Poll: Who's the "new face" of the NHL

Be advised that this is a public poll: other users can see the choice(s) you selected.

Another Hockey Thread...Ovechkin v Crosby

Page 2 of 5 First 1234 ... Last

  1. Quote Originally Posted by IainDaniel View Post
    My Bad I thought Bure seemed to have his best seasons leading into contract negotiations.

    Just trying to recollect that time.
    He would string together fantastic seasons. His issue was never motivation, but health. I was a huge Pavel Bure fan back in the day, but his career was horribly dogged by knee problems.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys



  2. Yeah he missed a couple of years due to knee reconstruction.

    Then held out for half a season when he didn't want to play with Vancouver anymore.
    •   
       


  3. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    He would string together fantastic seasons. His issue was never motivation, but health. I was a huge Pavel Bure fan back in the day, but his career was horribly dogged by knee problems.
    In fairness, one of his best seasons in Van., was prior to a contract year, which ultimately led to his departure from the Canucks. I certainly agree injuries were an issue with Pavel, but; I feel his lack of motivation was equally so. Unfortunate as it may be, that is an issue which has plagued a great many Russian snipers. (OV is definitely breaking the mould here, IMO.)

  4. Quote Originally Posted by Mulletsoldier View Post
    In fairness, one of his best seasons in Van., was prior to a contract year, which ultimately led to his departure from the Canucks. I certainly agree injuries were an issue with Pavel, but; I feel his lack of motivation was equally so. Unfortunate as it may be, that is an issue which has plagued a great many Russian snipers. (OV is definitely breaking the mould here, IMO.)
    Fedorov and Mogilny are the only Russian-born players close to 500 goals. There really isn't a large enough sample of Russian-born players in the NHL, yet, especially with the tumultuous transfer agreement between the NHL and the Russian leagues. I'll say that Kovalchuk plays very hard in obscurity in Atlanta. I would love to see him added to a contender (e.g. Vancouver, Pittsburgh, SJ).
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  5. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    Fedorov and Mogilny are the only Russian-born players close to 500 goals. There really isn't a large enough sample of Russian-born players in the NHL, yet, especially with the tumultuous transfer agreement between the NHL and the Russian leagues. I'll say that Kovalchuk plays very hard in obscurity in Atlanta. I would love to see him added to a contender (e.g. Vancouver, Pittsburgh, SJ).
    True, Russian players comprise about 3.5% of the NHL, however; the slavic countries which comprise the former U.S.S.R., and which by and large import their playing styles and philosophy from the Russian/Soviet style, comprise about 15% [these taken from NHL.com 2008].

    Kovalchuk can play hard, but he is notorious for flailing on back-checks, needlessly avoiding the body when it matters, and for being horribly streaky. IMO, he plays more or less when he wants to. (Living in Canada, we see a lot of hockey coverage from each and every team, so no team is truly obscure.) Mogilny, Fedorov [at times in his career], Kovalev, the Bure brothers, Kovalchuk and so on are [unfortunately] notorious for playing merely when it suits them. Albeit a Czech, Jagr would be the primary example of this playing "style".
    •   
       


  6. Kovalev is about as streaky of a player as there is. His talent should dominate the league, but it's not there in the head. That is a very common trait of Soviet-born players.

    As far as Kovalchuk, playing in a horrible hockey town such as Atlanta has to drain you at some point plus Ovie really took a lot of his thunder. It's really sad because he's averaged over 42 goals per year for his career playing with a horrible cast for most of his career (Heatley flourished while in Ottawa with Spezza and Hossa is streaky).
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  7. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    Kovalev is about as streaky of a player as there is. His talent should dominate the league, but it's not there in the head. That is a very common trait of Soviet-born players.

    As far as Kovalchuk, playing in a horrible hockey town such as Atlanta has to drain you at some point plus Ovie really took a lot of his thunder. It's really sad because he's averaged over 42 goals per year for his career playing with a horrible cast for most of his career (Heatley flourished while in Ottawa with Spezza and Hossa is streaky).
    I know, he is ridiculous! I feel the issue is he will command too much to go to a viable team with alternate threats. Unless he goes to an organization which carefully wheels around the cap like Detroit, and/or goes the Hossa route and takes considerably less.

    To be fair, Bure and Jagr were some of my perennially favorite players growing up. it is just unfortunate that these high-profile European snipers have come to characterize themselves as lacking passion and/or dedication. IMO, Jarmoir Jagr may very well be the most talented player to ever play the game, and should own countless records! Unfortunately, that is not necessarily the case.

  8. Even though im a huge PENS fan I would have to say Ovechkin is probally a little better. Hes bigger stronger faster and has a bad ass shot. But my boy Malkin has been playing pretty damn good these last couple games as well dont forget about him.

  9. Quote Originally Posted by wastchak View Post
    Even though im a huge PENS fan I would have to say Ovechkin is probally a little better. Hes bigger stronger faster and has a bad ass shot. But my boy Malkin has been playing pretty damn good these last couple games as well dont forget about him.
    Malkin has definitely been unconscious lately. I feel Crosby is better in literally every aspect of the game aside from open-ice hitting and snap/slap-shots, though. He certainly outshone OV in their head-to-head meeting.

  10. Quote Originally Posted by Mulletsoldier View Post
    Malkin has definitely been unconscious lately. I feel Crosby is better in literally every aspect of the game aside from open-ice hitting and snap/slap-shots, though. He certainly outshone OV in their head-to-head meeting.
    I agree. There is more to the Game of hockey then just being able to hit and shoot.

  11. Malkin also goes through stretches where he disappears. I remember watching the first couple of game vs Washington and it was as though he wasn't even playing. I had to really look for him to even notice he wasn't a scratch.

    OT, but, as far as talent taken away by injuries is concerned, there has been few losses worse than Peter Mattias Forsberg. Watching him play was something I'll never forget and when he was healthy, he was always dominant. I think it was the '99 and '02 playoffs where he led the league in points even though the Avs where eliminated in the West Finals.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  12. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    Malkin also goes through stretches where he disappears. I remember watching the first couple of game vs Washington and it was as though he wasn't even playing. I had to really look for him to even notice he wasn't a scratch.
    Definitely agree. This comes back to the patent streakiness in Russian-born players I spoke about earlier. Ethnocentrism aside, Russian-born players are notoriously and undeniably streaky!

    OT, but, as far as talent taken away by injuries is concerned, there has been few losses worse than Peter Mattias Forsberg. Watching him play was something I'll never forget and when he was healthy, he was always dominant. I think it was the '99 and '02 playoffs where he led the league in points even though the Avs where eliminated in the West Finals.
    Agree. He was ridiculous.

  13. I'll take Ovechkin over Crybaby, er, Crosby any day. But I'll take Datsyuk over both in a heartbeat.

  14. Quote Originally Posted by tribaltek View Post
    I'll take Ovechkin over Crybaby, er, Crosby any day. But I'll take Datsyuk over both in a heartbeat.
    Is that the Datsyuk with a whopping 1 goal this playoff season?
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  15. No, it's the Datsyuk that is still in the playoffs, and on his way to his third cup in 7 years...

  16. Quote Originally Posted by tribaltek View Post
    I'll take Ovechkin over Crybaby, er, Crosby any day. But I'll take Datsyuk over both in a heartbeat.
    Datsyuk is barely a point-per-game player in his career, though his work on the PK and defensively is great. This being said, he is in no way a franchise-player [see for comparison: Sedin twins]. I would take Crosby, OV, Malkin, Iginla, Nash, Heatley, Spezza, Kovalchuk, Toews, and Thornton over Datsyuk for forwards; Luongo, Brodeur, Mason, Fleury, Ward, Thomas and Nabokov over Datsyuk for goalies, and; Keith, Neidermayer, Pronger, and Lidstrom for defenseman.

    He is a defensive player, but his offense is non-existent, and that [to me] precludes him from any rational discussion involving the top five players in the league. If you offered any sane GM the choice between Datsyuk and any of those players, probably 90% would choose the other player over Datsyuk.

    Actually, TSN [Canadian version of ESPN] recently did a GM poll about "franchise players": out of the 28 that responded, 58% chose Crosby, with the next highest point-getter being OV at 16% with Luongo at 8% [he had more first place votes than OV, though]. It went on a 5-3-1 point system. Datsyuk was way down there!

  17. Quote Originally Posted by tribaltek View Post
    No, it's the Datsyuk that is still in the playoffs, and on his way to his third cup in 7 years...
    Aside from last year, he wasn't a huge reason for their success and was often a reason for their early exits. He had 6 points in '01-'02, when they won the cup and Hasek stole the show that year, even though Lidstrom won the Conn Smythe.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  18. OK, maybe Datsyuk isn't the "franchise player" so to speak, but I still believe him to be the most "complete" player in the NHL. Any part of the ice, any situation, the guy is gold.

    You both do have valid points, but I'll stick to my choice.

  19. Quote Originally Posted by tribaltek View Post
    OK, maybe Datsyuk isn't the "franchise player" so to speak, but I still believe him to be the most "complete" player in the NHL. Any part of the ice, any situation, the guy is gold.

    You both do have valid points, but I'll stick to my choice.
    I would definitely say he is the best defensive-forward in the NHL bar-none! For me, though, he is not dynamic and/or prolific enough to be considered the complete player; that distinction goes to Crosby, in my eyes.

    But, at least we can agree to disagree respectfully.

  20. Quote Originally Posted by Mulletsoldier View Post
    I would definitely say he is the best defensive-forward in the NHL bar-none! For me, though, he is not dynamic and/or prolific enough to be considered the complete player; that distinction goes to Crosby, in my eyes.

    But, at least we can agree to disagree respectfully.
    I'd definitely take him on my team because he plays both ends, doesn't bitch about anything, and has the talent to take over a game. He doesn't always produce in the playoffs, but he always makes the other line's job very difficult. I'd definitely take Henrik over Datsyuk, though.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  21. I'll take both! Er... wait, my team *has* both. Lucky me
    Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    I'd definitely take Henrik over Datsyuk, though.

  22. Quote Originally Posted by tribaltek View Post
    I'll take both! Er... wait, my team *has* both. Lucky me
    I'm obligated to hate you now since you're a Wings fan...
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  23. No problem, man. I understand

    But hey... I'm in Detroit. At least I have SOMETHING good, ya know?

    And your team is... the Stars?

  24. Quote Originally Posted by tribaltek View Post
    No problem, man. I understand

    But hey... I'm in Detroit. At least I have SOMETHING good, ya know?

    And your team is... the Stars?
    Hell, no. I hate them, too. I am an Avs fan, hence my man-love for Foppa. It's going to a be a long 3 years.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  25. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    I am an Avs fan
    Avs, eh? Good deal. Lots of good games between us! I miss the old rivalry.




  26. Hockey hasn't been the same for me since St Patrick retired and I really miss those days. Sadly, only a handful of people n both teams still play (Sakic, Foote, Osgood, Lidstrom, and most of the Grind Line)
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  27. Very true. I always hope for some sort of new rivalry with Detroit and whoever... but nothing seems to stick. Chicago is looking pretty upset right now, and they're really young, so hopefully that can brew up... but nothing else has been like Wings-Avs.

  28. Quote Originally Posted by tribaltek View Post
    Very true. I always hope for some sort of new rivalry with Detroit and whoever... but nothing seems to stick. Chicago is looking pretty upset right now, and they're really young, so hopefully that can brew up... but nothing else has been like Wings-Avs.
    All it takes is one incident to cause a nasty rivalry. That being said, neither team has the real snarl to have anything close.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  29. One incident... or maybe one more brutal check to Marty Havlat

    I'm surprised the guy can skate at this point (well, assuming he actually plays the next game).

  30. Quote Originally Posted by tribaltek View Post
    One incident... or maybe one more brutal check to Marty Havlat

    I'm surprised the guy can skate at this point (well, assuming he actually plays the next game).
    It appears as if my team [Pens] and your team [Wings] are on a collision course for the first Finals rematch since '84 [IIRC]. Except, obviously, with a drastically different result!
  •   

      
     

Similar Forum Threads

  1. ice hockey
    By warren in forum Sports Talk
    Replies: 382
    Last Post: 07-02-2008, 09:10 PM
  2. Hockey sticks?
    By sogone2day in forum Sports Talk
    Replies: 23
    Last Post: 11-12-2006, 01:59 PM
  3. 100 points for Crosby
    By Spectre32 in forum Sports Talk
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 04-22-2006, 10:34 AM
  4. junior hockey
    By hckykrt91 in forum Sports Talk
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 03-28-2006, 05:45 PM
Log in
Log in