[ofwolfandman]

hey guys I was wondering which would be better for fat loss...a TKD or just a regular split like 40%protein, 30%carbs, and 30%fat or something like that. Im doing the TKD now and seem to be seeing some results but Im going crazy. As long as I keep calories under maintenance, I should see results either way, right? Or is the TKD better? Thanks

[ofwolfandman]

by the way im on the tkd right now, 180 pounds, eating around 2200 cals a day. if i eat more of a tradtiona diet but keep it at 2200 cals, would the results be the same?

[OCCFan023]

It depends on how you respond to each diet. No one here knows what you should do to loose weight. If you are seeing results on the TKD then keep it up. If you find you can't handle the low carbs than switch to a more conventional approach like you mentioned.

Its all about how your body responds to certain aspects. Find principles that work for you and make an individualized plan. Thats your best course of action.

[Manimalia]

i am no expert at all, but i am of the opinion that it wouldn't make much difference either way. however, i am gonna assume that with the TKD, your carb intake will be lower/fat intake will be higher than with a traditional diet. i think that a TKD, having said this, will be better for you, as you will only take in carbs when you NEED THEM, which i would imagine be a few in the morning, a few more before/after workouts?

it sounds like the TKD is a bit for you to get used to. it sounds like you become overwhelmed with how many/where to place your carbs in your day. i would say just work to where you don't have to go above 100g on training days, and at the end of the week, up them on an off day and have what i guess is called a 're-feed.'

[ofwolfandman]

so im 180 pounds.....so i take 180x15 to get my maintenance right? which is 2700. so how much of a deficit should i be in? 500?

[OCCFan023]

Thats a pretty general rule of thumb to find your calorie needs but you also have to adjust it to account for expenditure through gym and other activities. A deficit of 200-500 is a great place to start.

[EasyEJL]

really the tkd is probably one of the more useful low carb diet schemes, in that you can still get a small amount of carbs every workout. it is easier to loose fat with a lower carb diet for most people, and if you have only been on it a couple weeks it does tend to get easier to manage over time.

Fat gains generally come from insulin related response, which come from carbs.

Getting your body "used" to oxidizing fats for energy by having no carbs but high fat in the diet makes it easier to burn the fat that is already on your body.

What does your tkd look like in terms of 1 day's worth of eating?

[ofwolfandman]

well it's not too interesting since im at college and only have access to a limited amount of stuff. in the dining halls, it is really hard to eat to the specifications of a tkd. i have decided that a tkd diet is not right for me at this point in time because it's too hard being at school and everything. so, how does this look for a fat loss diet:

60 grams of fat
150-170 grams of carbs
200 grams of protein

I am 180, and this comes out to 2200 calories. I would eat the majority of my carbs at breakfast and after my workouts. I lift three times a weeks. MON. chest/back TUES. Shoulders/Arms WED. Legs The other days I walk at an incline on the treadmill for about an hour and 80% of my heart rate. So I have a couple questions...

1) Would this yield roughly the same results as the TKD?
2) On my cardio days, should I still consume carbs after my workout, at breakfast, etc.?

Thanks!

[Manimalia]

Originally Posted by ofwolfandman

well it's not too interesting since im at college and only have access to a limited amount of stuff. in the dining halls, it is really hard to eat to the specifications of a tkd. i have decided that a tkd diet is not right for me at this point in time because it's too hard being at school and everything. so, how does this look for a fat loss diet:

60 grams of fat
150-170 grams of carbs
200 grams of protein

I am 180, and this comes out to 2200 calories. I would eat the majority of my carbs at breakfast and after my workouts. I lift three times a weeks. MON. chest/back TUES. Shoulders/Arms WED. Legs The other days I walk at an incline on the treadmill for about an hour and 80% of my heart rate. So I have a couple questions...

1) Would this yield roughly the same results as the TKD?
2) On my cardio days, should I still consume carbs after my workout, at breakfast, etc.?

Thanks!

you've relegated yourself to failure. it's NOT hard. you CAN do it. tell us the foods in your dining hall that are served on a regular basis. tell us in detail. in addition to your three meals, tell us the 'snacks' or 'mini-meals' as i call them you purchase from your local grocer that you keep in your room. if you do not have these things in your room, plan on getting them.

surely then someone can help you make it work EASILY. and you can then walk around getting cut up looking at all them other college lifters with their uniforms of bloat mockingly. hahahah! i'm on the Anabolic Diet. The snacks I'd have in my room'd be whey, cheese sticks, olive oil to mix with the whey, walnuts, and heavy cream. that's a tentative example.

[ofwolfandman]

I didn't say I couldn't do it, I just said that I would rather do a more traditional diet that's all.

[OCCFan023]

Originally Posted by ofwolfandman

I didn't say I couldn't do it, I just said that I would rather do a more traditional diet that's all.

It will be a very smart idea to choose a diet (rather a nutritional plan) that you know you won't be suffering through will be able to complete it (low carb/carb cycling certainly isn't for everyone.)

You would be fine doing a more traditional diet man, because in reality at the end of the day it comes down to calorie intake vs calorie expenditure (your in a net deficit you will loose weight.) Set up a diet that consists of the macros you laid out and see how your fat loss comes along. Then you tweak it until you are satisfied with the results.

[EasyEJL]

yeah, a CKD/TKD's main benefit is that it is almost nearly impossible to add more fat while on it (even if cals go over maintenance), and that in general fats tend to add more of a satisfying feel to meals. tuna on dry whole grain bread isnt' too exciting, tuna + cheese over greens is a little better

[delsolrob]

Originally Posted by ofwolfandman

well it's not too interesting since im at college and only have access to a limited amount of stuff. in the dining halls, it is really hard to eat to the specifications of a tkd. i have decided that a tkd diet is not right for me at this point in time because it's too hard being at school and everything. so, how does this look for a fat loss diet:

60 grams of fat
150-170 grams of carbs
200 grams of protein

I am 180, and this comes out to 2200 calories. I would eat the majority of my carbs at breakfast and after my workouts. I lift three times a weeks. MON. chest/back TUES. Shoulders/Arms WED. Legs The other days I walk at an incline on the treadmill for about an hour and 80% of my heart rate. So I have a couple questions...

1) Would this yield roughly the same results as the TKD?
2) On my cardio days, should I still consume carbs after my workout, at breakfast, etc.?

Thanks!

what we "know" about you, you're:

• age: 22
• weight: 180
• height: 5'10"
• you're a student
• you want to lose weight

some things I think would make it easier for us to help you:

• what's your BF%?
• training experience?
• how much weight have you lost and in how long?
• what are your goals? target (could be weight or BF%) and time frame to achieve you goal
• you're a student, how flexible is your schedule and how much time are you willing to commit?

[delsolrob]

Originally Posted by ofwolfandman

well it's not too interesting since im at college and only have access to a limited amount of stuff. in the dining halls, it is really hard to eat to the specifications of a tkd. i have decided that a tkd diet is not right for me at this point in time because it's too hard being at school and everything. so, how does this look for a fat loss diet:

Also, IMO any diet where you don't have control over your nutrition is bound for failure...

how many meals per week do you actually cook/prep yourself?

[ofwolfandman]

I prepare a lot for myself...the only times I eat in the dining hall is breakfast, lunch, and dinner. My bf% is around 15, my goal in a couple months is 10%.