I think it's kinda hard to tell at this point. Considering that LR has been around for some time, and known to work wonders, it's really hard to judge and compare. Why? Most people have been going on and on about recreate when they A) havent tried it for themselves B) Most people havent even finished it. LR has been known by many to work wonders. I don't know why people are going so crazy over recreate, People are saying it works so well, when it hasnt even been release long enough to really tell. I usually take beta logs with a grain of salt. In my opinion, recreate is hyped up right now, as LR has worked well for most people. It's unfair to compare as there probably isnt enough people to testify this.