Creatine, yay or nay?

Page 2 of 3 First 123 Last

  1. Quote Originally Posted by Jiigzz View Post
    The body is predominantly water yes, but its where the water is held that some people have an issue with. And of course Creatine is effective, it was merely a hypothesis on whether or not it is as effective in a certain situation.
    Jiigzz I would never make it a habit to question your statements cuz I know you know your shyt. Point taken on where the retention occurs may not be for some. Carry on
    Independent Review


  2. i use it cuz its cheap but im convinced im a non responder....
    Nutraceutical Innovations
    AMINDS15 - 15% code
    nutra-innovations.com
    •   
       


  3. Quote Originally Posted by Dirty Dan View Post
    Creatine has without a doubt worked for me in the past and I could certainly feel a difference, as of lately not so much. Not to put Myogenix on blast but I have been using their 500g jug of micronized creatine and I have felt no difference whatsoever using it compared to other creatine monos I have used in the past, where I indeed felt a difference. It may very well boil down to the company and their quality of creatine.
    What is your favorite brand
  4. AnabolicMinds Site Rep
    Driven2lift's Avatar

    Definitely a staple for me, first supplement I ever used and it's what made me see the merit in supplementation and desire to try more, saw definite results from mono, switched to creature powder to limit bloat, have creigmite on route to try it out
    PEScience Representative; Use the code Driven for 30% off at pescience.com

  5. Creatine is a must. Most people who don't "see results" want it to have an immediate, intense response.
    Serious Nutrition Solutions Representative
    •   
       


  6. Definitely a staple. EAS labeled creatine mono was my first supplement about 15 years ago. Now label is mostly irrelevant but still a staple

  7. Quote Originally Posted by PalmFist View Post
    Jiigzz I would never make it a habit to question your statements cuz I know you know your shyt. Point taken on where the retention occurs may not be for some. Carry on
    FTR I love creatine, its cheap and tried-and-true.
    It works well in RST type situations which is probably the closest type of work: rest periods comparable with bodybuilding. Sorta.

  8. The first time I used it (10-15 years ago) I had great result but after that not so much... I have a bunch of bulk from NP but thinking of stopping cuz I really don't feel a differance..?

  9. Quote Originally Posted by Dirty Dan View Post

    I use to go to a local supplement shop down the street where the owner would make his own supplements and I had a lot of success with his brand. Besides that I have used ProLabs Creatine Mono which delivered good results as well, I have tried Muscle Pharms Creatine which was ok but way to expensive. To be honest I have not really used a diverse amount of creatine so I would be interested in what you have used and which one delivered results for you?
    Quote Originally Posted by Distilled Water View Post
    Creatine is a must. Most people who don't "see results" want it to have an immediate, intense response.
    Like dw said, I don't really see that immediate intense response. I look bigger and Fuller, and can usually bust out a few more reps or slightly more weight.
    I buy just about any creatine that's cheap, I believe I'm using sns right now, bought a kilo of it.

    I mostly use creatine for the recovery and gains*, like I said I don't see any ridiculous immediate response but I can definitely notice increased strength.

    *a hydrated muscle is an anabolic muscle
    *it's been proven to: decrease soreness,
    Increase lbm
    Increase protein synthesis

    I wrote my twenty page capstone paper on it. I'm sold on creatine, without a doubt

  10. I don't see why creatine shouldn't be considered as a staple in any strength training program. Whether it be Creatine Mono vs. all the different ester+Creatine products, thats up to individual preference. I for one found creatine monohydrate to be the most effective in composite gains in both mass and strength. Also whether it be from a very strict diet and nutrient optimization, but w/ creatine I experienced faster recovery from harder workouts( significant increase in endurance after 10 days, pushing past plateaus and failures).

    You shouldn't need really need more that 5 grams a day, as it has been suggested by various studies. Thus loading phase and anything over 10 grams/day is IMO a waste of money, unless you're carrying some serious mass and training at a competitive level. But I'm 5'5 and at the time 155 lbs, so 5-7 grams was perfect for me.

    I agree with the post above. The studies, the longevity of creatine in the industry makes it a must have supplement, especially if it's a cost effective creatine mono product.
    Former- Performax Labs Online Company Rep.
    [COLOR=#333333]

  11. My vote is an absolute yay, my five go to supplements for enhancing size and performance

    creatine monohydrate
    arachidonic acid
    beta alanine
    creatinol-o-phosphate
    and of course whey protein
    Molecular Nutrition - Unlevel The Field
    X-Factor: THE Most Scientifically Valid Muscle Builder, Ever!
    Sign up for INSANE deals via our newsletter: www.mninsider.com

  12. I don't see how this is even a question. It's one of the most studied supplements out there... If you don't trust/believe in using it for strength/size/recovery I wouldn't trust anything else..
    My current UNsponsored PES EP cutting log:http://anabolicminds.com/forum/supplement-reviews-logs/234161-adonisbelts-pes-erase.html

  13. Quote Originally Posted by SwolenONE View Post
    My vote is an absolute yay, my five go to supplements for enhancing size and performance

    creatine monohydrate
    arachidonic acid
    beta alanine
    creatinol-o-phosphate
    and of course whey protein
    Creatin-o-phosphate? Why is that necessary if your already saturated with creatine?
    My current UNsponsored PES EP cutting log:http://anabolicminds.com/forum/supplement-reviews-logs/234161-adonisbelts-pes-erase.html

  14. Quote Originally Posted by AdonisBelt View Post
    Creatin-o-phosphate? Why is that necessary if your already saturated with creatine?
    You can read up about COP in the Peak Beta+ write up, aside from similarities in name, creatinol-o-phosphate isnt a form of creatine, it is an ergogen much like beta alanine (I personally rarely use beta alanine as of late due to prefering COP) that shines for muscular endurance.

    http://www.nutraplanet.com/product/m...-180-caps.html
    Molecular Nutrition - Unlevel The Field
    X-Factor: THE Most Scientifically Valid Muscle Builder, Ever!
    Sign up for INSANE deals via our newsletter: www.mninsider.com

  15. I would never NOT use creatin, i never "noticed" anything, cept some bloat when at high doses. but i know its working and its cheap so why wouldent i? :-)

    i just use soem bulk creatin either MH1000 or some bulk mono from tp.
    LG Sciences Board Rep
    These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA, do not constitute medical advice, and are not official or authorized comments by LG Sciences, LLC.

  16. Try primaforce cee if the mono gives you the bloat. I'm loving the cee

  17. Quote Originally Posted by Jiigzz View Post
    Its hard to say I notice anything from creatine or feel ay different. TBH I feel like many people supplement with it without a real idea of how to benefit from it; often BBers may use it but since rest periods are often low (30-60s) this isn't enough time for the body to fully restore PCr stores therefore the body switches to glycolysis.

    Strength + power athletes imo, get more benefit out of it as rest periods are much longer, thus allowing for full restoration of PCr and, as Creatine increases PCr capacity, it should translate into more reps.

    I'd love to see what @JudoJosh thinks about this.
    Creatine is one of the very few actually proven ergogenic aids we have in this game. That said its MOA is still really not quite fully understood and their are "non-responders" but as mentioned earlier in this thread, it is so freaking cheap I cant see any reason why someone wont at least give it a shot.
    PESCIENCE.COM

    "The only good is knowledge and the only evil is ignorance." - Socrates

  18. This one is pretty controversial

    Three weeks of creatine monohydrate supplementation affects dihydrotestosterone to testosterone ratio in college-aged rugby players.

    Abstract

    OBJECTIVE:
    This study investigated resting concentrations of selected androgens after 3 weeks of creatine supplementation in male rugby players. It was hypothesized that the ratio of dihydrotestosterone (DHT, a biologically more active androgen) to testosterone (T) would change with creatine supplementation.

    DESIGN
    Double-blind placebo-controlled crossover study with a 6-week washout period.

    SETTING:Rugby Institute in South Africa.

    PARTICIPANTS:College-aged rugby players (n = 20) volunteered for the study, which took place during the competitive season.

    INTERVENTIONS:Subjects loaded with creatine (25 g/day creatine with 25 g/day glucose) or placebo (50 g/day glucose) for 7 days followed by 14 days of maintenance (5 g/day creatine with 25 g/day glucose or 30 g/day glucose placebo).

    MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES:Serum T and DHT were measured and ratio calculated at baseline and after 7 days and 21 days of creatine supplementation (or placebo). Body composition measurements were taken at each time point.

    RESULTS:
    After 7 days of creatine loading, or a further 14 days of creatine maintenance dose, serum T levels did not change. However, levels of DHT increased by 56% after 7 days of creatine loading and remained 40% above baseline after 14 days maintenance (P < 0.001). The ratio of DHT:T also increased by 36% after 7 days creatine supplementation and remained elevated by 22% after the maintenance dose (P < 0.01).

    CONCLUSIONS:
    Creatine supplementation may, in part, act through an increased rate of conversion of T to DHT. Further investigation is warranted as a result of the high frequency of individuals using creatine supplementation and the long-term safety of alterations in circulating androgen composition.

    STATEMENT OF CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Although creatine is a widely used ergogenic aid, the mechanisms of action are incompletely understood, particularly in relation to dihydrotestosterone, and therefore the long-term clinical safety cannot be guaranteed.
    So as you can see it seems quite plausible that creatine may have some sort of effect on DHT but as far as I know the results have never been replicated. None the less it is still quite interesting IMO
    PESCIENCE.COM

    "The only good is knowledge and the only evil is ignorance." - Socrates

  19. Quote Originally Posted by JudoJosh View Post
    Creatine is one of the very few actually proven ergogenic aids we have in this game. That said its MOA is still really not quite fully understood and their are "non-responders" but as mentioned earlier in this thread, it is so freaking cheap I cant see any reason why someone wont at least give it a shot.
    Agreed, as I noted above it does have a positive effect on RST performance which, assumingly (without the FT) would have rest periods similar to that of BBing.

    Quote Originally Posted by JudoJosh View Post
    This one is pretty controversial



    So as you can see it seems quite plausible that creatine may have some sort of effect on DHT but as far as I know the results have never been replicated. None the less it is still quite interesting IMO
    Yikes. I hope somebody does replicate this..

  20. Quote Originally Posted by nidhogg View Post
    Overrated. People use it because its dirt cheep and lets you pull off that extra rep or two due to more efficient energy utilization. So far i haven't seen a single study supporting long term results in terms of lean mass gains. All studies i read measure muscle girth when fully creatine loaded, no fkin **** they are gonna be bigger then.

    Other than that its got a dozen of other health benefits, but hey there are about 1000 other stuff you could also be taking that provides general health benefits. By the end of the day you'll be popping pills like theres no tomorrow. There is nothing "special" about this one.
    Research further. There are several studies conducted for long periods of time. One done in D1 football players.

    Quote Originally Posted by SwolenONE View Post
    My vote is an absolute yay, my five go to supplements for enhancing size and performance

    creatine monohydrate
    arachidonic acid
    beta alanine
    creatinol-o-phosphate
    and of course whey protein
    Swollen knows what's up...

    I can't fathom any reason creatine would even be questioned except dumb asses spreading ridiculous broscience about.

    - Valdez
    The Physique Biochemist
    Biochemistry Major
    Your Physique AND Credentials Should Back Up Your Position

  21. Quote Originally Posted by Valdez View Post

    Research further. There are several studies conducted for long periods of time. One done in D1 football players.

    Swollen knows what's up...

    I can't fathom any reason creatine would even be questioned except dumb asses spreading ridiculous broscience about.

    - Valdez
    I've never used cop or ara but I've heard good things about both. If already using beta alanine, is cop overkill?

  22. Read up for the people saying it doesn't do anything.

    http://anabolicminds.com/forum/conte...benefits-3351/

  23. Quote Originally Posted by aceroni View Post
    I've never used cop or ara but I've heard good things about both. If already using beta alanine, is cop overkill?
    No way... A lot of people really enjoy the benefits of COP. Try it bulk to be able to manipulate dosing for what words best with you. I know we (SNS) carry it and Epharm does an effervescent.

    It's worth a try, if you've been on beta alanine for a while I would add it to everything you're currently using so you will be able to tell if any difference is made.

    - Valdez
    The Physique Biochemist
    Biochemistry Major
    Your Physique AND Credentials Should Back Up Your Position

  24. In a world full of snake oil, creatine is one of the only supplements not emptying peoples' wallets based on the placebo effect. It actually works. Imagine that.

  25. Quote Originally Posted by SXIPro View Post
    In a world full of snake oil, creatine is one of the only supplements not emptying peoples' wallets based on the placebo effect. It actually works. Imagine that.
    Well said

    - Valdez
    The Physique Biochemist
    Biochemistry Major
    Your Physique AND Credentials Should Back Up Your Position
  •   

      
     

Similar Forum Threads

  1. Creatine.... Yay? or Nay?
    By Elizabeth0215 in forum Female Fitness
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 09-10-2012, 06:12 PM
  2. Superman Returns 2006 - Suit: yay or nay?
    By Y2Jversion1 in forum General Chat
    Replies: 103
    Last Post: 06-21-2006, 03:55 PM
  3. Catfish...yay or nay?
    By rampage jackson in forum Nutrition / Health
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 06-11-2006, 02:03 AM
  4. Hot Sauce Yay or Nay?
    By ex_banana-eater in forum Weight Loss
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 02-03-2003, 10:02 PM
Log in
Log in