Topic of the Week: Is going on HRT still natural to you?

Shasow

Shasow

Banned
Awards
0
Im not anti- anything. I make test boosters ppl use for pct. So the more ppl on test the more product I sell. I said when im 60 i will get on "TRT" but i wont be walking around calling myself natural. Also you shoudnt look at being on TRT for medical reasons as something bad. Its not natural but that doesnt mean its bad. Ppl are on blood pressure medicine and thats not bad
Thing is you seem very finicky over this what is natural and what is not. You just said, for example, that when you go on TRT at 60 you "wont be walking around calling myself natural" but since you (and all of us for that matter) already do and consume many things that are not natural what do you call that? Because by your very definition you are already not natural. You just seem to take it to a finicky level where it becomes a bit silly.
 
Chuck Diesel

Chuck Diesel

Are you Diesel?
Awards
1
  • Established
Thing is you seem very finicky over this what is natural and what is not. You just said, for example, that when you go on TRT at 60 you "wont be walking around calling myself natural" but since you (and all of us for that matter) already do and consume many things that are not natural what do you call that? Because by your very definition you are already not natural. You just seem to take it to a finicky level where it becomes a bit silly.
We are talking about natural in terms of hormone levels. Not hypothetical natural like artificial flavors. Im not finicky bc im adding some logical thinking. Why would I care what others are on? Ive never been on synthetic test. Prosteroids or even prescribed a drug (any drug) in my life. The topic says HRT
 
thebigt

thebigt

Legend
Awards
6
  • Best Answer
  • The BigT Award
  • Established
  • Legend!
  • RockStar
  • First Up Vote
I hate Drs! Most of them are about writing a script and sending you on your way. They don't diagnose and treat the cause anymore. I go to an integrative medicine dr and they look at the cause of problems and treat it to solve other issues.
do you drive a beamer benz or bentley?

i use the VA AND AM VERY HAPPY TO GET THAT SCRIPT!!!!

this whole thread is based on perception, if you think it is...then it is for you...
 
Johnston

Johnston

Active member
Awards
0
If an athlete takes TRT in the woods and no-one is around to see it, is he still natural? Mmm, philosophical. ;)
 
MrKleen73

MrKleen73

Legend
Awards
5
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
Then once again, what is the difference between testosterone to achieve normal levels and a cortisone shot. Both are prescription only.

One works in 4-6 weeks IF you train...the other is instant. How is the drug that lets run if you have a blown knee not cheating vs normal levels of test?!?!
The gear will allow him to perform a super-physiological levels that he never would be able to without them. The cortisol masks the pain so they can perform. It is to use words used later in this thread correcting a problem... IE sever inflammation. So it is seen as a treatment and not a perfomrance enhancing drug. If you take it without having severe inflammation it does nothing for your performance. So it requires there be a problem in order for it to bring you back to your normal level of performance.

Testosterone will increase your gains so long as you continue to train like an athlete, so we will assume both people would be training like an athlete to remove the "Test does nothing if you don't work out from the equation" The difference there is for test to work you need to do something, for cortisol to work you need to BE something and that something is injured. Since talking about athletes both are training.

And that's his choice...and I understand when you chose to do that you have to abide by the rules.

I just think what they seem legal and illegal ridiculous at times. Like I said, treatments that help recovery that are prescription injections are fine...yet steroids are not. It seems odd.
Things that treat injuries or ailments to get you back to your normal performance levels do not improve your normal performance levels they simply get you back to them more quickly so not a performance enhancer so much as a healing enhancer.

That's my point.

Steroids were developed to help recovery and they are legal by prescription. They are banned.

Cortisone shots and platelet rich therapy are injections by prescription and they are legal in most sports.

Why?
Because steroids were demonized in the early 90's. You had crack heads like Lyle Alzado lying to everyone saying his brain cancer and other issues were caused by steroids which was one of the big pushed to get them made into a schedule 3 drug... I remember him making such a HUGE deal about it. Same as this other guy on Youtube now professing that eating 10,000 calories a day to get to 280 is what caused him to get cancer. He doesn't want to talk about the HGH he probably pumped into himself making the tumors grow like wildfire...

http://www.cnn.com/2009/HEALTH/12/02/doping.golfer/index.html

Doug Barron sued the PGA to get an answer. In November, the 40-year-old from Memphis, Tennessee, became the first player in professional golf to be suspended for doping.

The dope in this case is synthetic testosterone and beta blockers.

Barron, a journeyman who has played Tour events for more than a decade, says he had been taking the blockers to treat a heart condition since 1987. Long banned in Olympic sports from bobsled to diving, beta blockers also reduce anxiety and muscle tremor and can sharpen focus and precision.

Barron has another health problem: extremely low testosterone. Since 2005, he has been getting monthly shots of synthetic testosterone, which is also banned from most professional sports. Testosterone, naturally occurring or synthetic, promotes muscle mass and strength, among other things.

The golfer's natural testosterone count when he was prescribed the shots was 78 nanograms per deciliter of blood. Most healthy men his age have a testosterone level between 300 and 500.



Banned!!!

Is this guy cheating or just trying to live a normal life.
First in my opinion this guy got screwed!!!!!

Now we are onto the heart of the subject. The question is not really is HRT natural because I honestly don't think there is anyone here who has stuck a needle in themselves felt like it was the natural thing to do. HRT is not natural, it is not something that your body made, and our natural test doesn't come with various different esters attached. Definitely man made and not natural. There simply is no denying that.

The question is really is it ethical to compete in sports that do not allow the use of steroids, if you are being medically treated for low testosterone and are competing you should seek out a medical waiver. Many sports associations have them, and if so then do what is needed to ensure it is all legit.

Now if we are talking about TRT and competing in Natural competitions then most of the federations I looked at will allow TRT within the normal ranges, however you have to provide your prescription from your doctor and will definitely be tested if you place. Of course that is bodybuilding where they obviously already knew that people on HRT would be likely to want to compete. I am sure many other sports have simply not crossed that threshold, and it makes sense that bodybuilding would be on the cusp of making exceptions for hormone based treatments. I don't think it will take too many law suits before things change. I think the guy above has a pretty good case to make something happen.

I didnt say anything needs to b banned. I said there are rules and if you dont comply you get in trouble.

I got to 230lbs at 5'7" drug free w less than 10% bodyfat. If i was a,running back then went on "HRT" you saying I woudnt notice any increase in fav muscle to fat ratio? Recovery?
For the short term then you would shut down and things would more than likely level out. Now if you were those stats and had lower test that actually needed replaced you would definitely continue to see improved gains for a bit.
There is no such thing as "ur normal levels" then all of a sudden your on test shots and still at your "normal levels"
No not all of the sudden but over a few weeks shut down takes place then people by your products! ;)
if a guy is 240lbs with less than 10% bf with a total test of 78 and then you bring him up to 700 you don't think he would see improvement?
There obviously would be but he is more than likely just coming off a cycle and not recovered yet if maintaining 240 and 10% bodyfat & test at 78.

A guy wouldn't be 240lbs with than 10% bf with a total test of 78.

Stop thinking of theoretical extremes and look at the case in front of you.
Only likely way would be right after a cycle before the HPTA recovery process. I know several people who have gotten on TRT right after a cycle due to this.

The case above though is ridiculous, and should be handled better. I hope he sues the hell out of them and wins.

I've said it before, but I think it bears repeating. You are natural if you are working with what you are naturally producing ie endogenously. If you alter that with exogenous testosterone, you are introducing a product that was synthetically made. While you may be bringing levels into "normal" levels, you aren't doing it naturally.

I'm on TRT and I would never consider myself natural.
BOOM!!!! My boy kisaj laying it down!

I think this thread has shed a little light on the subject. I have come out of this with a new classification for those of us on TRT/HRT.

We are definitely not natural, but are elevated unnaturally to be what is considered a normal natural range. Confused yet. LOL

Dieting, stress, cortisol or even sleep deprivation does not lower our testosterone levels, our levels are already super-physiological to what our bodies can naturally create. Yet remain within the natural normal ranges for the "average male" I think that makes it obvious... we are Super Natural!
 
JudoJosh

JudoJosh

Pro Virili Parte
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
The gear will allow him to perform a super-physiological levels that he never would be able to without them. The cortisol masks the pain so they can perform. It is to use words used later in this thread correcting a problem... IE sever inflammation. So it is seen as a treatment and not a perfomrance enhancing drug. If you take it without having severe inflammation it does nothing for your performance. So it requires there be a problem in order for it to bring you back to your normal level of performance.
2 things..

1 - HRT test levels are not supraphysiological

2 - you are ignoring the fact that medical prescribed HRT treatment does in fact require there to be a problem. Hypogonadism

HRT is medication to treat a condition. If that is cheating then so is any medication someone takes that helps them.
 
JudoJosh

JudoJosh

Pro Virili Parte
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
I've said it before, but I think it bears repeating. You are natural if you are working with what you are naturally producing ie endogenously. If you alter that with exogenous testosterone, you are introducing a product that was synthetically made. While you may be bringing levels into "normal" levels, you aren't doing it naturally.

I'm on TRT and I would never consider myself natural.
Caffeine increases catecholamimes via a synthetic not endogenous manner.

Is drinking coffee make you not natty then? I mean, caffeine does help performance and you are effecting this by an exogenous synthetic compound. Would seem to follow the above logic that coffee drinkers aren't natty, no?

Same can be said for Admin example, which I thought was rather clever. Cortisone shots are exogenous treatment with a synthetic hormone. Are athletes that got shots also not natty then?
 
JudoJosh

JudoJosh

Pro Virili Parte
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
I've said it before, but I think it bears repeating. You are natural if you are working with what you are naturally producing ie endogenously. If you alter that with exogenous testosterone, you are introducing a product that was synthetically made. While you may be bringing levels into "normal" levels, you aren't doing it naturally.

I'm on TRT and I would never consider myself natural.
Caffeine increases catecholamimes via a synthetic not endogenous manner.

Is drinking coffee make you not natty then? I mean, caffeine does help performance and you are effecting this by an exogenous synthetic compound. Would seem to follow the above logic that coffee drinkers aren't natty, no?

Same can be said for Admin example, which I thought was rather clever. Cortisone shots are exogenous treatment with a synthetic hormone. Are athletes that got shots also not natty then?
 

kisaj

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
We are talking hormone replacement here. We can get into the weeds all day determining natural and not with the supplements and diets people have, but that isn't the topic.
 

kisaj

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
2 - you are ignoring the fact that medical prescribed HRT treatment does in fact require there to be a problem. Hypogonadism

HRT is medication to treat a condition. If that is cheating then so is any medication someone takes that helps them.
And you must not be aware how corrupt the hormone industry is. There does not need to be a condition, that is highly subjective to the doctor and if dealing with a clinic, doesn't need to be present at all. So even if someone is still well within normal ranges, they can still go on TRT to dramatically increase those levels and can very easily train and prepare working in supraphysiological ranges, only to come back within normal levels fairly quickly. It happens all the time, even in the amateur levels. So now you have someone on TRT that is not influenced by exposure to factors like stress, sleep, diet, time of day, etc fluctuating normal test levels so they can always be where they want, and they can increase their levels anytime they feel.
 

sammpedd88

Well-known member
Awards
3
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
do you drive a beamer benz or bentley?

i use the VA AND AM VERY HAPPY TO GET THAT SCRIPT!!!!

this whole thread is based on perception, if you think it is...then it is for you...
I drive a Nissan Altima.

I wasn't referring to test prescriptions but scripts in general. Dr's don't give the attention they should or like they did years ago.

What we think we want is not always what we need and that can cause problems.
 
JudoJosh

JudoJosh

Pro Virili Parte
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
And you must not be aware how corrupt the hormone industry is. There does not need to be a condition, that is highly subjective to the doctor and if dealing with a clinic, doesn't need to be present at all. So even if someone is still well within normal ranges, they can still go on TRT to dramatically increase those levels and can very easily train and prepare working in supraphysiological ranges, only to come back within normal levels fairly quickly. It happens all the time, even in the amateur levels. So now you have someone on TRT that is not influenced by exposure to factors like stress, sleep, diet, time of day, etc fluctuating normal test levels so they can always be where they want, and they can increase their levels anytime they feel.
But that isn't the hypothetical that Admin proposed. You are going out of you to try and damn the situation.

The question was, if an athlete is on HRT and maintains his test within range, is he natty.

If the parameters for natty is you can not introduce a foreign synthetic substance that may positively effect performance, then drinking coffee will mean you aren't natty.

However, if the parameters is you keep everything within normal ranges and don't go above, than the HRT guy is natty.

This scenerio you are creating where a guy is deceiving his physician to stock pile test and do cycles would not be a guy on HRT taking test to maintain his levels, i.e. not the question being asked.
 

kisaj

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
Then we go back to my original response, to which I stand. We are talking about hormone replacement here and not dietary additions.

Look, obviously by the number of posts and differing views, this is a hot button topic that we don't all see eye to eye on. This is my stance and you have yours, so I'll leave it at that.
 
Chuck Diesel

Chuck Diesel

Are you Diesel?
Awards
1
  • Established
And you must not be aware how corrupt the hormone industry is. There does not need to be a condition, that is highly subjective to the doctor and if dealing with a clinic, doesn't need to be present at all. So even if someone is still well within normal ranges, they can still go on TRT to dramatically increase those levels and can very easily train and prepare working in supraphysiological ranges, only to come back within normal levels fairly quickly. It happens all the time, even in the amateur levels. So now you have someone on TRT that is not influenced by exposure to factors like stress, sleep, diet, time of day, etc fluctuating normal test levels so they can always be where they want, and they can increase their levels anytime they feel.
My thing is everyone pro HRT/TRT for the most part is like "TRT doesnt do anything super dooper, it keeps you normal" .....but they are on TRT....
 

kisaj

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
I'm on TRT and I am the first to say that it is super duper and absolutely has helped me in my athletic endeavors. I have comparisons in my gym logs, martial arts sparring journals, time decreases in endurance events, and anecdotal evidence that my injury and recovery times have declined.
 
CATdiesel76

CATdiesel76

Well-known member
Awards
3
  • Established
  • RockStar
  • First Up Vote
Another thing to consider is that on TRT your levels are pretty stable no matter what you do. Natural if you drink too much, don't sleep, eat like ****, etc. Your testosterone levels can drop so you have to worry about those things. On TRT its not as much of a concern
 

ucheoma

Active member
Awards
2
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
How can HRT/TRT be considered natty???? It fails all the definitions of natty - an externally administered synthetic substance not naturally generated in the body. In fact it acts to suppress the body's natural HPTA functions!! The argument that HRT which places you in a normal range is = natty is facile because the generation and administration of HRT is patently unnatural period. Where it places you in the range is irrelevant. And by the way, Ive yet to see any test levels for those on HRT where the individual are below mid-point or low end of the range, except they're on a suppressive substance eg AAS or SARM.

On average HRT levels tend to be at the upper end of the scale otherwise what would be the point. We all know while this may be considered 'normal' there is a world of difference for someone on the low end of normal and those perched at the uppermost limits. Cumulatively maintaining these upper test limits over time will confer significant performance and recovery advantages over those with more normal average test levels. That's why HRT is banned by most sporting bodies and test boosters aren't.

One last thing, athletes tend to have average or even low test levels due to the level of training they perform. if an athlete then took HRT this would result in performance and recovery benefits of at least 20% compared to being off HRT. We all know at the highest competitive level winning is often a matter of margins
 

kisaj

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
The whole argument is only for people on TRT to have a reasoning or excuse to come across as normal as everyone else and we all know that we have a distinct advantage. If someone on TRT isn't taking advantage of that, then that is on them.
 
JeremyNG25

JeremyNG25

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
But that isn't the hypothetical that Admin proposed. You are going out of you to try and damn the situation.

The question was, if an athlete is on HRT and maintains his test within range, is he natty.

If the parameters for natty is you can not introduce a foreign synthetic substance that may positively effect performance, then drinking coffee will mean you aren't natty.

However, if the parameters is you keep everything within normal ranges and don't go above, than the HRT guy is natty.

This scenerio you are creating where a guy is deceiving his physician to stock pile test and do cycles would not be a guy on HRT taking test to maintain his levels, i.e. not the question being asked.
Lol at you aren't natty if you drink coffee. Yea coffee versus injectable testosterone. Those are extremely similar *rolling eyes*
 
JeremyNG25

JeremyNG25

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
2 things..

1 - HRT test levels are not supraphysiological

2 - you are ignoring the fact that medical prescribed HRT treatment does in fact require there to be a problem. Hypogonadism

HRT is medication to treat a condition. If that is cheating then so is any medication someone takes that helps them.

Dude you need to come to south Florida. I assure you these anti aging clinics give HRT to almost anybody for a price. I've seen many guys prescribed nandrolone phenyl proprionate, sermorelin, HGH, Test Cyp, injectable winstrol and more all at the same time from an anti aging clinic. Is this TRT!? Lol **** no. But they do in fact call it TRT
 
Chuck Diesel

Chuck Diesel

Are you Diesel?
Awards
1
  • Established
Dude you need to come to south Florida. I assure you these anti aging clinics give HRT to almost anybody for a price. I've seen many guys prescribed nandrolone phenyl proprionate, sermorelin, HGH, Test Cyp, injectable winstrol and more all at the same time from an anti aging clinic. Is this TRT!? Lol **** no. But they do in fact call it TRT
Lived in FL 5 yrs...saw the same thing. Straight Balco.
 
JudoJosh

JudoJosh

Pro Virili Parte
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
Cognitive dissonance is a hell of a thing
 
thebigt

thebigt

Legend
Awards
6
  • Best Answer
  • The BigT Award
  • Established
  • Legend!
  • RockStar
  • First Up Vote
And you must not be aware how corrupt the hormone industry is. There does not need to be a condition, that is highly subjective to the doctor and if dealing with a clinic, doesn't need to be present at all. So even if someone is still well within normal ranges, they can still go on TRT to dramatically increase those levels and can very easily train and prepare working in supraphysiological ranges, only to come back within normal levels fairly quickly. It happens all the time, even in the amateur levels. So now you have someone on TRT that is not influenced by exposure to factors like stress, sleep, diet, time of day, etc fluctuating normal test levels so they can always be where they want, and they can increase their levels anytime they feel.
then they are not on trt, merely getting drugs that aren't really needed...
 
MrKleen73

MrKleen73

Legend
Awards
5
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
Apparently it took 3 weeks to complete after the first and second draft and final editing stage.
Haha, I posted it the day I read it. LOL Just didn't see it until then.

2 things..

1 - HRT test levels are not supraphysiological

2 - you are ignoring the fact that medical prescribed HRT treatment does in fact require there to be a problem. Hypogonadism

HRT is medication to treat a condition. If that is cheating then so is any medication someone takes that helps them.
JudoJosh, you did not read all of my post obviously brother.
1 - I said that supraphysiological was more than the body could naturally produce. Since HRT is Hormone REPLACEMENT Therapy intended to replace the missing testosterone your body was not capable of making it takes you to a supraphysiological level FOR YOU. My natural testosterone levels were 241 when I got on TRT. Now they sit around 900. I am pretty sure my normal test levels were never 900 before except maybe during puberty.

2 - I am not ignoring that fact, but you are ignoring the fact that testosterone will indeed still improve performance even if you are not suffering from hypogonadism. Which was my exact point. You aren't going to get any benefit from using cortisol improperly but you damn sure will with testosterone.

Again tho I said as far as natty goes it is all open to interpretation. The reasoning for the question was should it be allow in "natural competitions". The answer is yes but you need to get a waiver and be tested to prove with in "natural ranges".

Well the milk natty....so its like a natty/synth stack?
Absolutely Not!!!! It is pasteurized! ;)


I still say we are Super Natural!!! FTW!!!!
 

KillIt

New member
Awards
0
I'd say yes, "bodybuilding" doses far exceed theraputic doses. Bodybuilding say 250mg of test a week on the low end. Hrt being 100mg a week or 200 for two weeks. Much less in comparison and doesn't require a post cycle therapy when used for medical purpose.
 
MrKleen73

MrKleen73

Legend
Awards
5
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
I'd say yes, "bodybuilding" doses far exceed theraputic doses. Bodybuilding say 250mg of test a week on the low end. Hrt being 100mg a week or 200 for two weeks. Much less in comparison and doesn't require a post cycle therapy when used for medical purpose.
If it is for a medical purpose a PCT would be useless. The whole reason someone is put on TRT is because their HPTA had failed so they needed put on TRT.

If someone who does not need TRT goes on 100mg a week they will indeed need a PCT to come off, or have a slow and uncomfortable recovery otherwise. Just 100mg a week is more than enough to shut down your natural test production.
 

aovereem

Member
Awards
1
  • Established
Another thing to consider is that on TRT your levels are pretty stable no matter what you do. Natural if you drink too much, don't sleep, eat like ****, etc. Your testosterone levels can drop so you have to worry about those things. On TRT its not as much of a concern
This.
Testosterone levels fluctuates heavily during a 24 h period. My tostrex testosterone has a 25 h half life meaning my levels are constantly at the top end, basically never drops below 1200.
Natty? No fukkin way
 

aprindle

New member
Awards
0
New member, but I started TRT 2 months ago so I've got a couple thoughts on this:

1. The human body secretes testosterone (and pretty much all other hormones except Thyroid) in a pulsatile fashion, TRT delivers stable, long-chain that provide MUCH longer, slower peaks and valleys so it's not identical to the body and in that sense definitely not natural.......but the best option currently available for people needing TRT.

2. Having had a decent amount of lab work done in the past 10 years of my life, all the Total Test values showed up somewhere in between 600-800. I know it varies with pulses but the years of labwork seem to show that somewhere around 700 was likely my body's 'setpoint'. When I started becoming symptomatic (total loss of libido for a year) I went in for an eval starting about 4 months ago and my Total test was checked 2 times, both in the 200-300's. TRT started at a dose that realistically is a bit high (200mg/wk) and my Total test sits 1100-1200 (still considered within normal limits by my lab).

So, in MY case, the 1100-1200 range Test that I'm currently at is definitely not "Natty" for me because its nearly double where I was at for the past decade. I realize most HRT pts don't have the benefit I do of knowing my prior approximate Test level, but I think a person could only truly considered "natural" while on HRT if they return to their pre-andropause baseline. The pulsatile/steady difference still exists but artificially mimicking the body's pulsatile nature just isn't practical so it shouldn't be held against a person and seen as performance enhancing
 
Admin

Admin

Administrator
Staff member
Awards
4
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
  • Established
Same can be said for Admin example, which I thought was rather clever. Cortisone shots are exogenous treatment with a synthetic hormone. Are athletes that got shots also not natty then?
Still hasnt been answered ;)

Running down a field when you're knee is bone on bone is certainly natural. :D
 
Chuck Diesel

Chuck Diesel

Are you Diesel?
Awards
1
  • Established
Still hasnt been answered ;)

Running down a field when you're knee is bone on bone is certainly natural. :D
Natural and "permitted" is two dif things. But in the case of shooting synthetic test in your body. I dont see how that is "naturally" increasing ur test levels. Actually it doest make sense. People are using "tested within normal limits" to mean natural. Its not natural which is like I stated WADA uses a test to epitest ratio to determine if your "natural" having 200 ng/dl or 1300 ng/dl test results dnt matter 2 them bc obviously that doesnt indicate if someone is natural. That test to epitest ratio does.
 
Admin

Admin

Administrator
Staff member
Awards
4
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
  • Established
Natural and "permitted" is two dif things. But in the case of shooting synthetic test in your body. I dont see how that is "naturally" increasing ur test levels. Actually it doest make sense. People are using "tested within normal limits" to mean natural. Its not natural which is like I stated WADA uses a test to epitest ratio to determine if your "natural" having 200 ng/dl or 1300 ng/dl test results dnt matter 2 them bc obviously that doesnt indicate if someone is natural. That test to epitest ratio does.
And shooting cortisone into your knee isn't natural either.

I didn't raise a point about what's permitted.


You can't seem to answer that question on why one is fine and another is not other than "it's the rules". In fact, nobody has.
 
Chuck Diesel

Chuck Diesel

Are you Diesel?
Awards
1
  • Established
And shooting cortisol into your knee isn't natural either.

I didn't raise a point about what's permitted.


You can't seem to answer that question on why one is fine and another is not other than "it's the rules". In fact, nobody has.
I would say shooting cortisone is not a natural to raise your circulating cortisone levels. This started with "rules of competition" then became like "im natural if....." (in relation to HRT/test and about hormone test results.

So we got 3 things going on. If you take something that doesnt have to convert to have its intended effects....its not natural. Its not a pain shot is legal which makes test shots natural.

Test shot -> test levels up -> not natty

Cortisone shot -> pain go away -> not natual pain relieve

As-k -> product taste sweet ->not natural

Honey -> product taste sweet -> natural

Above is all cut and dry. Now heres how to complicate it:

Take dhea -> dhea-s goes up -> not natural levels of dhea

Take dhea -> test/estro goes up -> natural test elevation

Take protein -> blood nitrogen goes up -> natural nitrogen elevation

Shoot nitrogen in ur arm -> blood nitrogen goes up --> not natural levels of nitrogen.
 
Admin

Admin

Administrator
Staff member
Awards
4
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
  • Established
The can of worms that opens is...well, its not a can anymore..its a giant sized bucket.

Cortisone shot ---> taken to mask pain and reduce inflamation ---> actually does harm you over time ---> Legal

HRT --> taken to normalize hormone levels ---> actually beneficial to health ---> banned.

Logic.
 
Chuck Diesel

Chuck Diesel

Are you Diesel?
Awards
1
  • Established
The can of worms that opens is...well, its not a can anymore..its a giant sized bucket.

Cortisone shot ---> taken to mask pain and reduce inflamation ---> actually does harm you over time ---> Legal

HRT --> taken to normalize hormone levels ---> actually beneficial to health ---> banned.

Logic.
Hrt isnt 100% benicicial to health unless u plan on staying in it for life. I know a guy who was on HRT for 7 yrs. His LH .2 now and wont go up.

Legal and illegalis abt organization rules. HRT..ie taking test shots will never b legal in competition....but luckily for people getting shots....there are tons of non tested organizations they can compete in again other ppl on test etc. But they usually wanna compete against the "natty" ppl
 
Admin

Admin

Administrator
Staff member
Awards
4
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
  • Established
Hrt isnt 100% benicicial to health unless u plan on staying in it for life. I know a guy who was on HRT for 7 yrs. His LH .2 now and wont go up.

Legal and illegalis abt organization rules. HRT..ie taking test shots will never b legal in competition....but luckily for people getting shots....there are tons of non tested organizations they can compete in again other ppl on test etc. But they usually wanna compete against the "natty" ppl
Do you always take the extreme outlier to make a generalized point?

HRT overall is to treat a medical condition and make someones life better. As with all drugs or protocls, its not 100% effective but you seem to use whatever small percentage (or the guy you know) to justify your point of view.

If that were the case, you would ban chemo for cancer patients.
 
Chuck Diesel

Chuck Diesel

Are you Diesel?
Awards
1
  • Established
Do you always take the extreme outlier to make a generalized point?

HRT overall is to treat a medical condition and make someones life better. As with all drugs or protocls, its not 100% effective but you seem to use whatever small percentage (or the guy you know) to justify your point of view.

If that were the case, you would ban chemo for cancer patients.
No chemo is to stop someone from dying from cancer. It is radiation and agressive treat meat to kill something guarantee to kill you. A male around 30-40 yrs old w test levels at 200 isnt probably going to die from low test. So no where near the same thing.

Not just the person I know but yes HRT does improve the standard of living for men w low test. I didnt say it doesnt serve a purpose or im against it. I said taking test shots to evelevate test levels isnt natual. At least 3 guys on HRT chimed in on here saying its not "natural".

Legal somewhere and not legal somewhere else doesnt make anything natural or not natural. If the NPC said "ok yall all can shoot test" no more drug free class....that doesnt make it natural. Taking test shots in Mexico isnt natual bc its prob legal.

Driving in IL w tinted fromt windows is illegal. Drive to Indiana, its not illegal, drive ur indiana can in IL... you can have tent on that car....drive ur IL car in IN you cant have tinted front windows in IN eventhough their law allows it. Its called rules. If someone is on HRT and mad they cant compete in the Drug free for life NPC class......then go compete again everyone in the open class on test. If you feel corrisone shots is a no-no contract the fight/match to not allow cortisone shots.
 
Admin

Admin

Administrator
Staff member
Awards
4
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
  • Established
No chemo is to stop someone from dying from cancer. It is radiation and agressive treat meat to kill something guarantee to kill you. A male around 30-40 yrs old w test levels at 200 isnt probably going to die from low test. So no where near the same thing.

Who said they were the same thing? I was talking results and outliers.

Not just the person I know but yes HRT does improve the standard of living for men w low test. I didnt say it doesnt serve a purpose or im against it. I said taking test shots to evelevate test levels isnt natual. At least 3 guys on HRT chimed in on here saying its not "natural".
And some also said people shouldn't be banned from sports while on HRT either.

Legal somewhere and not legal somewhere else doesnt make anything natural or not natural. If the NPC said "ok yall all can shoot test" no more drug free class....that doesnt make it natural. Taking test shots in Mexico isnt natual bc its prob legal.
How is this relevant to anything? I was stating legal in terms of sports orginizations. Painkillers and cortisone shots, which have HIGHER negative side effects especially post career is legal. Your context was stating sports organizations.

Driving in IL w tinted fromt windows is illegal. Drive to Indiana, its not illegal, drive ur indiana can in IL... you can have tent on that car....drive ur IL car in IN you cant have tinted front windows in IN eventhough their law allows it. Its called rules. If someone is on HRT and mad they cant compete in the Drug free for life NPC class......then go compete again everyone in the open class on test. If you feel corrisone shots is a no-no contract the fight/match to not allow cortisone shots.
I was tempted to compare tinting windows to HRT as you comapred HRT to chemo but I will refrain because its irrelevant.

I just love debating with guys that tihnk the rules are the rules are the rules....it generally shows how their basis for opinion isn't based on anything scientific, but perception and "its the rules".

Cortisone shots and painkillers ---> making former NFL players lives miserable and costing millions in healthcare costs ---> legal to sports organizations --> can actually inject on the sidelines

HRT ----> making the majority of people lives better ----> illegal because its the boogeyman and needles are evil

Strong logic is strong.
 

kisaj

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
I thought this was about what is natural and what isn't, not what is allowed and what isn't?
 
Admin

Admin

Administrator
Staff member
Awards
4
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
  • Established
I thought this was about what is natural and what isn't, not what is allowed and what isn't?
So if someone brings up a point of what is allowed, we shouldn't respond?
 

kisaj

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
Huh? I don't know what that has to do with anything, but my comment was more general in nature because one thing has nothing to do with the other.
 
Chuck Diesel

Chuck Diesel

Are you Diesel?
Awards
1
  • Established
I thought this was about what is natural and what isn't, not what is allowed and what isn't?
Its really abt that but it turned into both those bc the natural-ness of hrt is being justified by x y z being legal.
 
Admin

Admin

Administrator
Staff member
Awards
4
  • Best Answer
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
  • Established
Huh? I don't know what that has to do with anything, but my comment was more general in nature because one thing has nothing to do with the other.
Actually its does since its the basis for many of what the sports organizations deem legal/illegal....so my point remains....if they deem HRT as not natural, why do they allow other substances that are not as well.
 

Top