Guest viewing limit reached
  • You have reached the maximum number of guest views allowed
  • Please register below to remove this limitation

Too Much Protien

GetYourWeightUp

New member
In my college nutrition class that all extra protein above ur daily value (under 100 grams) will turn to fat???? This is like the oposit of what I have heard from bodybuilding and what I have practiced...I always went with the 1.5 to 1.7 grams per pound of bodyweight...is this just turning to fat??
 
The average person is going to have much different caloric needs than a bodybuilder. You will be fine as long as you are staying active and in the gym.
 
Let me just start off by saying access calories make you fat, no matter where it comming from. Too much fat will make you fat, too much carbs will make you fat etc. For bodybuilders increased protein is needed to aid in muscle recovery. Sedentary people would need less protein since they aren't constantly tearing down muscle tissue.
 
The thing to remember is that in an excess caloric environment, protein is LESS likely to be stored as fat. This doesn't mean it won't, it just means it has a greater chance of being burned or used for repair than being stored in adipose tissue.

Factors such as those mentioned above as well as overall macro ratio are going to affect the the ultimate end point of the extra protein.

The number given by the class is simply one based on the "average" person expending the "average" number of calories per day while sitting in their cubicle e-mailing the newest Dilbert back and forth. BBers and atheletes in general would be statistical outliers in this sort of bell curve view .
 
Likeliness of being stored as fat:

Saturated Fat (highest)
Monounsaturated Fat
Polyunsaturated Fat
High GI Carbs
Low GI Carbs
Protein (lowest)

All things being equal, would this be correct?
 
Moyer said:
Likeliness of being stored as fat:

Saturated Fat (highest)
Monounsaturated Fat
Polyunsaturated Fat
High GI Carbs
Low GI Carbs
Protein (lowest)

All things being equal, would this be correct?
Click to expand...

That was discussed in Invalid Link Removed a while ago
 
Moyer said:
Likeliness of being stored as fat:

Saturated Fat (highest)
Monounsaturated Fat
Polyunsaturated Fat
High GI Carbs
Low GI Carbs
Protein (lowest)

All things being equal, would this be correct?
Click to expand...
No.
 
IRserge said:
Let me just start off by saying access calories make you fat, no matter where it comming from. Too much fat will make you fat, too much carbs will make you fat etc. For bodybuilders increased protein is needed to aid in muscle recovery. Sedentary people would need less protein since they aren't constantly tearing down muscle tissue.
Click to expand...

From my experience, increased protein intake is a must when trying to put on some muscle. I take in over 200 grams of protein a day and I only weigh 133lbs. Never really saw any substantial body composition changes until I increased protein.
 
bda55 said:
That was discussed in Invalid Link Removed a while ago
Click to expand...

From what I can tell, that thread only discussed which macros are first used for energy. Nothing about fat storage (unless I'm stupid today and I missed something obvious).
 
mab904 said:
From my experience, increased protein intake is a must when trying to put on some muscle. I take in over 200 grams of protein a day and I only weigh 133lbs. Never really saw any substantial body composition changes until I increased protein.
Click to expand...

I am the same way...I didnt start seeing real gains till I was eating more then 400 grams a day....( At a bodyweight of 270..)
 
O/T - Moyer, is that you in your avatar?

If so, you look awesome man, that's exactly the physique I'm aiming to achieve - what are your stats there?
 
once i started scarfing down 300+ grams of protein a day (workout days are about 350g protein) i finally began growing. lots of food i've been eating.
i do that now at a bodyweight of 170lbs and 19 years old. Momma goes grocery shopping twice a week! :burger::food:



oh yea, btw, 270 at 15% is TREMENDOUS! good job getyourweightup!
 
I heard this too. In fact, my nutrition textbook DID talk about bodybuilders and how they don't need as much protein as say, marathon runners. a bunch of BS if you ask me... but it is backed by some scientific studies, albeit probably flawed.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top