Guest viewing is limited

Beef protein powder Vs Whey Protein

LiftWithDonuts

LiftWithDonuts

Well-known member
Whats the difference?
I've seen some people swear by beef protein powder and some people laugh at the idea of supplementing with it.


Plus beef protein sounds like it taste like dirt.
 
Matthandyo said:
Whats the difference?
I've seen some people swear by beef protein powder and some people laugh at the idea of supplementing with it.


Plus beef protein sounds like it taste like dirt.
Click to expand...

Research still shows whey as the highest grade protein source available.
Carnivor is made primarily from collagen, not muscle tissue. It's inferior to whey.
Due to the cost of the raw materials, most "beef" protein powders use discarded parts like collagen and even blood.

Believe it or not, but even tongue is too expensive for use in beef protein powder. Just realize you are getting the scraps of the scraps.
 
If you love protein high in non essential amino's and eating liquid cow *******s that were dried out, then be my guest. Otherwise stick with whey or casein or anything but beef protein
 
Yep you're definitely better going with whey or a blend. PES select all the way.
 
I use beef protein powder (MuscleMeds Carnivore Invalid Link Removed), but I'm unable to stomach whey even in isolate form due to lactose intolerance and dairy issues.
 
TexasLifter89 said:
I use beef protein powder (MuscleMeds Carnivore Invalid Link Removed), but I'm unable to stomach whey even in isolate form due to lactose intolerance and dairy issues.
Click to expand...

Just use egg protein
Or even pea

Or more meat :)
 
TexasLifter89 said:
Previously used egg protein, pea, various vegan proteins, but I really do like the MuscleMeds carnivore. I eat plenty of meat, own a BBQ restaurant
Click to expand...

Not hitting your totals with it?
I couldnt imagine having a shake if i always had meat available
 
Driven2lift said:
Not hitting your totals with it?
I couldnt imagine having a shake if i always had meat available
Click to expand...

I don't really do calorie or macro monitoring to a T, I'm sure if I did I would be. Honestly, the whole protein shake thing has just been a daily habitual process really.
 
Driven2lift said:
Not hitting your totals with it?
I couldnt imagine having a shake if i always had meat available
Click to expand...

I don't really do calorie or macro monitoring to a T, I'm sure if I did I would be. Honestly, the whole protein shake thing has just been a daily habitual process really.
 
Isn't carnivore mainly collagen & gelatin? The added creatine & BCAA's are what's providing the real benefits.
 
ddfox said:
Isn't carnivore mainly collagen & gelatin? The added creatine & BCAA's are what's providing the real benefits.
Click to expand...

Yeah, looks like it after digging in more. I've been pleased with my progress while using it though, def open to trying other beef proteins
 
ddfox said:
Isn't carnivore mainly collagen & gelatin? The added creatine & BCAA's are what's providing the real benefits.
Click to expand...

Yeah, looks like it after digging in more. I've been pleased with my progress while using it though, def open to trying other beef proteins
 
ddfox said:
Isn't carnivore mainly collagen & gelatin? The added creatine & BCAA's are what's providing the real benefits.
Click to expand...

.....

The Solution said:
Research still shows whey as the highest grade protein source available.
Carnivor is made primarily from collagen, not muscle tissue. It's inferior to whey.
Due to the cost of the raw materials, most "beef" protein powders use discarded parts like collagen and even blood.

Believe it or not, but even tongue is too expensive for use in beef protein powder. Just realize you are getting the scraps of the scraps.
Click to expand...
 
U should try the one from Bentancourt Nutrition it says 0 collagen or gelatin. Definitely seems better than carnivore.
 
TexasLifter89 said:
I don't really do calorie or macro monitoring to a T, I'm sure if I did I would be. Honestly, the whole protein shake thing has just been a daily habitual process really.
Click to expand...

Do you understand the meaning of collagen/gelatin described by others? It maybe good for your joints but that's about it...
 
USPlabsRep said:
Do you understand the meaning of collagen/gelatin described by others? It maybe good for your joints but that's about it...
Click to expand...

Of course I do, which is why I said I am open to trying others above. Not sure why you feel the need to make implied insults?

EDIT: I came in to mention about how I was using Carnivore, I've learned more about it since the creation of this thread. As someone who is lactose with dairy issues and didn't care for vegan proteins, I was just happy to have something that did not bring down my quality of life. I learned stuff in this thread, so will be looking else where now. Hence the purpose of AM for me (to learn) :)
 
Are these collagen / gelatin based or meat:

1.Betancourt Nutrition Beef Standard
2.Dymatize Elite Primal
3.Revolutions Beef Protein Isolate
4.Ronnie Coleman King Beef
5.SAN 100% Pure Titanium Beef Supreme
6.MHP IsoPrime 100% Beef
7.MuscleTech Platinum 100% Beef Protein
 
paul56778 said:
Are these collagen / gelatin based or meat:

1.Betancourt Nutrition Beef Standard
2.Dymatize Elite Primal
3.Revolutions Beef Protein Isolate
4.Ronnie Coleman King Beef
5.SAN 100% Pure Titanium Beef Supreme
6.MHP IsoPrime 100% Beef
7.MuscleTech Platinum 100% Beef Protein
Click to expand...

The MHP IsoPrime 100% Beef Protein claims to be no collagen or gelatin, not sure of the others.
 
I'm sure bulk powders over here in the UK sell a beef protein powder that claims to be from meat and not collagen and bones.
 
paul56778 said:
Are these collagen / gelatin based or meat:

1.Betancourt Nutrition Beef Standard
2.Dymatize Elite Primal
3.Revolutions Beef Protein Isolate
4.Ronnie Coleman King Beef
5.SAN 100% Pure Titanium Beef Supreme
6.MHP IsoPrime 100% Beef
7.MuscleTech Platinum 100% Beef Protein
Click to expand...

Email the company...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top