Myprotein Whey Flavors

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah I open two at a time typically just in case one is horrible and another is decent so I can mix them. Both blueberry and pineapple are extremely chemically tasting mostly in the aftertaste. Given the only real fruit flavored protein I have had for comparison is XF Arctic Lemonade which is a high standard to live up to.
 
booneman77 said:
Oh might not have missed anything... iirc the last few reviews I saw were awful... terms like chemical, fake, etc were all thrown around
Click to expand...
Ya and I saw some saying that as well, lol...just wanted to try it for myself since taste is so subjective...case in point, using the rocky road, above someone says it has almost a fruity taste and thinks it's horrible...I think it's ok, choc variant with subtle marshmallow cream flavor. Wouldn't buy it again but I don't hate it and have no problem getting it down.
 
schizm said:
Ya and I saw some saying that as well, lol...just wanted to try it for myself since taste is so subjective...case in point, using the rocky road, above someone says it has almost a fruity taste and thinks it's horrible...I think it's ok, choc variant with subtle marshmallow cream flavor. Wouldn't buy it again but I don't hate it and have no problem getting it down.
Click to expand...

Agreed. Most of their flavorings are on the "light" side which leaves a lot of room for interpretation depending how much water/scoop people use.
 
I bought another big bag of Mocha cause it's probably my favorite protein so far.

Salted caramel for me is very sweet but no salt like you guys said.

The diet whey vanilla cookie smells like fish food but the taste is okay.
 
I just brought out a bag of peanut cookie ive had for awhile. heard a lot of mixed reviews on it (surprise surprise)...

Still ahve rhubarb and custard and pecan pie in the stash.
 
I just brought out a bag of peanut cookie ive had for awhile. heard a lot of mixed reviews on it (surprise surprise)...

Still ahve rhubarb and custard and pecan pie in the stash.
 
booneman77 said:
I just brought out a bag of peanut cookie ive had for awhile. heard a lot of mixed reviews on it (surprise surprise)...

Still ahve rhubarb and custard and pecan pie in the stash.
Click to expand...

Peanut cookie is not good solo, but when combined with some sort of chocolate it is decent. I know you have loads of already opened flavors laying around so you won't have any issues with it.
 
Chocolate Coconut
Taste: 2/5
Consistency: 4/5
Price: 5/5
Miscibility: 5/5
Overall: 3/5

I was anticipating to taste Chocolate coconut flavor, but it was a big disappointment. I do not really find the chocolate taste from it, it is just really overpowered by the coconut. This would be quite nice / ok flavor, but there is this weird aftertaste on it.

Wont order again.
 
Hemavol said:
Chocolate Coconut
Taste: 2/5
Consistency: 4/5
Price: 5/5
Miscibility: 5/5
Overall: 3/5

I was anticipating to taste Chocolate coconut flavor, but it was a big disappointment. I do not really find the chocolate taste from it, it is just really overpowered by the coconut. This would be quite nice / ok flavor, but there is this weird aftertaste on it.

Wont order again.
Click to expand...

I wasn't a fan of the Chocolate Coconut either. Very weak flavor for both chocolate and coconut. I struggled to get through my 5.5lb bag haha
 
Of the flavors I've tried so far, thinking like 4 or 5, cinnamon roll had been the best flavor. Not as light as the others, very pronounced. I have white candy cane on the way.
 
schizm said:
Of the flavors I've tried so far, thinking like 4 or 5, cinnamon roll had been the best flavor. Not as light as the others, very pronounced. I have white candy cane on the way.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the update. I have yet to try the cinnamon roll, but now I'll probably have to give it a try. Salted caramel still stands as my favorite to date
 
White candy cane, was really hoping for a shamrock shake style mint but it actually is candy cane-ish. Decent but probably not one I'd order again. But with all things flavor, ymmv.
 
Stracciatella
Taste: 4/5
Consistency: 4/5
Price: 5/5
Miscibility: 5/5
Overall: 4/5

Stracciatella is one of those Myprotein flavors where you just cannot go wrong. Tastes like ice cream with chocolate flakes, really good. Keep in mind that I do not give 5/5 for flavor easily..

It is really hard to put the best flavors I've tried in particular order, but here is what I would recommend:
Chocolate Caramel (this is definitely top1 for me, hands down)
Choco Cereal
Chocolate Brownie
Salted Caramel
Stracciatella

I wont recommend:
Coconut Chocolate
Chocolate Peanut
Smooth Chocolate (I know this flavor is topped by many people but I did not like it.. there is a lot better ones around).
 
schizm said:
Of the flavors I've tried so far, thinking like 4 or 5, cinnamon roll had been the best flavor. Not as light as the others, very pronounced. I have white candy cane on the way.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the cinnamon bun recommendation.... officially my new favorite flavor. It tastes like cinnamon toast crunch! Definitely a much more flavorful taste than most of their other flavors. Thanks again bro
 
Hemavol said:
Stracciatella
Taste: 4/5
Consistency: 4/5
Price: 5/5
Miscibility: 5/5
Overall: 4/5

Stracciatella is one of those Myprotein flavors where you just cannot go wrong. Tastes like ice cream with chocolate flakes, really good. Keep in mind that I do not give 5/5 for flavor easily..

It is really hard to put the best flavors I've tried in particular order, but here is what I would recommend:
Chocolate Caramel (this is definitely top1 for me, hands down)
Choco Cereal
Chocolate Brownie
Salted Caramel
Stracciatella

I wont recommend:
Coconut Chocolate
Chocolate Peanut
Smooth Chocolate (I know this flavor is topped by many people but I did not like it.. there is a lot better ones around).
Click to expand...
john.patterson said:
Thanks for the cinnamon bun recommendation.... officially my new favorite flavor. It tastes like cinnamon toast crunch! Definitely a much more flavorful taste than most of their other flavors. Thanks again bro
Click to expand...
Thanks for the recommendations! I have some of their regular chocolate protein, and it's not bad, but sort of light, but since it's such a good price I just picked up 5.5lbs of the cinnamon bun and 2.2lbs of the salted caramel. It's such a good price. I use 1.5 scoops (30g protein), and it still came out to be like $0.66 per serving (that's including shipping) and it came with a free shaker bottle.
 
john.patterson said:
Thanks for the cinnamon bun recommendation.... officially my new favorite flavor. It tastes like cinnamon toast crunch! Definitely a much more flavorful taste than most of their other flavors. Thanks again bro
Click to expand...
No problem man! They really did up the bar on their flavor game with that one :)
I have some Vanilla and Cookies n Cream headed to me now to try out.
 
Cinnamon Danish
Taste: 4/5
Consistency: 4/5
Price: 5/5
Miscibility: 5/5
Overall: 4/5

Cinnamon danish is one of those Myprotein flavors which is on point. Tastes like cinnamon bun, really good. Also one of those flavors that I use also for cooking (oats, salt, cinnamon + cinnamon danish = perfect breakfast).

I've also purchased following flavors: Chocolate Banana, Neapolitan, Jam roly-poly, Chocolate Mint... so stay tuned for these.

It is really hard to put the best flavors I've tried in particular order, but here is what I would recommend:
Chocolate Caramel (this is definitely best out of these for me, hands down)
Choco Cereal
Chocolate Brownie
Salted Caramel
Cinnamon Danish
Stracciatella


I wont recommend:
Coconut Chocolate
Chocolate Peanut
Smooth Chocolate (I know this flavor is topped by many people but I did not like it.. there is a lot better ones around).
 
Broke into the rhubarb and custard last night... very impressed. As with most of these, its not the strongest of flavors, but it truly nails the rhubarb flavor. Its not overly sweet or sour, and the custard is more of an afternote, but if you like rhubarb/pie, this is worth a pickup if for no reason other than its unique, and tastes like real rhubarb.
 
Just switched to MyProtein Impact Whey after mostly running "zero" carb brands.

Thought I'd join in with my thoughts on the flavours I've had so far.

Latte
Went through 1kg of this quite quickly because I enjoyed it more than real food. :-)

White Chocolate (Sample)
Actually couldn't taste anything at all. I love white chocolate and I've had white chocolate protein powder from other (less acclaimed) companies and was really disappointed with this one.

Coffee Caramel (Sample)
Did not like. The caramel flavouring tasted weird to me, which is interesting because...

Salted Caramel (Sample)
Really enjoyed this one. A lot of people say that the flavour is a little weak, but I thought it was good. Ordered more.

I have Sticky Toffee Pudding and Peanut Cookie samples arriving today.
 
Neapolitan
Taste: 3/5
Consistency: 4/5
Price: 5/5
Miscibility: 5/5
Overall: 4/5

Neapolitan drops to the middleground for me, not bad but not special either. If you had ever eaten neapolitan ice-cream and have mixed the flavors together, this comes actually really close to that flavor. Only reason why this is not getting 4 for taste is the fact that the strawberry flavor is too strong and artificial. If they would fix this flavor or tone it down, it would be a killer.


Chocolate Mint
Taste: 4/5
Consistency: 4/5
Price: 5/5
Miscibility: 5/5
Overall: 4/5

Again one of those flavors that people have hyped a lot in this thread and I gotta say that there is no question why.. This flavor is on top, only thing I would change is that I would tone down the minty part a little bit. It is overtaking too much in my opinion. But anyway this is a flavor that you can't go wrong with.

It is really hard to put the best flavors I've tried in particular order, but here is what I would recommend:
Chocolate Caramel (this is definitely best out of these for me, hands down)
Choco Cereal
Chocolate Brownie
Salted Caramel
Cinnamon Danish
Stracciatella
Chocolate Mint


Neutral:
Neapolitan


I wont recommend:
Coconut Chocolate
Chocolate Peanut
Smooth Chocolate (I know this flavor is topped by many people but I did not like it.. there is a lot better ones around).
 
Chocolate mint is a million times my favorite, but I love chocolate mint anything.
 
warnerve said:
Gotta hurry but they are having some sort of flash sale for a few hours, I just got two 11 lbers for 99 dollars shipped. Code is flash20 but it's right on the site, you'll see it.
Click to expand...

They run sales like this pretty regularly. Almost every month. Their prices are flat out unbeatable
 
I'm sorry if someone addressed this already, but I'm very close to buying Chocolate Mint and Cinnamon Danish, which are two flavors I love. However... I keep looking at the Pumpkin Pie flavor, which is my favorite kind of pie. It seems like a huge gamble... but can anyone speak for it?
 
Martyfnemec said:
I'm sorry if someone addressed this already, but I'm very close to buying Chocolate Mint and Cinnamon Danish, which are two flavors I love. However... I keep looking at the Pumpkin Pie flavor, which is my favorite kind of pie. It seems like a huge gamble... but can anyone speak for it?
Click to expand...

I can tell you cinnamon roll is my fav flavor that I've tried. I haven't tried pumpkin pie, but I would think I'd get tired of that kind of flavor before I made it through 5 lbs.
 
Rebel1978 said:
I can tell you cinnamon roll is my fav flavor that I've tried. I haven't tried pumpkin pie, but I would think I'd get tired of that kind of flavor before I made it through 5 lbs.
Click to expand...
Being someone who could positively live on pumpkin pie and Cool Whip, I just need to know if they nailed the flavor or not. Lol.
 
I'm not sure. It is on the USA site. I couldn't pull the trigger on the pumpkin pie as I was buying the 11 lb bags and I didn't want to be stuck with a huge bag of it. I went with cinnamon roll and strawberry cream this time around.
 
Yeah, I found a pretty big flavor poll on reddit, and I can't see pumpkin pie. One guy said that it is not sweet enough, which is weird for Myprotein.

Anyways, I like Blueberry Cheesecake, Chocolate Banana, Chocolate Mint, Mocha, Latte
 
mbonheur said:
Yeah, I found a pretty big flavor poll on reddit, and I can't see pumpkin pie. One guy said that it is not sweet enough, which is weird for Myprotein.

Anyways, I like Blueberry Cheesecake, Chocolate Banana, Chocolate Mint, Mocha, Latte
Click to expand...

If I saw blueberry cheesecake, I might have gone with that one. Just thinking about the sheer amount of flavors is giving me a tiny bit of anxiety!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top