Dextrose v. WMS: Which is better in terms of recovery pre, during, and post WO??

Page 1 of 4 123 ... Last
  1. Question Dextrose v. WMS: Which is better in terms of recovery pre, during, and post WO??


    Thread title says it all...


  2. I've been wondering about this too...been using WMS in my post workout drink with Creatine mono and Xtend for about a month now; but never used dextrose before.
    •   
       


  3. I don't think one is guaranteed superior than the other in the terms listed above. Some respond well to dextrose using intra/post workout while others will notice considerable stomach issues. WMS has better feedback as far as stomach issues, and personally I like the fact that it is low glycemic, but that does not make it better either.

    Everyone is different in terms of genetics and response to nutritional factors. Just have to find what works for you.

  4. In all honesty I think they are very, very similar in function..

    I believe WMS is absorbed slightly faster than dex, but it is almost negligible..

    The only real reason I could see anybody saying WMS is superior to dex is if they get bloat from the dex (most likely) or, for whatever reason, they like the taste of WMS better..

    Otherwise, it's just personal preference I guess.. I use dex but if somebody gave me some WMS, I'd use it!

    They are pretty much equal -- take your pick!

  5. i wouldn't say they are equall. WMS as no sugar in it, and it does digest faster than dextrose. That is why i prefer WMS.
    •   
       


  6. Right now I do a 50/50 mix of dex and malto during training and I really see no difference between the times I have used WMS except the dex/malto taste better. If you can digest it go for the cheaper option of dex and malto.
    Muscle Pharm Rep

  7. Quote Originally Posted by avgBdybldr View Post
    i wouldn't say they are equall. WMS as no sugar in it, and it does digest faster than dextrose. That is why i prefer WMS.
    I see what you're saying, and the sugar part may be true, but he is asking about recovery -- and in terms of recovery, I would say they are quite equal.

    Here is a post from John Berardi on another board..

    Originally Posted by John Berardi
    I've been seeing more and more waxy maize discussion here and as a result I thought I'd jump in.

    For starters, the claims that WM is "much, much" faster absorbed seems fairly irrelevant to me - for most recreational exercisers - as well as high level athletes.

    Let's not forget, the reason we minimize maltodextrin, sucrose, and dextrose in our daily intake is because they are already very, very quickly absorbed, leading to high blood concentrations of carbohydrate and concomitant surges of insulin. (Of course, this is precisely the reason we take them during/post exercise - for the blood sugar boost and anabolic insulin surge).

    If we look to the data, huge blood sugar (and insulin) increases with malto and dextrose occur within 15-20 minutes of ingestion. However, these carbs are appearing in the bloodstream even faster. You see, digestion (and some absorption) of these 2 carbs begins in the mouth. So although PEAK blood concentrations don't occur until 15-20min in, there's no delay.

    So, here's some food for thought...just a question to ponder...
    Do you really need your blood sugar and blood insulin to peak 5-10 minutes sooner?

    In the end, be careful with the marketing rhetoric about the amazing properties of WM and how fast it's absorbed. Dextrose, sucrose, and malto are also VERY quickly absorbed. And the difference between these and WM (which are real and have been measured) may very well be negligible.

    So, with respect to speed of digestion/absorption, all this ado, seems to me, about nothing.

    http://www.sherdog.net/forums/showthread.php?t=736811

  8. I love you guys... Awesome information.

    Let the discussion rage on!!
  9. Thumbs up Its a matter of preference!


    Honestly it really is a matter of preference. For recovery, I notice a minor difference between the two. I prefer WMS because it is sugar-free and it tends to give me a pump even more so when I take my NeoVar with it post-workout, and WMS doesn't give me a bloated feeling. To be honest though...to say one is superior to the other...thats purely subjective. Just adding in my two cents!

    Cheers!
    "Never trust a b*tch because b*tches be crazy, now get out there and go crush some P***Y!" - Jerry Stiller.

  10. What about the insulin response of each? Where is WMS on the GI?

  11. keep in mind GI only matters if you consume that material on an empty stomach with water only. add anything else and the GI changes and there is no telling how much. So even if WMS is 20 points lower as far as GI goes, how it affects you when mixed with BCAAs or whey may be no different than how dextrose dose

    Also I think this is one of those things where the difference would only be measureable if you are at your genetic max and training natural only. Otherwise my assumption would be that the difference is so tiny that likely other "mistakes" or problems would cover up the statistical significance of their difference. On the average person here, I bet the difference wouldn't add up to an oz of muscle mass a month.
  12. Thumbs up Precisely my thoughts!


    Quote Originally Posted by EasyEJL View Post
    keep in mind GI only matters if you consume that material on an empty stomach with water only. add anything else and the GI changes and there is no telling how much. So even if WMS is 20 points lower as far as GI goes, how it affects you when mixed with BCAAs or whey may be no different than how dextrose dose

    Also I think this is one of those things where the difference would only be measureable if you are at your genetic max and training natural only. Otherwise my assumption would be that the difference is so tiny that likely other "mistakes" or problems would cover up the statistical significance of their difference. On the average person here, I bet the difference wouldn't add up to an oz of muscle mass a month.
    ^^^Ozarka...I believe Easy just answered your question. He beat me to it, but what he has said here is along the same lines of what I would have said. This is why I say the topic is purely subjective.

    Cheers!
    "Never trust a b*tch because b*tches be crazy, now get out there and go crush some P***Y!" - Jerry Stiller.

  13. Quote Originally Posted by SamBoz19 View Post
    ^^^Ozarka...I believe Easy just answered your question. He beat me to it, but what he has said here is along the same lines of what I would have said. This is why I say the topic is purely subjective.

    Cheers!
    its something i've thought for a while, but a few weeks ago I spent a bunch of time talking with Hugo Rivera, and that was one of the things he mentioned - its not really that complicated, and those tiny differences add up to so little that being completely anal about the detail is ok when you have nothing else important to worry about, but almost none of us are in those shoes. So for most us, the difference between hitting 40/40/20 for macros and 37/41/22 for a day is inconsequential, and the effort (and life enjoyment leve) it takes to perfectly acheive the 40/40/20 isn't necessarily worth it.

  14. for the price of dextrose why not mix the two??

  15. Quote Originally Posted by rugrat5288 View Post
    for the price of dextrose why not mix the two??
    I'm thinking of trying this. I have a bunch of both, so why not?

  16. i thought the difference between WMS and dex was that dex is all simple sugars and even though WMS is supposed to absorb faster its a complex carb and stays with you longer ..... or something like that??
  17. Thumbs up 1/2 WMS + 1/2 Dex


    Quote Originally Posted by rugrat5288 View Post
    for the price of dextrose why not mix the two??
    +1

    WMS: Fast absorption
    Dex.: High GI

    So the best for post-wo: 50% WMS + 50% Dex.

  18. Quote Originally Posted by EasyEJL View Post
    keep in mind GI only matters if you consume that material on an empty stomach with water only. add anything else and the GI changes and there is no telling how much. So even if WMS is 20 points lower as far as GI goes, how it affects you when mixed with BCAAs or whey may be no different than how dextrose dose

    Also I think this is one of those things where the difference would only be measureable if you are at your genetic max and training natural only. Otherwise my assumption would be that the difference is so tiny that likely other "mistakes" or problems would cover up the statistical significance of their difference. On the average person here, I bet the difference wouldn't add up to an oz of muscle mass a month.
    You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to EasyEJL again.

    Agreed 100%. Even if you were to attempt to measure differences in which works better for you aside from bloat and stomach issues the gains difference would be so insignificantly small that it wouldn't be possible to judge it.

  19. Combination of Dextrose and WMS is the best. However if I had to pick one I will go with Dextrose.

    The only issue with Dextrose is that it causes a bit of bloating, but I am not sure if its the Dextrose only that does it. I mean when I just take Dex by itself I am fine. It is the combination of Dex + Glutamine + Creatine that makes me bloated, more so the Creatine.

    Also pricewise Dextrose is much cheaper than WMS, and easily obtained at most stores.

    I go with Dex.

  20. right now i do a 50/50 split of dextrose and maltrodextrin...do you guys suggest 33/33/33 split with wms or 50/50 with dextrose and wms?

    iv been doing this for 5years (no bloat), im curious if switching it up would be beneficial for the mere fact of switching it up so your body doesn't get used to it...

  21. mmmm I love my banannas, and oatmeal. I don't buy into the whole post workout drink except for protein.

  22. Quote Originally Posted by TheMyth View Post
    mmmm I love my banannas, and oatmeal. I don't buy into the whole post workout drink except for protein.
    Same here. I keep my Dex or WMS or what ever I am using for intra workout fuel. I love me my w/w bagels and Banana Bread flavored oatmeal with banana. MMMM MMMM good.

  23. i do wms and pure vt maple syrup in my post workout shake,. followed by a meal of ww bagel with chicken sandwhich and banana or apple 45 minutes later.
  24. Guest
    Guest's Avatar

    Quote Originally Posted by SamBoz19 View Post
    Honestly it really is a matter of preference. For recovery, I notice a minor difference between the two. I prefer WMS because it is sugar-free and it tends to give me a pump even more so when I take my NeoVar with it post-workout, and WMS doesn't give me a bloated feeling. To be honest though...to say one is superior to the other...thats purely subjective. Just adding in my two cents!

    Cheers!
    What does sugar free have to do with it? Maltodextrin is a complex carbohydrate and at the end everything becomes a sugar before it becomes stored as glycogen.
  25. Guest
    Guest's Avatar

    Where is the data on WMS and insulin response? Is there any?

  26. Quote Originally Posted by USPLabs View Post
    Where is the data on WMS and insulin response? Is there any?
    Idk, but I frickin' wanna know..

    I googled it and didn't come up with anything.
  27. Guest
    Guest's Avatar

    Quote Originally Posted by ozarkaBRAND View Post
    Idk, but I frickin' wanna know..

    I googled it and didn't come up with anything.
    Carbohydrates are transported into Cells by GLUT4. GLUT4 is signaled by Insulin, exercise, and supplements like Anabolic Pump or P-SLIN.

    My questions is if WMS has a SUPER DUPER FAST Digestion rate the only way it makes it into the cells as glycogen is with insulin.

    I get Hypoglycemic with WMS and thats because of the fast digestion rate and subsequent drop in plasma insulin(my reasoning until I see date on the contrary) Which is exactly how Berardi explains is above.

  28. Quote Originally Posted by USPLabs View Post
    Carbohydrates are transported into Cells by GLUT4. GLUT4 is signaled by Insulin, exercise, and supplements like Anabolic Pump or P-SLIN.

    My questions is if WMS has a SUPER DUPER FAST Digestion rate the only way it makes it into the cells as glycogen is with insulin.

    I get Hypoglycemic with WMS and thats because of the fast digestion rate and subsequent drop in plasma insulin(my reasoning until I see date on the contrary) Which is exactly how Berardi explains is above.
    You make a very nice point.. Glad you popped up in here man! Keeping the discussion going!!

  29. I've always used dextose for at least four years now.

    Never used Wazy Maize . Might have to try it oput when dextose runs out. dextose works well for me. i get no stomach issues
    Facebook John Smeton Fitness
    youtube JohnSmetonFitness1
    Twitter SmetonFitness

  30. Leucine has been shown to boost insulin levels quite a bit and would be a good adjunct to any pwo drink. But like OCCFan023 said the variances amongst individuals will likely result in different reactions. So there's always a bit of experimentation required to find your ideal mix.
  •   

      
     

Similar Forum Threads

  1. Replies: 19
    Last Post: 04-30-2015, 06:07 AM
  2. All New Recovery/Post-Workout Recovery Formula!!!
    By ScottyDoc in forum Finaflex-Redefine Nutrition
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 12-23-2010, 12:42 PM
  3. Replies: 6
    Last Post: 07-19-2008, 09:34 AM
  4. need help with post cycle recovery
    By djhex36 in forum Cycle Info
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 10-28-2003, 07:06 PM
Log in
Log in