkretz made to the scoop shop. I started off with Oreo Dough which is vanilla ice cream with Oreo cookie pieces and cookie dough. The Solution has a review of his own of this flavour on ICI and he got it spot on... It sounds so simple, but it is so good. With the amount and the quality of the mixins Handel's uses this is an A+. Easily cracks my top 5 pints, beating Graeter's Buckeye.
Click to expand...

If you thought this was good CCCD Is just as good. but more cookie dough mix-ins :)
Now another convert to the handels train LLN
 
Got a BOGO Coupon for Coldstone:
2x Gotta Have It Pumpkin Creations:

1) Pie in the Sky (Pumpkin ice cream + Whip Cream + Graham Cracker Pie Crust + Caramel)
2) Pumpkin Ice Cream + SnickerDoodle Cookies + Pecans + Caramel

Invalid Link Removed
 
I scooped Ample Hills Salted Crack Caramel tonight. The Solution
AH describes it as "Salted butter caramel ice cream with Deb's Famous Ctack cookies: saltine crackers coated with butter, sugar and chocolate".
Invalid Link Removed
I bought it off the description despite poor reviews, especially from PBI who said it taste like "burnt caramel".
On the first spoonful I got hit with a strong burnt caramel flavour that had me doubting this decision. However, it mellowed out after the third spoonful and for the rest of the pint, phew. On to the mix-ins, one word: amazing! I first hit them on the fourth or fifth spoonful and could not have come sooner. These crack cookies make this pint, if there were more and the base was a bit better maybe could be an A.
Rating: B-
 
GNO said:
I scooped Ample Hills Salted Crack Caramel tonight. The Solution
AH describes it as "Salted butter caramel ice cream with Deb's Famous Ctack cookies: saltine crackers coated with butter, sugar and chocolate".
Invalid Link Removed
I bought it off the description despite poor reviews, especially from PBI who said it taste like "burnt caramel".
On the first spoonful I got hit with a strong burnt caramel flavour that had me doubting this decision. However, it mellowed out after the third spoonful and for the rest of the pint, phew. On to the mix-ins, one word: amazing! I first hit them on the fourth or fifth spoonful and could not have come sooner. These crack cookies make this pint, if there were more and the base was a bit better maybe could be an A.
Rating: B-
Click to expand...

Ugh
Let me know how oatmeal cookie is
i bet its unreal.....



Speaking of ice cream
May make a handels run next weekend. Before i start my new job, may take a ride to columbus and hit TJ's, Handel's, Fresh Market (Mcconnells)

Cotton Candy + Birthday Cake from Handels
PB + Sweet Cream and Cookies (Mcconnells)
Gonna try to hit Pumpkin Pie Gelato from Gelato Fiasco if Fresh Market stores it

Columbus may be a ZOO of traffic they play MSU and ESPN will be there for 2 top 10 teams playing.
I think pittsburgh has a fresh market 15 minutes from the Handels i go to, may be a safer trip.
and one last stock up. time off will be limited.
 
Step 1) Go to the Gowanus location
Step 2) Order two 6 choice samplers
Step 3) Be disappointed at the ice cream to mix-ins ratio of 40:60
 
kdubson14 said:
Step 1) Go to the Gowanus location
Step 2) Order two 6 choice samplers
Step 3) Be disappointed at the ice cream to mix-ins ratio of 40:60
Click to expand...
KDubson which ic brands you like?

Any AH flavours you actually enjoyed?
 
They were all tasty, I'm just not a fan of 60% of my ice cream being chunks of... not ice cream haha. It Came from Gowanus and the Oatmeal Lace were my favorites from AH. The coconut milk based dark chocolate was very good too if you're a fan of straight bittersweet chocolate.

These days I'm gravitating more towards gelato from Dolcezza
 
Graeter's strikes a nice balance between mix-ins and ice creams for me. Ample Hills just goes way overboard. It would be better if their mix ins were smaller or evenly broken down, but finding two 1'' x .5'' x .5'' chunks of frozen whatever in every bite got pretty old, fast.
 
kdubson14 said:
Graeter's strikes a nice balance between mix-ins and ice creams for me. Ample Hills just goes way overboard. It would be better if their mix ins were smaller or evenly broken down, but finding two 1'' x .5'' x .5'' chunks of frozen whatever in every bite got pretty old, fast.
Click to expand...

I don't mind a eating halved oatmeal cookies in an ice cream offering or full peanut butter cups, cookies, etc. Just my personal preference.
 
Aleksandar37 said:
Yeah, balance is preferred, but I would rather have too much than barely any at all.
Click to expand...

Bingo
i have got my fair share of pints that were supposed to have plentiful mix-ins and had next to nothing. Which makes for buyers remorse on some flavors/brands. Sometimes you can not win every battle with ice cream. some are better than others
 
kdubson14 said:
They were all tasty, I'm just not a fan of 60% of my ice cream being chunks of... not ice cream haha. It Came from Gowanus and the Oatmeal Lace were my favorites from AH. The coconut milk based dark chocolate was very good too if you're a fan of straight bittersweet chocolate.

These days I'm gravitating more towards gelato from Dolcezza
Click to expand...

I read your previous post and mistakenly interpreted it as less mix-ins than base...I love my mix-ins so AH seems right down my alley. I really enjoyed the crack cookies in SCC so looking forward to the others.
 
GNO said:
I read your previous post and mistakenly interpreted it as less mix-ins than base...I love my mix-ins so AH seems right down my alley. I really enjoyed the crack cookies in SCC so looking forward to the others.
Click to expand...

Ample Hills is perfect for you then. Unfortunately it looks like only a few of their flavors are available online. The Gowanus and Prospect Heights locations have special flavors too. I think there are at least 14-18 on rotation daily at their shops.
 
kdubson14 said:
Ample Hills is perfect for you then. Unfortunately it looks like only a few of their flavors are available online. The Gowanus and Prospect Heights locations have special flavors too. I think there are at least 14-18 on rotation daily at their shops.
Click to expand...

Too bad we don't live in BRKLYN in new york.
I heard their pumpkin is unreal. Some guy did a review on bb.com and it looked ridiculous.
 
The Solution said:
They do. Many off bb.com who went there got hand packed pints and took back to their house.
Click to expand...

If you order AH The Solution don't hesitate to scoop Nonna D's oatmeal ...
No pic but base is nice & tons of cookie pieces of varying size. At first they were small then I started hitting bigger chunks lol. B+/A-... Only thing I would suggest is they add choc chunks to it.
 
GNO said:
If you order AH The Solution[/MENTION[B][I][U]] don't hesitate to scoop Nonna D's oatmeal ... [/U][/I][/B]
No pic but base is nice & tons of cookie pieces of varying size. At first they were small then I started hitting bigger chunks lol. B+/A-... Only thing I would suggest is they add choc chunks to it.[/QUOTE]

I told you that in your emails when you were considering 3 pints and not including the oatmeal in your selection (you wanted to split with marty)

many rank it better than the GOAT B&J Flavor OCC (Oatmeal cookie chunk) that is why i suggested it for you.

I will get these 6 flavors which i told you before:
Ooey Cake
Oatmeal Cookie
Raw Dough
Chocolate Milk & Cookie
Snap Mallow
Peanut Brittle

said the same thing last month (see below).. but i am making a handel's run next week so i will hold off for a bit. I already know what i plan to grab based off reviews.

[QUOTE="The Solution, post: 5133983, member: 148929"]

About to order an Ample hills
Snap Mallow Pop
Oatmeal
Raw Dough
Ooey Cake
Peanut Brittle
Chocolate Milk & Cookies

6 pints shipped for 70$ NOT bad at all.[/QUOTE]

[B]Invalid Link Removed[/B]
Click to expand...
 
The Solution said:
I told you that in your emails when you were considering 3 pints and not including the oatmeal in your selection (you wanted to split with marty)

many rank it better than the GOAT B&J Flavor OCC (Oatmeal cookie chunk) that is why i suggested it for you.

I will get these 6 flavors which i told you before:
Ooey Cake
Oatmeal Cookie
Raw Dough
Chocolate Milk & Cookie
Snap Mallow
Peanut Brittle

said the same thing last month (see below).. but i am making a handel's run next week so i will hold off for a bit. I already know what i plan to grab based off reviews.



Invalid Link Removed
Click to expand...

all of these flavors sound right up my alley... might ahve to put an order in here sometime I know I'll be home to receive it ha... cant have ice cream sitting on the porch for a week
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top