Na I dont hold back BS if I sense a load of it coming my way. I do agree, a good protein diet does help to add mass. Thats the point of this so called "game" Good diet (which may incorperate the use of protein shakes such as things like MM.) will slap on mass. It just depends on time.
Saying you gained 10 pounds when you drank muscle milk and making it sound like an instantaneous gain is wrong. I can attribute my natural gains to high calorie diet with training. Within my diet contained muscle milk which helped me to add 10 pounds of mass over a long period of time. Saying you took muscle milk and it slapped on 10 pounds is misleading and wrong.
As a regular member here, I dont think anyone would try to mislead someone on purpose. (although in some cases people prove me wrong :lol
I have a strong belief in my mind that you are working for Cytosport and trying to pimp some more muscle milk. Your claims sound like something they would put on a muscletech ad from so called "satisfied customers." It's so ludicrous that neither I or anyone else would really believe.
I do agree that a high calorie/high protein intake does lead to lean gains over time, however it doesnt happen instantly.