This is my hopes for the scenario. It all makes sense to me like this more than any other way. I'm really sick to my stomach in general though about all this.
"I will get ripped for this in other places, and I'm not saying this is fact, but let me suggest this:
What if Cecil Newton did ask MSU for money and, for whatever reason, decided to back out. Conscience? Logistics? Things just seemed skeevy? Who knows. He obviously can't go back to MSU after leading them on for so long. So he goes to Plan B, Auburn, and The Newtons elect to make that move cleanly. Cecil doesn't ask for money. Doesn't want the headaches. Figures NFL cash is coming one day soon. Just hold out until then.
And let's say The Newtons are up front with Auburn about what happened with MSU. And Auburn self-reports it.
Now you're looking at a clean recruitment from Auburn's perspective. Is Cam on the hook for sanctions simply based on the dalliance with MSU? Donald Jackson would say no.
Auburn then would be 100% justified in being strong about Newton playing. They know what happened. They know they're in the clear. They've fessed up.
I'm just saying it's possible. "
Although anything's possible... and I'm not an expert at NCAA matters... I think there would be a couple of dilemmas with that scenario:
1. Cecil still attempted to shop him, and although no one may be able to prove Cam was even aware of it, it's still an NCAA violation (as he was Cam's representative)... and he would still be deemed ineligible. While AU might be unaffected in the long run, they would still have to sit him, and may be in jeopardy of forfeiting the previous 10 wins, as his ineligible status would be deemed retroactive back to the violation.
2. There's no way Cecil pulled Cam away from MSU (a place he really wanted to go because of Mullen) to put him at AU unless there was money/benefits involved. Just doesn't make much sense.
Honestly, while it would appear ridiculously stupid for Auburn to do this... it's actually just extremely desperate measures by extremely desperate men... Jacobs and Chizik. With Bama getting Saban and winning a NC, they had to do something to compete. I really think they went ALL IN to get the recruits they needed. It's a hell of a risk... but look... it almost paid off.
Still waiting for the "maverick booster" defense. Jacobs will throw anyone and everyone under the bus to save face.
Like I said, this isn't something that pleases me as a Bama fan. The UA-AU rivalry is like no other, and this drama may end up damaging that match-up's allure for years to come. It sure won't make the SEC look good.
We all know great athletes get "extras" at major programs, but when greed takes over, situations like this come to light.
My $0.02 --------> If AU is guilty, then Auburn deserves better than Jacobs and his cronies.