Botch
Active member
Hey Botch. I don't think we are philisophically as far apart as you think we are.
I am not recommending long term ketosis. I am talking about short term ketosis to strip off some fat. Then move to the approach you describe.
I agree that long term, you want to ride the fence, not be in deep ketosis. But, in the short term, there is no question in my mind, that ketosis is much more effective at stripping fat than the fence straddling method.
I view this as a staged process. Strip off fat, then once you are in range of your target, add some carbs back. I have done this many times and for me it works very well with minimal muscle loss, you just can't stretch it too far.
For example, if I went six weeks, I would 2% bodyfat and little muscle left since I am so carb responsive, but for others that may not be true.
I am a big believer in letting your body be your guide. I don't think anyone is going to stay in ketosis if they are wasting away and can't bench a watermelon. At least I hope not.
I'm not an expert, so dont think I am not open to others ideas (which is why I started asking carb cycling questions). Just sharing my opinions.
I don't really put a ton of credence in "studies" however. I work in the medical field and I see every day how studies can be used to support any position the researchers want them to be. Dig into the initial research on Celebrex and Viox.........
To me studies are a starting point, and real world experience is the true test, which is why I dig this forum. Granted a lot of folks on here go a lot more overboard than I do, but there are some SMART folks on here.
:goodpost: I agree Kraftkid.