Is this a proper squat technique ?
08-20-2008 01:13 AM
Is this a proper squat technique ?
I would like an opinion on this :
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yha2XAc2qu8&feature=re lated"]YouTube - Mark Rippetoe: Fixing the Squat: Hip Drive[/ame]
It kind of contradicts what I learned on how to squat properly. Moving the a$$ up before the shoulders...hm, doesn't that sound like a recipe for lower back pain ?!
08-20-2008 02:59 AM
I'm no expert but that sounds horrible. That does sound like a recipe for back pain. The way I learned was to pretend like there is a chair behind you and just barley touch it and drive back up. Had no problems with doing it this way.
08-20-2008 03:19 AM
There are generally two different styles of squats, olympic and powerlifting. Olympic squats are quad dominant; they utilize a narrow stance, bar high on the shoulders, and usually go to a depth below parallel. On the other hand, squats done in the powerlifting style feature a wider stance and utilize the hip drive that was shown in that vid. However, in that example, the kid seemed to exaggerate this movement a little too much making the lift look awkward. It should be seemless; a vid of a powerlifter squating would probably provide the best example.
08-20-2008 03:44 AM
Originally Posted by Rhyno
I thought that the movement was exaggerated as well, perhaps Rippetoe should have demonstrated how it was meant to be executed.
08-20-2008 04:32 AM
I was over at the HST forums the other day asking about the Rippetoe squats and here is part of the response I got. The youtube video is not of me but of an example someone else gave and the comments on the video follows.
I tried these squats yesterday and admit my back felt great...just have to remember to put the bar lower on your back. Youtube has a lot of Rippetoe videos.
Also, I can't see the video above, the wonderful IT guy blocked me from youtube so I can't comment on it.
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A6TLa5ICl0Y"]YouTube - Low Bar Squat 147.5kg 5x3[/ame]
Yeah you are definitely wide. That is much more like a powerlifter squat than the Rippetoe squat. The hip drive issue should be fixed if you do some drills with a TUBOW or some other object that you can place infront of your toe that you can touch your knee with when you squat. The knee should stop moving forward (about tip of the knee over the tip of the toe although this can change due to individual morphologies) about 1/3 to 1/2 of the descent and remain in that position for the remainder of the trip down and the equivalent back up. This allows the hamstring to participate as a primary mover. As the weight got heavier this occurred naturally but there was still a bit of knee wobble which can happen with heavy weight, such as your triples. The TUBOW gives a tactile stimulus during the response so you know what your knees are doing without having to look at them or directly concentrate on them.
The powerlifting style squat has a more vertical shin which requires that the hips are back further which requires that that the back be more horizontal which minimizes the use of the quads. You can generally move more weight this way, but the idea of the Rippetoe squat is to become stronger overall. The Rippetoe squat requires more knees forward which gives more balanced load to all the muscle groups of the legs. It is very hard to bring the knees forward over the top of the toes with the wide stance of the powerlifting squat so the Rippetoe squat requires a bit closer of a stance.
On the descent think knees forward and hips backward at the same time. If the knees are over the tips of the toes, the hip are back, the bar is balanced over the middle of the foot, then the back should be at its current angle for the rest of the descent. The shoulders should rise with the hips and vice versa.
Fixing the "looking down" thing should be easy if you stare at a spot on the floor 6-10 feet in front of you. If that does not work then practice squating with a tennis ball held under your chin. This will help you keep your neck in a neutral position.
09-04-2008 06:44 PM
Ok, so that Rippetoe video is about the closest thing I've ever seen to a proper squat. The only thing I don't agree with is the chin down and elbows back. In a proper squat with lay persons, you have to keep your elbows under the bar and your chest and chin up. This will allow you to keep your abs engaged throughout the range of motion. The problem with his method is that you end up in an anterior pelvic tilt throught the movement and as you guys mentioned.. hell yeah that hurts. The Hip drive that he speaks of is loading the hip flexors and hamstrings during the movement, and then changing directions using the glute maximius and medius. Most people in gyms and health clubs typically keep their knees way too far forward and overwork the quadriceps without ever loading the glutes, hamstrings or quads. It's no wonder so many people have bad knees.
As a side note... that is pretty much exactly what I do every day as an exercise science coach except I coach up to 4 people at a time. That Rippetoe guy definitely knows his stuff.. but he dumbs it down so people can understand it. Props.
09-08-2008 11:57 PM
[QUOTE=SynergyCSCS;1525563] Most people in gyms and health clubs typically keep their knees way too far forward and overwork the quadriceps without ever loading the glutes, hamstrings or quads. It's no wonder so many people have bad knees.
...and flat a$$es
09-11-2008 07:48 PM
[QUOTE=dragonfly;1532206][QUOTE=SynergyCSCS;1525563] Most people in gyms and health clubs typically keep their knees way too far forward and overwork the quadriceps without ever loading the glutes, hamstrings or quads. It's no wonder so many people have bad knees.
...and flat a$$es
Similar Forum Threads
By youngandfree in forum Exercise Science
Last Post: 06-15-2009, 08:59 PM
By Kostanovovic in forum Powerlifting/Strongman
Last Post: 12-17-2007, 11:55 PM
By canadian champ in forum Exercise Science
Last Post: 04-17-2006, 05:28 PM
By Beelzebub in forum Anabolics
Last Post: 01-11-2006, 10:06 PM
By chainsaw in forum Exercise Science
Last Post: 06-12-2005, 07:05 PM
Tags for this Thread