Catobolic vs. Anabolic?

  1. Question Catobolic vs. Anabolic?


    Ok I am just trying to understand this a little more....

    My question is when you are dieting you want to be more Catabolic or Anabolic?

    I understand that being Catobolic is the breakdown of complex molecules, which can increase cortisol in turn breaking down more molecules...(I think that is right about the cortisol)

    I understand that being Anabolic is the build up of complex molecules, and to be Anabolic you have to have energy(which is the catoblic process) and when you are more Anabolic you gain size....which is lean muscle

    Now here is where I am getting a little confused.....If anabolic increases size(lean muscle) that would increase your matoblism and in turn burn more fat which seems to coinside with catobolic

    So anabolic can in a way break down fat( prevent muscle loss because you are adding muscle being anabolic) and catobolic is breaking down fat......

    That is my question if catobolism is the breaking down of compex molecules would you not want to be more catobolic? or would it be better to be more anabolic where you do not lose muscle?


  2. Um. I'm pretty sure you went through the details too much. This is what ive learned, correct me if im wrong, BUT :
    Anabolic is the buildup of muscle tissue, whereas
    Catabolic is the breakdown of muscle tissue.

    Anabolic is what you want, even if you are cutting. Catabolism is what happens to muscles during excessive cardio, or overtraining perhaps.

    You can prevent that many ways, (glutamine perhaps? not sure) but catabolism I dont think is a good thing.

    I would think both break down fat, just one builds muscle, the other tears it down.

    to answer your question, IMHO, you dont want to be catabolic.

    hope i got things straight... good luck man!
  3. Red face


    Quote Originally Posted by Sooty
    Um. I'm pretty sure you went through the details too much. This is what ive learned, correct me if im wrong, BUT :
    Anabolic is the buildup of muscle tissue, whereas
    Catabolic is the breakdown of muscle tissue.

    Anabolic is what you want, even if you are cutting. Catabolism is what happens to muscles during excessive cardio, or overtraining perhaps.

    You can prevent that many ways, (glutamine perhaps? not sure) but catabolism I dont think is a good thing.

    I would think both break down fat, just one builds muscle, the other tears it down.to answer your question, IMHO, you dont want to be catabolic.

    hope i got things straight... good luck man!


    Actually you answered it perfectly, i posted it on BB.com and they thought that I was talking about working out....which i guess I could see where they would get that...but saying the word DIETING I would think they would understand that is what I was talking about....thanx for your help.
    •   
       


  4. Great man anything to help

  5. browsing by this topic really fast it looks like catholic vs. anabolic. i believe my exact thought was "damn, ****ers compete with everything." LOL.

  6. Quote Originally Posted by Beelzebub
    browsing by this topic really fast it looks like catholic vs. anabolic. i believe my exact thought was "damn, ****ers compete with everything." LOL.
    Great, now they're gonna try and stop us from being anabolic.

  7. i hope my supplements dont molest me!

  8. Quote Originally Posted by Sooty
    i hope my supplements dont molest me!

  9. Quote Originally Posted by Cutter
    Ok I am just trying to understand this a little more....

    My question is when you are dieting you want to be more Catabolic or Anabolic?

    I understand that being Catobolic is the breakdown of complex molecules, which can increase cortisol in turn breaking down more molecules...(I think that is right about the cortisol)

    I understand that being Anabolic is the build up of complex molecules, and to be Anabolic you have to have energy(which is the catoblic process) and when you are more Anabolic you gain size....which is lean muscle

    Now here is where I am getting a little confused.....If anabolic increases size(lean muscle) that would increase your matoblism and in turn burn more fat which seems to coinside with catobolic

    So anabolic can in a way break down fat( prevent muscle loss because you are adding muscle being anabolic) and catobolic is breaking down fat......

    That is my question if catobolism is the breaking down of compex molecules would you not want to be more catobolic? or would it be better to be more anabolic where you do not lose muscle?
    Anabolism is the building of more complex molecules from energy and materials (can be lean tissue or fatty tissue). Catabolism is just the reverse.

    When you consume more calories than you are burning then you will be overall anabolic (fat and/or muscle). Catabolism is again the reverse.

    When a lifter diets, they go overall catabolic but the goal is to maximize fatty tissue catabolism while minimizing lean tissue catabolism. It is a balancing act.

    Generally, only beginners can lose overall weight and build muscle at the same time. So yes in that case anabolism of muscle can promote more fatty tissue breakdown. Overall, however, they would be catabolic because more energy is going out than coming in (weighing less on the scale).

  10. Quote Originally Posted by Nitrox
    Anabolism is the building of more complex molecules from energy and materials (can be lean tissue or fatty tissue). Catabolism is just the reverse.

    When you consume more calories than you are burning then you will be overall anabolic (fat and/or muscle). Catabolism is again the reverse.

    When a lifter diets, they go overall catabolic but the goal is to maximize fatty tissue catabolism while minimizing lean tissue catabolism. It is a balancing act.

    Generally, only beginners can lose overall weight and build muscle at the same time. So yes in that case anabolism of muscle can promote more fatty tissue breakdown. Overall, however, they would be catabolic because more energy is going out than coming in (weighing less on the scale).

    Thanx man....Im glad that you explained that....Im not a beginner but at the same time I have so much to learn and IM just trying to get to the point where I can maximize my results like everyone else....I have a feeling that working out could possibly become my life soon....lol so I want to be knowledgable about the subject....

  11. Quote Originally Posted by Beelzebub
    browsing by this topic really fast it looks like catholic vs. anabolic. i believe my exact thought was "damn, ****ers compete with everything." LOL.
    HAHAHA!

  12. pretty much eat right, lift right, and sleep longer. take stuff that prevent muscle catabolism.. i dont know any off hand.. use search
  

  
 

Similar Forum Threads

  1. p-slin vs anabolic pump
    By IamTheWalrus in forum Supplements
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 09-04-2008, 12:19 PM
  2. Blue Gene vs. Anabolic Edge
    By Mar430 in forum Supplements
    Replies: 56
    Last Post: 08-27-2008, 08:52 AM
  3. Sizeon VS. Anabolic Pump
    By izzzzooo in forum Supplements
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 03-17-2008, 03:30 PM
  4. NHA Stack vs anabolic xtreme mass stack
    By weaknessis in forum Supplements
    Replies: 14
    Last Post: 10-27-2007, 08:36 PM
Log in
Log in