The Unofficial Ice Cream thread

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Pal's Pint:

Caffe Panna Pal's Pint |

Caffe Panna Pal's Pint CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on delicious ice c

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

" Sweet cream base with a peach swirl and cinnamon crunch"
Grade: B

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Pistachio Explosion:
Grade: A+

A pistachio base ice cream, fig caramel swirl, and oatmeal cookies

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/691/caffe-panna-pistachio-explosion

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Bob's Dream:
Grade: A

Peanut butter ice cream, salted cookie dough, fudge swirl, chocolate cookie crunch

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/692/caffe-panna-bobs-dream

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Make My Cannoli Dream Come True

"Mascarpone lightly zested with orange ice cream, cannoli shells crushed from Settepani Bakery, and a swirl made of cannoli filling kissed with cinnamon."

Caffe Panna Make My Cannoli Dream Come True |

Caffe Panna Make My Cannoli Dream Come True CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphas

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Grade: B+

 

[The Solution]

New flavor from B and J
Target find so far

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Pecran Puff:
Grade: B
Chocolate ice cream with candied pecans, tangy cranberry swirl and house made cranberry marshmallow

Caffe Panna PeCran Puff |

Caffe Panna PeCran Puff CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on delicious ice

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Pumpkin Ranger

Grade: B+

Pumpkin ice cream, housemade chocolate fudge chunks, salted caramel, and graham crunch.

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/698/caffe-panna-pumpkin-ranger

 

[ndiguy]

Really craving some Birthday Cake Remix from Cold Stone, right about now...

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Gingie's Pie:
Grade: A-

Graham cracker ice cream with pumpkin pie swirl and gingerbread crunch

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/699/caffe-panna-gingies-pie

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna CB Snick:


Grade: A

We infuse coffee beans into our sweet cream resulting in a beautiful white bright coffee flavor. Then we layer in crunch coated snickerdoodle cookie dough because it’s fall, plus a spice cookie swirl.

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/700/caffe-panna-cb-snick

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Our Favorite:

Grade: B-

Mascarpone ice cream kissed with cooked down market Concord grapes with pear compote swirled throughout. Sprinkle Graham Crunch on top of this one!"

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/701/caffe-panna-favorite

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Nocciola Buns:

Grade: C

Piemontese Hazelnut ice cream with toffee crunchies, sweet potato bun swirl made with our favorite breakfast good from Millers & Makers

Caffe Panna Nocciola Buns |

Caffe Panna Nocciola Buns CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on delicious ice cream

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Butterfinger:

Caffe Panna Butterfinger |

Caffe Panna Buttefinger CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on delicious ice

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Grade: B-
Caramel cream ice cream with butterfinger candy and peanut butter flecks". A take on one of America's classic candies laced within one of America's best ice cream. How can you go wrong

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Casserole:

Grade: A
Sweet potato ice cream with cinnamarsh swirl and candied pecans

Caffe Panna Casserole |

Caffe Panna Casserole CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on delicious ice cr

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Strong Rope:

Grade: B-

Story Time Stout ice cream with housemade pecan pie crust and filling, plus a cocoa caramel swirl"

Caffe Panna Strong Rope |

Caffe Panna Strong Rope CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on delicious ice

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Panna World:
Grade: B+

Salted chocolate peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter flecks, oreo brittle and graham crunch (pretty much everything you all ask for!) Top this one with Panna and make an affogato out of it

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/708/caffe-panna-world

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Chocolate Toffee Pistachio

Caffe Panna Chocolate Toffee Pistachio |

Caffe Panna Chocolate Toffee Pistachio CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emp

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Milk chocolate based with a swirl of Sicilian pistachios with toffee shards.

Grade: A+

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Frutti di Biscotti:

Grade: B

Panna-enriched sweet cream is the backdrop to chunks of our housemade hazelnut biscotti and Marco Colzani’s Frutti di Bosco preserves, imported and made with Italian wild berries. For this pint, we only bake the cookies once (instead of twice as is traditional with ours and most BIscotti). The hazelnuts are from Terra delle Nocciole, a small nut grower located in Piemonte, Italy. Three fantastic Italian products in one pint!

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/714/caffe-panna-frutti-di-biscotti

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Wholly Cannoli:

Grade: B

A wholly cannoli experience. Our favorite Italian bakery in NYC is Settepani Bakery and their cannolis are superb! The base ice cream of this pint is kissed with Sicilian pistachios and mascarpone for added richness. Then we swirl in cannoli filling and freshly baked pistachio coated cannoli shells."

Caffe Panna Wholly Cannoli |

Caffe Panna Wholly Cannoli CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on delicious i

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Chunky Velvet:

Grade: B+

Coconutty cream cheese ice cream made with coconut cream and flecked with shards of Amano chocolate for a cocoa punch, plus Red Velvet chunks from our friends at Blondery and — maybe our favorite house mixin here at Caffè Panna — candied pecans.

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/715/caffe-panna-chunky-velvet

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Sweet Dough:

Grade: B+

Callebaut Chocolate chip studded brown sugar and Heilala vanilla bean ice cream with chunks of salted chocolate chip cookie dough. The base has molasses notes that bring out the depth in the dough that SweetDoughNYC makes for us!

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/713/caffe-panna-sweet-dough

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Banilla Killa:

Grade: A-

Heilala vanilla bean and fresh banana ice cream with candied Nilla wafers and a deep butterscotch caramel. Big Banoffee vibes!

Caffe Panna Banilla Killa |

Caffe Panna Banilla Killa CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on delicious ic

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna You Win:

Grade: A+
Everything you always ask for. So we obliged. Just promise you’ll still let us make other flavors. Milk chocolate ice cream with marshmallow swirl, caramel swirl, oreo brittle, and obviously Reese’s cups. Enjoy."

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/716/caffe-panna-win

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Brightland:

Grade: C

Smooth olive oil ice cream made with Brightland heirloom Frantoio olive oil with a hint of lemon and Italian wild berries, plus swirls of lemon curd to bring out the fruitiness. Try the graham crunch on top of this one, or scoop it on top of a bowl of berries.

Caffe Panna Brightland |

Caffe Panna Brightland CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on delicious ice c

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Passionfruit Stracciatella

Grade: C
puckery creamy passionfruit ice cream kissed with Italian wildflower honey. And fruity Amano chocolate shards to round out the punchy flavor."

Review:

Caffe Panna Passionfruit Stracciatella |

Caffe Panna Passionfruit Stracciatella CaffePanna's goal is to bring that same welcoming spirit and all-day accessibility to the heart of New York City, with an emphasis on

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Dalgona:

Grade: B+

Ice cream that tastes like a latte (coffee with Italian imported panna!) and marshmallow swirl with a cinnamon dusting on top just like a cup of Dalgona coffee.

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/721/caffe-panna-dalgona

 

[beefyfan]

As I get older, I have less and less of an affinity for ice cream. At least as a stand alone. If you're talking about a hot brownie or cookie sundae, we're in business. Every now and then, maybe a blizzard or mcflurry or with a good piece of cake. Shakes and malts ate A-ok as well. I just never, ever have the gumption to eat a bowl of ice cream. Just me I guess. Unfortunately, my wife eats enough for the both of us.

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Panna PB Cup

Grade: A-

Smooth peanut butter ice cream, handmade peanut butter cups from our friends @cuppeddesserts, thick panna caramel, graham crunch

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/723/caffe-panna-pb-cup

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Razzy Prezz:

Grade: A-

Piemontese hazelnut kissed chocolate ice cream, raspberry swirl, pretzel brittle, chocolate-coated mini pretzels

Full Review:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/720/caffe-panna-razzy-prezz

 

[beefyfan]

You are making me rethink my stance on ice cream.

 

[booneman77]

You are making me rethink my stance on ice cream.

if you have a stance on ice cream that is anything other than "GIMME MOAR" you're in the wrong place haha

 

[The Solution]

Caffe Panna Pecan Carrot Cake

Grade: A+

Toasted pecan ice cream, chunks of Lloyd’s famous Carrot Cake, candied pecan crumble, and a spiced cream cheese swirl

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/722/caffe-panna-pecan-carrot-cake

 

[The Solution]

Ben & Jerry's Whisky Biz:
Full Review:

Ben & Jerry's Topped Whisky Biz |

Ben & Jerry's Topped Whisky Biz Ben & Jerry's Topped Whisky Biz is labeled as "Brown Butter Bourbon Ice Cream with Blonde Brownies & Whiskey Caramel Swirls Topp

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Grade: C

Brown Butter Bourbon Ice Cream with Blonde Brownies & Whiskey Caramel Swirls Topped with White Chocolatey Ganache & White Fudge Chunks

 

[chainsaw]

Came across these

 

[robshef]

Came across these

Are those as good as they look??

 

[The Solution]

Ben & Jerry's Tiramisu

Ben & Jerry's Topped Tiramisu |

Ben & Jerry's Topped Tiramisu Ben & Jerry's Topped Tiramisu is labeled as "Mascarpone Ice Cream with Fudge Swirls & Shortbread Pieces Topped with Espresso Fudge

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Grade: B+

Mascarpone Ice Cream with Fudge Swirls & Shortbread Pieces Topped with Espresso Fudge Chunks & Chocolatey Ganache

 

[booneman77]

Ben & Jerry's Tiramisu

Ben & Jerry's Topped Tiramisu |

Ben & Jerry's Topped Tiramisu Ben & Jerry's Topped Tiramisu is labeled as "Mascarpone Ice Cream with Fudge Swirls & Shortbread Pieces Topped with Espresso Fudge

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Grade: B+

Mascarpone Ice Cream with Fudge Swirls & Shortbread Pieces Topped with Espresso Fudge Chunks & Chocolatey Ganache

This was far and away my favorite of the topped ones... the strawberry one was second but the topping on it was horrible and almost ruined it at the start. had to eat that off and get to the better part but overall it was a bit "fakey".

 

[booneman77]

Came across these

these look amazing... where from?

 

[chainsaw]

these look amazing... where from?

They are nightengale, they are based out of Richmond, but I found a grocery store in wexford, pa (outside Pittsburgh). Only other option is get them shipped from goldbelly. Best ice cream sandwich I ever had

 

[The Solution]

They are nightengale, they are based out of Richmond, but I found a grocery store in wexford, pa (outside Pittsburgh). Only other option is get them shipped from goldbelly. Best ice cream sandwich I ever had

Check out Graeters on Perry Highway. Grab the Chip Wheelies.
They also have a Black Raspberry Cookies & Cream Bonus flavor available till the end of the week.
They should be doing new flavors every 2 weeks the next 4-6 weeks. May be worth scooping.
1870 tower is the play if you eat in for Graeters in Pitt/Wexford.

 

[chainsaw]

Check out Graeters on Perry Highway. Grab the Chip Wheelies.
They also have a Black Raspberry Cookies & Cream Bonus flavor available till the end of the week.
They should be doing new flavors every 2 weeks the next 4-6 weeks. May be worth scooping.
1870 tower is the play if you eat in for Graeters in Pitt/Wexford.

Been there my friend, black raspberry is the bomb, just got some of there orange cream last week.... however nightingale ice cream sandwiches are so unique and really hard to beat. Next time you head down 79 stop at t-bones market exit 73 wexford. They have the multiple flavors of nightingale sandwiches there.

 

[The Solution]

Been there my friend, black raspberry is the bomb, just got some of there orange cream last week.... however nightingale ice cream sandwiches are so unique and really hard to beat. Next time you head down 79 stop at t-bones market exit 73 wexford. They have the multiple flavors of nightingale sandwiches there.

Be down either this weekend or next. My brother just had their 2nd kid. So I will be down to visit and hit Oakmont Bakery (if you are a big sweets person)

 

[chainsaw]

Be down either this weekend or next. My brother just had their 2nd kid. So I will be down to visit and hit Oakmont Bakery (if you are a big sweets person)

We speak the same language

 

[chainsaw]

Are those as good as they look??

Top notch ice cream is high quality and holds up while you eat the cookie. Fat banana is my favorite, nothing like it.

 

[The Solution]

Living the Cream PB Nana Gooey Pie:

Grade: C+

Graham cracker ice cream, brown sugar graham crumble, marshmallow swirls, and peanut butter-banana ooey gooey butter cake.

Full Review Here:
https://theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net/thread/730/living-cream-nana-gooey-pie

 

[The Solution]

Living the Cream Brookie Remix

Living the Cream Brookie Remix |

Living the Cream Brookie Remix Living the Cream is a small business out of Buffalo. The guy is churning up some masterpieces out of his own kitchen. I luckily found him off Instag

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Grade: B

Oreo ice cream, chocolate chip cookie dough, and half baked brownies

 

[The Solution]

Living The Cream Blackout Brownie:

Living the Cream Blackout Brownie |

Living the Cream Blackout Brownie Living the Cream is a small business out of Buffalo. The guy is churning up some masterpieces out of his own kitchen. I luckily found him off Ins

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Dark chocolate ice cream, Guittard extra dark stracciatella, half-baked dark chocolate brownies

Grade: B-

 

[The Solution]

Living the Cream Lookin' Like a Snack

Living the Cream Lookin' Like a Snack |

Living the Cream Lookin' Like a Snack Living the Cream is a small business out of Buffalo. The guy is churning up some masterpieces out of his own kitchen. I luckily found him

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

"Malt Ice Cream, potato chip crusted brownies, salty pretzel crunch, and peanut butter swirls"
Grade: B+

 

[The Solution]

Living the Cream Basic Bob:
Grade: B+

Living the Cream Basic B.O.B |

Living the Cream Basic B.O.B Living the Cream is a small business out of Buffalo. The guy is churning up some masterpieces out of his own kitchen. I luckily found him off Instagram d

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Chocolate ice cream, peanut butter frosting swirls, peanut butter Oreos, and chewy peanut butter blondies

 

[The Solution]

Living the Cream Bob's Birthday

Living the Cream Bob's Birthday |

Living the Cream Bob's Birthday Living the Cream is a small business out of Buffalo. The guy is churning up some masterpieces out of his own kitchen. I luckily found him off Instagram due to hi

theicecreaminformant.freeforums.net

Vegan peanut butter ice cream, brownie batter swirls, oreo chunks, and salted peanut butter chocolate chip cookie dough chunks.

Grade: A-