Guest viewing limit reached
  • You have reached the maximum number of guest views allowed
  • Please register below to remove this limitation

Creatine Has Unknown Effects on Young Athletes

yeahright

Well-known member
Supplement Has Unknown Effects on Young Athletes
Posted by:
Baylor College of Medicine
on 06-18-2006.

"Creatine monohydrate, a dietary supplement often marketed as a way to enhance athletic performance and to increase weight, muscle size and strength, could cause health problems for some adolescents."

Creatine Dietary Supplement


Adolescent athletes who take creatine to "bulk up" should do so with caution.

Creatine monohydrate, a dietary supplement often marketed as a way to enhance athletic performance and to increase weight, muscle size and strength, could cause health problems for some adolescents.

"Creatine is found naturally in the body and is essential for your muscles during quick, high-intensity exercise, said Dr. Joseph Chorley, an assistant professor of pediatrics, adolescent and sports medicine at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston. "However, there are no quality safety tests that define its short-term and long-term side effects."

It is generally considered safe for adult athletes, however, there is little information about potential health risks for young athletes. Creatine is produced by the liver, kidneys and pancreas, and is also found in fish and meat

Creatine works in the body by delivering a three- to 10-second energy boost to the muscles, allowing you to reach your maximum effort while exercising. However, when muscles run out of creatine, the body relies on its natural supply of carbohydrates for energy, causing muscles to tire. The most common side effects are muscle tears, kidney disorders, dehydration, diarrhea and cramping.

"For parents who are concerned that their child might be using creatine, their worry is appropriate," Chorley said. "We do not have a clear idea of what adverse reactions could occur, nor do we know how creatine could interact with prescription medications."

To increase size and performance, Chorley recommends following a properly balanced diet and adequate fluid intake as well as planned strength training.
 
I would like to know what data or references they used to come to their conclusion - "Creatine Monohydrate ....could cause health problems for some adolescents." Many things "could" cause health problems for some adolescents. Nothing worse than speculative articles. I guess that topic would be a good thesis for someone to do in their graduate studies.
 
What's more we have studies of use up to five years and 20 grams with no observed negative effects Second, how the **** does anyone know if there are unknown effects? Pure idiot yellow journalism.
 
what's even crazier is that is from a "school of medicine". I can't imagine the hack Dr's they are pumping out.
 
sock said:
what's even crazier is that is from a "school of medicine". I can't imagine the hack Dr's they are pumping out.

anyones Kidneys every fill like they are twicking on creatine?:bruce1:
 
"Unknown Problems"

That's pretty much the same as saying "No Problems"..isn't it???

You could make these statements about every single man made drug ever produced...but they wouldn't do that now would they?
 
dangerous for adolescents and no one else? what separates this group fromt he rest of humanity and substaniates creatine might have negative effects only towards them, putting aside of course, that i have not heard of one person ever suffering any serious side effects except the Sh!ts.

OFTEN advertised as a strength and muscle builder? its not really a question, it science and the author of this article should look into it instead of pulling subjective statments out of his/her ass.
 
anabolicrhino said:
its a ticking time bomb and a gateway drug supported wholly by the terrorists. Micronized death!!! Esterfied evil!!!


It's time to put out a dcoumentary called "Monohydrate Madness".
 
sock said:
I would like to know what data or references they used to come to their conclusion - "Creatine Monohydrate ....could cause health problems for some adolescents." Many things "could" cause health problems for some adolescents. Nothing worse than speculative articles. I guess that topic would be a good thesis for someone to do in their graduate studies.

I agree.
 
jomi822 said:
dangerous for adolescents and no one else? what separates this group fromt he rest of humanity and substaniates creatine might have negative effects only towards them, putting aside of course, that i have not heard of one person ever suffering any serious side effects except the Sh!ts.

OFTEN advertised as a strength and muscle builder? its not really a question, it science and the author of this article should look into it instead of pulling subjective statments out of his/her ass.

That's the problem with the media. Instead of getting the facts correct, they instead go for the statments that garner more attention; which in turn, generates more adverting $. It is difficult to believe anything written or reported anymore. Thank god for this forum, besides anecdotal data, I have seen links posted numerous times to studies that elucidate the effectiveness of many compounds. If one knows where to look, much information can be obtained. It is ashame that an academic institution is lowering the standards. The only positive is that an article like this would not be published in any scientific journal. It is pure rubbish.
 
Story for ya. Back in the day... 3 years ago. I walked into a Health Food store to purchase some Creatine Monohydrate. I was like SWEET ASS! A product to help me with endurance. So I'm looking at it and some jack-o-lantern walks in and looks at the protein powders. I'm discussing the creatine with the health food store owner. Then jack-o interrupts and says "Ya better not get that Creatine... It messed up my liver REAAL bad. And It'll get you too. I had bad lower back pain on it!! Better watch out." "So after he said that I looked back at the store owner and said, Yeah I'll go ahead and take this one" Go **** your mother jack-o.
 
My god, thanks for the creatine awareness. I didn't know this crap was that heavily used by teens, lets ban and problem solved. We all know creatine is also grown by the Taliban and smuggled to the states through their GW Bush connection, and they used this $$$ to take down the towers :rolleyes:
 
I bet water has unknown effects on young atheletes as well.

You really do have to watch the unknown dangers. I don't even leave my house anymore because of them. Workout or excercise? No way amigo..just too many unknown effects. What if I grow another head or something. Then people would call me Zaphod and that wouldn't be cool.

Now I just sit home, eat trans fats and chain smoke because at least I KNOW how this stuff is going to kill me.

And knowing is half the battle.
 
bioman said:
I bet water has unknown effects on young atheletes as well.

You really do have to watch the unknown dangers. I don't even leave my house anymore because of them. Workout or excercise? No way amigo..just too many unknown effects. What if I grow another head or something. Then people would call me Zaphod and that wouldn't be cool.

Now I just sit home, eat trans fats and chain smoke because at least I KNOW how this stuff is going to kill me.

And knowing is half the battle.

What about the unknown benifits of death and danger?
 
anabolicrhino said:
What about the unknown benifits of death and danger?

Or the unknown benefits of living on a private carribean island with a tribe of women to worship you and monthly air drops of all the latest supplements, and a guy named Willy who shows up on a boat with some good gear when you need him and does a quick fade otherwise, leaving you alone with a surplus of tail, time, hormones and boner strengthening pills and other supplements of all kinds.

The boss is in the city today, I have spare time and was day dreaming...
 
People are making a mountain out of a mole hill....

There is nothing wrong with the article.

It says "..Adolescent athletes who take creatine to "bulk up" should do so with caution...."

"It is generally considered safe for adult athletes, however, there is little information about potential health risks for young athletes. ..."

So, what's the big deal? Do you people have any scientific studies that show otherwise?
 
CDB said:
Or the unknown benefits of living on a private carribean island with a tribe of women to worship you and monthly air drops of all the latest supplements, and a guy named Willy who shows up on a boat with some good gear when you need him and does a quick fade otherwise, leaving you alone with a surplus of tail, time, hormones and boner strengthening pills and other supplements of all kinds.

The boss is in the city today, I have spare time and was day dreaming...

That is the LIFE.
 
I heard that creatine CAN make your dyck shrink. And when you go off it all your muscles turn to fat. Taken from the genius doing push ups on the bench press. LOL sad thing is its not to off par to public perception. Well recently i told someone sarcastically that white bread and pizza pops are how you get big...... Seen the guy eeating pizza pops pre workout "the have 12 grams of protein so i eat three" OMFG I should have know better. Oh yeah creatine is an abomination lol.
 
somewhatgifted said:
I heard that creatine CAN make your dyck shrink. And when you go off it all your muscles turn to fat. Taken from the genius doing push ups on the bench press. LOL sad thing is its not to off par to public perception. Well recently i told someone sarcastically that white bread and pizza pops are how you get big...... Seen the guy eeating pizza pops pre workout "the have 12 grams of protein so i eat three" OMFG I should have know better. Oh yeah creatine is an abomination lol.


I'm not laughing at that because I know that that is how it really is. Many people will believe the stupidest **** to stay away from the deadly supplements. Oh wait hey what's going on guys? Your dipping that blunt in bug spray? NO WAY DUDE "Yeah it's awesome you lose feeling in your face and mouth! Steve almost passed out last week!" AWESOME DUDE LEMME HIT THAT!
 
BioHazzard said:
So, what's the big deal? Do you people have any scientific studies that show otherwise?

The mayhew study covers 19-24 year olds. Not sure about younger groups used.
 
Back
Top