Extensive Flavor Review for ATW

pmiller383

pmiller383

Well-known member
I have tried just about every flavor at ATW now so I figured I would give a list of how I ranked them. All protein was mixed with water and will be judged on a 5 point scale with 5 being the best. Without Further ado:
  • Chocolate - 4
    Strong flavor in both the Isolate and Opti-Blend, very safe bet when ordering.
  • Vanilla - 4
    Great vanilla taste that isn't overly sweet, one of my favorite post workout flavors.
  • Banana - 5
    Great Flavor that mixes well with other flavors. My personal favorite to throw in oats and also my favorite to mix with chocolate milk protein isolate before bed.
  • Cinnamon bun - 5
    This stuff is great in water but amazing in milk. The perfect breakfast shake flavor
  • Strawberry - 4
    Good strawberry flavor, very similar to nesquick strawberry milk. Another good one for smoothies.
  • Orange - 3
    In just water it taste alright, pretty good postworkout when mixed with some dextrose. Not heavy on the pallet.
  • Chocolate Mint - 4
    Taste just like the ice cream, more like a dessert than a protein shake. Calms any sweet tooth.
  • Grape - 3
    Another one that is good when mixed with dextrose postworkout.
  • Pineapple - 4
    Surprisingly delightful. I was not expecting to like this one at all but it is outstandingly good. It is my favorite protein to dump into cottage cheese for a snack. Definitely worth having some around for those days when you need a change of pace.
  • Cake Batter - 5
    Spot on, was one of the best shakes I ever had when I mixed it with some plain frozen yogurt in a blender.
  • Key Lime - 4
    This was really good as well, super refreshing with some ice cold water.
  • Cappuccino - 6
    This stuff was off the charts good, hands down my favorite protein out of anything I have tried before in just straight whey or isolate. I don't know if I could have this around my house to long because I would easily go through 2lbs a week.
Thanks again for really turning around All The Whey customer service Marcus and bringing the company back into the spotlight here at AM. I hope everyone tries some of these great tasting, affordable proteins for themselves.
 
pmiller383 said:
I have tried just about every flavor at ATW now so I figured I would give a list of how I ranked them. All protein was mixed with water and will be judged on a 5 point scale with 5 being the best. Without Further ado:
  • Chocolate - 4
    Strong flavor in both the Isolate and Opti-Blend, very safe bet when ordering.
  • Vanilla - 4
    Great vanilla taste that isn't overly sweet, one of my favorite post workout flavors.
  • Banana - 5
    Great Flavor that mixes well with other flavors. My personal favorite to throw in oats and also my favorite to mix with chocolate milk protein isolate before bed.
  • Cinnamon bun - 5
    This stuff is great in water but amazing in milk. The perfect breakfast shake flavor
  • Strawberry - 4
    Good strawberry flavor, very similar to nesquick strawberry milk. Another good one for smoothies.
  • Orange - 3
    In just water it taste alright, pretty good postworkout when mixed with some dextrose. Not heavy on the pallet.
  • Chocolate Mint - 4
    Taste just like the ice cream, more like a dessert than a protein shake. Calms any sweet tooth.
  • Grape - 3
    Another one that is good when mixed with dextrose postworkout.
  • Pineapple - 4
    Surprisingly delightful. I was not expecting to like this one at all but it is outstandingly good. It is my favorite protein to dump into cottage cheese for a snack. Definitely worth having some around for those days when you need a change of pace.
  • Cake Batter - 5
    Spot on, was one of the best shakes I ever had when I mixed it with some plain frozen yogurt in a blender.
  • Key Lime - 4
    This was really good as well, super refreshing with some ice cold water.
  • Cappuccino - 6
    This stuff was off the charts good, hands down my favorite protein out of anything I have tried before in just straight whey or isolate. I don't know if I could have this around my house to long because I would easily go through 2lbs a week.
Thanks again for really turning around All The Whey customer service Marcus and bringing the company back into the spotlight here at AM. I hope everyone tries some of these great tasting, affordable proteins for themselves.
Click to expand...


word!

I remember at one point where ATW was hard to reach and the rep wasnt around much. Glad we have marcus now. He even emailed me to tell me that the order may be delayed due to X reason, which is really neat that he would go out of his way to let me/people know. Props to you :dance:


btw how does one go about ordering cappuccino? I want to try that now ;]
 
You a big coffee fan Paul? I am by no means a coffee enthusiast and have some cappuccino waiting to get tried (if I can pull myself from the cb and cake batter).
 
Yeah, I love coffee flavored stuff. Once in a while I will mix some instant coffee in with my oats and some splenda, so this protein was right up my ally.
 
PMiller383

pmiller383 said:
I have tried just about every flavor at ATW now so I figured I would give a list of how I ranked them. All protein was mixed with water and will be judged on a 5 point scale with 5 being the best. Without Further ado:
  • Chocolate - 4
    Strong flavor in both the Isolate and Opti-Blend, very safe bet when ordering.
  • Vanilla - 4
    Great vanilla taste that isn't overly sweet, one of my favorite post workout flavors.
  • Banana - 5
    Great Flavor that mixes well with other flavors. My personal favorite to throw in oats and also my favorite to mix with chocolate milk protein isolate before bed.
  • Cinnamon bun - 5
    This stuff is great in water but amazing in milk. The perfect breakfast shake flavor
  • Strawberry - 4
    Good strawberry flavor, very similar to nesquick strawberry milk. Another good one for smoothies.
  • Orange - 3
    In just water it taste alright, pretty good postworkout when mixed with some dextrose. Not heavy on the pallet.
  • Chocolate Mint - 4
    Taste just like the ice cream, more like a dessert than a protein shake. Calms any sweet tooth.
  • Grape - 3
    Another one that is good when mixed with dextrose postworkout.
  • Pineapple - 4
    Surprisingly delightful. I was not expecting to like this one at all but it is outstandingly good. It is my favorite protein to dump into cottage cheese for a snack. Definitely worth having some around for those days when you need a change of pace.
  • Cake Batter - 5
    Spot on, was one of the best shakes I ever had when I mixed it with some plain frozen yogurt in a blender.
  • Key Lime - 4
    This was really good as well, super refreshing with some ice cold water.
  • Cappuccino - 6
    This stuff was off the charts good, hands down my favorite protein out of anything I have tried before in just straight whey or isolate. I don't know if I could have this around my house to long because I would easily go through 2lbs a week.
Thanks again for really turning around All The Whey customer service Marcus and bringing the company back into the spotlight here at AM. I hope everyone tries some of these great tasting, affordable proteins for themselves.
Click to expand...
Your Welcome thanx 4 the post!!!
 
pmiller383 said:
I have tried just about every flavor at ATW now so I figured I would give a list of how I ranked them. All protein was mixed with water and will be judged on a 5 point scale with 5 being the best. Without Further ado:
  • Chocolate - 4
    Strong flavor in both the Isolate and Opti-Blend, very safe bet when ordering.
  • Vanilla - 4
    Great vanilla taste that isn't overly sweet, one of my favorite post workout flavors.
  • Banana - 5
    Great Flavor that mixes well with other flavors. My personal favorite to throw in oats and also my favorite to mix with chocolate milk protein isolate before bed.
  • Cinnamon bun - 5
    This stuff is great in water but amazing in milk. The perfect breakfast shake flavor
  • Strawberry - 4
    Good strawberry flavor, very similar to nesquick strawberry milk. Another good one for smoothies.
  • Orange - 3
    In just water it taste alright, pretty good postworkout when mixed with some dextrose. Not heavy on the pallet.
  • Chocolate Mint - 4
    Taste just like the ice cream, more like a dessert than a protein shake. Calms any sweet tooth.
  • Grape - 3
    Another one that is good when mixed with dextrose postworkout.
  • Pineapple - 4
    Surprisingly delightful. I was not expecting to like this one at all but it is outstandingly good. It is my favorite protein to dump into cottage cheese for a snack. Definitely worth having some around for those days when you need a change of pace.
  • Cake Batter - 5
    Spot on, was one of the best shakes I ever had when I mixed it with some plain frozen yogurt in a blender.
  • Key Lime - 4
    This was really good as well, super refreshing with some ice cold water.
  • Cappuccino - 6
    This stuff was off the charts good, hands down my favorite protein out of anything I have tried before in just straight whey or isolate. I don't know if I could have this around my house to long because I would easily go through 2lbs a week.
Thanks again for really turning around All The Whey customer service Marcus and bringing the company back into the spotlight here at AM. I hope everyone tries some of these great tasting, affordable proteins for themselves.
Click to expand...

Banana seems tempting, I used to use biotest's metabolic drive in banana- it would be great if this was similiar......also, cupcake batter- as in chocolate? did you try just in water?
 
Good Shepherd said:
Banana seems tempting, I used to use biotest's metabolic drive in banana- it would be great if this was similiar......also, cupcake batter- as in chocolate? did you try just in water?
Click to expand...
No, the cupcake batter was a yellow cake i guess, (not chocolate or funfetti lol) and it was good in water. Trust me ATW's banana is the Bee's Knees
 
pmiller383 said:
No, the cupcake batter was a yellow cake i guess, (not chocolate or funfetti lol) and it was good in water. Trust me ATW's banana is the Bee's Knees
Click to expand...

nice, I was a little hesitant to order because of reading of some shipping issues....it seems like that is being corrected
 
pmiller383 said:
No, the cupcake batter was a yellow cake i guess, (not chocolate or funfetti lol) and it was good in water. Trust me ATW's banana is the Bee's Knees
Click to expand...

it doesn't taste like a real banana milkshake or anything, but it is closer to that than it is most banana protein flavors and their laffy taffy-ness. not too sweet, not too candy like, but definitely not like you made a fresh milkshake with banana. I'd give it a 3.5-4/5
 
SO things are looking up huh? Maybe I will place an order again, I refused to purchase after Laura left, and customer service hit rock bottom.

Good to see the turn around Marcus.

Adams
 
DAdams91982 said:
SO things are looking up huh? Maybe I will place an order again, I refused to purchase after Laura left, and customer service hit rock bottom.

Good to see the turn around Marcus.

Adams
Click to expand...

i also didn't order from ATW for awhile after a bad experience awhile back and hearing about other's bad experiences, but was too tempted by the cupcake batter flavor to say no. the service i got from marcus was excellent, he emailed me 5 or 6 times to keep me updated :clap2:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top