A Oldy but Goody
- 05-29-2006, 06:35 PM
A Oldy but Goody
An oldy but goody I dug up off my hdd from IronAddict:
Don't "lose it" while losing it!
Most trainees lose WAY too much size and strength when losing bodyfat. They simply go to extremes with caloric restriction, while usually being miles away from optimal macro-nutrient profiles. Add to much high intensity cardio and you have a great recipe for catabolism.
With the proper approach to diet and training you should continue to build strength the whole time you diet. I know this may sound like heresy to people that have been lead to believe that the best one can hope for is holding onto what you have or more likely only losing a little muscle while dieting. THESE PEOPLE ARE FLAT OUT WRONG!
You CAN build substantial amounts of muscle WHILE losing bodyfat. This is what I have the majority of my trainees doing. Not because this is the ideal situation, but simply because most people come to me overweight and under-muscled. It is NOT an optimal situation as it is easier to build muscle in an environment with an abundance of macro-nutrients and kcals.
But……..that doesn't mean you need to be a lard-ass to build muscle. An optimal situation is getting the trainee down to 7-8% then doing a mass phase and "bulk”, to 10-12% and repeat.
THERE IS NO REASON TO WALK THROUGH LIFE A FAT-ASS WHILE GAINING MASS. IT CAN BE DONE VERY EFFECTIVELY WHILE BEING RELATIVELY LEAN. You will look and feel much better about yourself if bodybuilding is your goal.
I rarely make drastic changes to routines from mass to cutting cycles. The only things that may change is a slight decrease in volume if someone is being very aggressive with bodyfat loss. And by the way, I do not recommend this approach. Being extreme, as in trying to strip fat at a very fast rate is usually a recipe for catabolism. With the proper approach to diet and training you should continue to build strength the whole time you diet. I know this may sound like heresy to people that have been lead to believe that the best one can hope for is holding onto what you have or more likely only losing a little muscle while dieting. THESE PEOPLE ARE FLAT OUT WRONG! If you are training and dieting properly you will be able to add strength and at least a some size while stripping the fat.
Let me take the time to address those people (trainers especially) that use weight training to burn additional calories. This is soooooo absolutely mis-guided. Lifting weights is an anaerobic activity. The energy pathways are mostly ATP and glycogen. Doing endless sets in the gym to burn more calories is a cruel joke played out on those people that subscribe to its practice. Weight training should be used to stimulate muscle growth....period.
Aerobic work is what you need to increase fat loss. Light intensity cardio, done at an intensity level that will allow one to talk fairly normal while being done is the best activity for using fat as a fuel source and keeping catabolism from occurring. The rest is up to diet, which should be a timed carb diet, as in little or no carbs until post workout. To answer your question in brief, the same routine that works best for you while focusing in size should be the one you use while dieting.
I will post much more info here about how to go about losing body-fat effectively without becoming "Captain Catabolic", or spending your whole life on a treadmill. Until I do though, here is a hint.....timed carb diet. Just enough carbs to:
Keep performance good
Keep you from going crazy, like when you do a keto diet
Keep thyroid from shutting down
Retain some semblance of being semi-normal (not really)
Once you understand the ratio's it's simple as can be to balance the macro-nutrient profiles/K-Cals to give you whatever degree of fat loss is desired. WHILE maintaining progression in the gym! Yes, you should still be able to continue to make progress with your poundage's while the bodyfat slips away. If you're not able to build strength and add at least a reasonable amount of muscle while dieting, you are simply doing it wrong, or are being WAY to aggressive with caloric restriction, or overzealous with cardio--or both.
There are no surefire percentage guidelines to use that can determine the correct macro nutrient profile. Two routines I wrote very recently are a good example. Both lifters weighed approximately the same amount (200+- a few lbs) and both had the same goal of gaining LBM while keeping fat gain minimal. Based on responses to my questionnaire and the subsequent phone interviews the diets varied 1200 calories a day for these two. Without knowing a lot more, here are a couple of guidelines and info-bits to take into account:
Protein should be 1.5-2 grams per lb of bodyweight unless you are WAY overweight, in which case it should be scaled back somewhat.
If you are getting fat, either overall kcals are too high, or carbs are too high. Usually the latter. If bodyfat is coming on too fast, reduce the carbs until:
A) Fat loss gains subside
B) Performance starts to suffer
If B) occurs first add a few more carbs and reduce fats to compensate for the cals if needed.
A couple other things that are important are:
No carbs at least 3 hours before bed, unless it is post-workout.
No fast cartbs unless it is post-workout.
Do the “Anarchy Stack” while bulking. It will help keep you lean.
Doing low intensity cardio 3-6 times a week will help keep you lean with little impact on gains unless you are a fairly extreme hardgainer or have a physical labor job.
These are just a few pieces of the puzzle, and I will keep adding to it. Don't want to give it all up at once-lol.
OK, Here is more info for everyone:
Timed Carb Dieting
Most of the people that come to me seeking personal training advice have their number one priority listed as dropping bodyfat. And when I say most, I am talking about 75-80%. The sad part is a big percentage of those people were NOT fat when they started bodybuilding. Yes, they got that way trying to “bulk up”. I guess you can say they were successful at “bulking” if you consider fat to be “bulk”. What they should have been doing is “muscling up”. That is rarely done until the trainee is quite experienced. The yo-yo approach can work well if you are blessed with a great metabolism……few are. Had they done it right they wouldn’t be in that situation. But, past mistakes are best left in the past. This article is about how to leave those mistakes in the past where they belong, and give you some general guidelines about timed-carb dieting, which I FIRMELY believe is the best approach to dropping the bodyfat while at a bare minimum retaining 100% of your muscle mass, and in the VAST majority of cases, adding some muscle and lots of strength while shedding the unwanted fat.
Before I outline the timed carb strategy, I am going to go over the typical types of diets followed by those in search of their abs, and talk about the pros and cons of each technique. Lets get started!
Low calorie, low fat diets
This is probably the #1 approach taken by those that have taken the plunge into the realm of dieting and it also happens to be the #1 reason many are afraid to diet. Why are they afraid? Because past experience has taught them that when dieting, they lose hard-earned muscle. And with this type of diet you can EXPECT at least a 50/50 muscle to fat loss ratio! YES! You lose 10 lbs and at LEAST 5 is usually muscle!!! Why? You first need to understand a bit about bodyfat metabolism. Your body stores bodyfat as “reserve fuel” in case of famine. Which is not much of a problem in today’s world in industrialized countries. OK, now you’re fat and you decide to drop it using this approach. The problem is, that when carbs are present, the fat burning pathways, which are driven by an enzymatic process are SHUT-DOWN, because carbs produce the release of insulin in your system, and insulin stops the enzymatic processes that allows you to burn bodyfat as a fuel source.
But wait! Calories are too low to fuel basal metabolism, and since your body can’t burn fat what is left? Ahhhh, you guessed it! Protein! Where does this protein come from? Well first your body will convert the recently ingested protein to glucose, but that still doesn’t cover daily caloric demands. So what next? Yup, your body starts catabolizing it’s own muscle to use as a fuel source, and…..you LOSE!
This is the diet made famous by Barry Sears of the “Zone Diet” fame. The idea here is to make the diet as balanced between protein/carbs/fats as possible and reduce insulin secretion as much as possible. These types of diets do quite a bit better at holding onto muscle while beating down the fat than low-cal, low-fat diets, but once caloric levels get low enough to drop bodyfat levels at a reasonable rate, you will still be chewing up a bunch of muscle unless on a LOT of gear, and you won’t really be on an ISO ratio if you are going to be getting enough protein to build/maintain muscle. These types of diets (with additional protein skewing a true iso-caloric profile) are GREAT while adding mass, but not really what the bodybuilder needs to get rid of bodyfat. Same problem as listed above arises since carbs/insulin are still present.
These diets are based on the fact that when you reduce carbs to ZERO, and keep it that way for a period of anywhere from 12 hours to 48 hours (dependant an a variety of factors) your body will shift from first burning carbs, to then burning fats, to ultimately converting fats into ketones, and using the ketones as the primary fuel source. The name given to this process is ketosis, hence the name keto-diet. Keto diets are protein sparing, which means your body will tend to hold on to protein (muscle) which is exactly what we want when dieting.
These diets do work extremely well for dropping bodyfat while holding onto muscle. Just what the aspiring bodybuilder wants. So what’s the catch? Well……the catch is that to achieve and stay in actual ketosis, you usually have to be carb-free about 2 days. These diets are typically done by going without any carbs for 5 days (sometimes 6) and then doing a 1 or 2 day “carb-up” and repeating the cycle. Sound simple? Try it and then tell me how easy it is. If you can breach that stumbling block, you then reach the second problem. Without ANY carbs for so many days performance in the gym suffers. So while these diets are protein sparing, they don’t allow you to go all out in the gym, and you end up losing strength because you are held at reign in the gym. The third big reason they fail many is because with zero carbs, and low calorie levels, thyroid metabolism tends to get S-L-O-W-E-R. Bad thing! Even with these drawbacks, this is not a bad diet for dropping bodyfat and definitely many notches above the previously mentioned diets. But……there is a better way! Enter timed-carb dieting!
Timed Carb Diets
A timed carb diet works on the same basic principle as a keto-diet. Take away the bodies preferred fuel source (carbs) and provide enough fat in the diet that the body will switch to using fat as the fuel. But instead of going 5-6 days without ANY carbs, this diet allows you to take in carbs when they are most needed, and least likely to spill over into fat stores—right after the workout. Also, since we are not worried about actually hitting ketosis and staying in ketosis, if you slip, or just feel the need to bump up carbs a bit to replenish glycogen stores, you didn’t just bump yourself out of the ketogenic state you just spent 2 days to achieve.
What do these diets accomplish?
Fat is burned as the preferred fuel source and protein (read that muscle) is spared.
Performance in the gym stays good.
Thyroid function remains higher for a longer period of time.
You don’t go out of your head waiting 5 days to eat some damn carbs!
OK, now the how-to of a timed carb diet. Again, we are trying to get the body to switch from being a carb or protein-burning machine into a fat burning machine. Remember, if caloric levels are low, and carbs, thus insulin is high, your body will convert protein to carbs via glucogenisys and that is to be avoided at all costs. Anyway, to get on the path of burning fat as fuel, we simply remove the carbs out of the equation, AND keep fat in the diet at (at least) a 40-50% ratio. This lets the body know there is still a primary fuel source (fat) and allows it to be burned as fuel, while sparing protein
So, we decide to start a timed carb diet on Monday. Sunday night you cut out the carbs about three hours before bed. When you wake up in the morning blood sugar levels will be very low, and your body will be wanting some carbs---too bad, it doesn’t get any! You will eat only fat and protein. Ensuring fat makes up at LEAST 40% of the caloric profile. You may have a leafy green salad with oil based dressing, or some string-beans, or other such low-carb veggie, BUT NO MORE THAN 6-8 grams of carbs per feeding. You keep this up right until pre-workout, where an apple is allowed IF you feel the need to put a few carbs in your system to raise energy levels. MOST guys do not find this to be necessary and if it does not provide a big advantage DON’T do it. If the carbs don’t help much, have a small protein drink and proceed with the workout.
Post-workout, and it’s time to replenish the carb-stores in the muscles you just worked. As the vast majority of you already know, immediately after a hard weight training session there is a “window of opportunity” in the muscle cell when insulin sensitivity is very high and the body is most receptive to nutrient uptake. So…..you slam down 65-100 grams of fast liquid carbs (malto-dextrin, dextrose, and yes, even sucrose will work). About 10 minutes later follow it up with a 65-100 gram whey protein drink. As soon as you are hungry again, you can eat a small “regular” meal with a 40/30/30 protein/carb/fat profile to “top off the tank” of glycogen stores in the muscle. Then, you are back to zero or trace amounts of carbs until the next workout.
You then repeat the this format for a maximum of five days, and then have a 1-2 day carb-up. On days that you don’t train, you don’t eat any carbs except for a green salad or two. You do not have to run these no carb to carb days for the full five days and for many of you, having a lower ratio of no carb Vs. carb days will be advantageous. Also you do NOT have to do the carb days back-to back. You may do a couple of no carb days, followed by one or more carb days. This is determined on YOUR metabolism and how fast you want to drop the bodyfat.
Pretty simple huh? Well, I haven’t given you ALL the details, but close enough to get most of you at least much closer to being able to put together a successful diet plan on your own, and if you want to have ALL the details in place, consider having me train you!
Do’s and don’ts:
If you don’t keep the fat ratio AT LEAST 40% your body will just continue to use carbs as fuel. How does this happen if all you are eating is chicken breasts as an example? Well your body has no problems converting protein to carbs and WILL do this if it doesn’t sense an alternate fuel source (fats.)
This type of diet tends to work best with lower overall workout days, so if you are a volume trainer who is in the gym 6 days a week (bad idea in any case IMO) you will see decreased results since every day will be a carb day. It will still work however.
Log your food intake for at LEAST a week to ensure you are hitting your numbers for both macro-nutrient profile, and overall kcals. You might just find out how far off you are from where you “thought” you were.
Your carb-up days are designed to refill the glycogen stores in the muscle, and bump up caloric levels a bit to keep your thyroid off balance. They are not go all-out berserk pig-out days. MANY, MANY lifters make this mistake and cancel out all the fat loss they achieved up until the carb-up day(s).
Do cardio when dieting. No it is not mandatory, but it makes such a big difference for such little effort and time expended that is extremely short-sighted to not include it as part of your fat-loss plan.
Don’t be in a big hurry to drop the bodyfat. You didn’t get fat overnight (well, some of you almost did) so don’t try to lose it overnight. You should work along the lines of about this much fat loss a week:
150-200 lb trainees, 1.5 lbs a week
200-250 lb trainees, 2 lbs a week
250+ 2 to 2-1/2b lbs a week
Going much more aggressive than that and strength gains will slow or stop, and catabolism may set in.
If you are just starting a reduced volume (or realistic training program) the scale may be worthless at first. Many people are able to gain a significant amount of muscle when dieting like this. Use the mirror and calipers (or better yet hydro-static weighing) to determine your rate of success.
You WILL end up looking flat by day 3-4, this is NOT representative of what you will look like when fully carbed-up. Remember, each gram of glycogen in the muscle brings 3 grams of water with it. When glycogen stores are down (and they will be) when doing low carbs you will “appear” smaller. It’s just water, don’t sweat it!
This type of diet lends itself well to getting a large percentage of daily caloric levels from protein powder and EFA’s (essential fatty acids), and that makes it convenient to do.
I will at some point put out another article aimed at how to stay lean while adding mass, and as you might guess it is a variation of this basic format.
There you go, get that damn bodyfat off you and become a true bodybuilder. You know, one who isn’t afraid to take his shirt off-lol.
- 05-29-2006, 07:58 PM
- 5'8" 230 lbs.
- Join Date
- Dec 2003
- Rep Power
- Lv. Percent
Excellent information although I went crossed eyed by the end and had to knock myself in the head with a board to straighten them
I think it's the fine tuning and time spent that kills the thought of gaining muscle and losing fat. Takes longer than doing one at a time and takes more managing versus eat it all and eat a little. I think it's probably the healthiest long term considering you're not hitting any extremes in either direction.
- 06-01-2006, 12:51 AM
You stole my diet, LOL.
This is exactly the diet I cobbled together over 12 yrs ago in my late 20's early 30's, after nearly 16 yrs of training/bodybuilding, and weak success dieting for Shows, or just to get lean.
I really put together the best advice I gleaned, and step by step arrived at this very diet, or very nearly this diet.
By my mid 30's I used this diet to get completly shredded, and had success in BB contest.
I taught it to many guys, or say I tried, they would ask "how did you got so shredded", but they mostly got scared by certain aspects of the diet.
It really can be a eating program that you can use year round, just by dialing in and out the carbs, and cardio.
The one big mistake I have made on this diet is not eating enough fat on no carb days, or during non-carb meals.
I will add a few pointers, and cautions.
It can easily become Catabolic, therefore, "supplementation" is highly recommended. Alot of guys on this board use PH, thats good, there are of course other products also.
Guys with Fast Metabolism should be very careful on this type diet, and may very well need to add, oatmeal or another good carb early in the day. Most of you young guys do not have to hit this as hard as us older guys, your bodies are furnaces, and hormonally jacked.
Additionally, AM cardio lights the fire for this diet, and, following AM cardio, NO CARBS, protein/fat meal only, scrambled whole eggs with carb free cheese is perfect.
Do not combine carbs & fats, another mistake I've made, even though I knew better.
On "re-feed days", eat your carbs, enjoy yourself, always use ALA with carb meals. However, it is not a "cheat day", don't break the rules, no carbs & fats together(no pizza, chinese food), eat Sorbet, or fat free frozen yogurt if you must, not full fat ice cream.
There are many fat free items, that are treats you can eat on re-feed day.
As was mentioned, you will get flat the 2nd-3rd day after "re-feed", and will fill out by the morning after re-feed, (in other words, 1 or 2 days a week you will get a really good "pump", and see the results of the diet as you progress).
This diet is great for those with slow metabolisms, older guys, (I'm 45 btw), and those which just don't respond well to Carbs/insulin, ie you get fat easily.
I am using this diet right now, and at 4 weeks I've lost well over 1 inch off my waist, and the veins & cuts are coming in nicely.
I don't go by pounds, in fact once I begin the diet I will not step on a scale untill I have dropped significant BF.
Typically, if you are holding a good deal of "love handles" you can expect 3/4 to 1 inch off your waist every 3 weeks.
An important rule is on days you don't lift weights, you eat zero or very low carbs, to make that more intense, I do AM cardio on that day, and a 2nd cardio session at night. I know thats brutal, but I know my body.
My goal is to never lose one molecule of muscle while dieting, it can be done.
The strictness of this diet and the diet itself is not for every one.
06-01-2006, 03:29 AM
While I don't doubt that this diet works, I think he is presenting a fair bit of his own theory to validate its superiority.
Firstly, he compares an extremely calorie restricted low fat diet to a moderately restricted calorie TKD diet; not apples to apples. The further you restrict calories the more you risk losing muscle.
No. If your calories are low, then you are not eating a ton of carbs so insulin will not be high but it will be elevated. Also elevated insulin levels do not promote gluconeogenesis; in fact it does the opposite. Why would your body breakdown protein into glucose when you just ate carbs that (surprise) yield glucose?if caloric levels are low, and carbs, thus insulin is high, your body will convert protein to carbs via glucogenisys and that is to be avoided at all costs.
Absolutely false. Resting fasting blood sugar level in a healthy person will be at normal baseline levels.When you wake up in the morning blood sugar levels will be very low.
Where did this 40% come from? So if it's 39% you're hooped? As I mentioned above carbs are also protein sparing. If his model was correct then gluconeogenesis would be proportional to carb intake and a carb based bulking diet would catabolize more muscle than a carb based cutting diet!If you don’t keep the fat ratio AT LEAST 40% your body will just continue to use carbs as fuel. How does this happen if all you are eating is chicken breasts as an example? Well your body has no problems converting protein to carbs and WILL do this if it doesn’t sense an alternate fuel source (fats.)
Sorry to be so anti about this but I think there are some very misleading statements in some of his arguments. IMO, at the time of writing, he did not have a very good understanding about insulin and blood glucose behaviour.
What is good to take away from his recommendations is not to diet with too great of an energy deficit otherwise you risk unacceptable muscle loss.
Similar Forum Threads
- By freqfly in forum General ChatReplies: 0Last Post: 02-02-2009, 08:28 PM
- By Basso in forum Powerlifting/StrongmanReplies: 6Last Post: 07-22-2006, 12:24 PM
- By wojo in forum AnabolicsReplies: 4Last Post: 10-15-2003, 06:58 PM