Affirmative Action / Do You Vote?
- 08-12-2009, 09:46 PM
Affirmative Action / Do You Vote?
A thread over at the Cannabis Culture forums prompted this response, I will post what I wrote unedited, so while this thread is aimed at the issues of affirmative action, you can also address the original question of "do you vote?"
I tend to vote NDP, but they along with the Green Party seem partial to affirmative action which is "reverse discrimination." Reverse discrimination only implies a directionality, i.e., it implies this is discrimination against the original discriminators. It is simply discrimination. Using discrimination to combat discrimination is clearly hypocritical. That does not sit well with me.
I also know why these policies are supported by some people and I respect their intentions. They start with the question "Do you believe that past events and conditions influence future events and generations?" Clearly, the answer is a resounding "Yes!" A child has a better chance of succeeding in life if they are from a well-off family for many reasons, I trust you people have sufficient imagination to abstract reasons of your own. Similarly, people of different backgrounds, particularly those who are decedents of a traditionally oppressed group, are likely to have been negatively affected by the past actions of our society. For example, white people had a better chance of leading good lives and very adequately supporting their families for a longer period of time than black people would.
However, is race really the problem? Is gender? Women make less money than men if doing the exact same job on average, this is true, but is the answer to enforce ethnic, gender, or other quotas? I don't think so. It's entirely possible a poor white person could be denied entrance into a law school over a minority with lesser qualifications. This not only is wrong because merit is not the determining factor, but also because it exactly contradicts the intentions of affirmative action. As I have already stated, the first contradiction is fighting discrimination with further discrimination. The second is that it is meant to equalize society, to make society more fair.
But what are the reasons why these groups are put in a disadvantageous position? Surely, racism is not absolutely eliminated from anywhere. With that said, though, I believe there are adequate laws in place and that society has progressed far enough such that we do not need to institute quotas. But the main reason these groups could be considered to be placed in disadvantageous positions is because of socioeconomic conditions. Does this mean that we should change affirmative action to be geared toward individuals of lower incomes? I don't think this is a good idea, either. It is a better idea, but still not a good idea. There is still the issue of the first contradiction (fighting discrimination with more discrimination).
I think we just need to invest more into social programs and into education. The student loan situation is not a good one and educating your populace is without question an investment. And to appeal to the core audience of this website, if we legalized marijuana, I am sure that the government would have even more funds to be able to help out those who are truly in need of help.
I hope what I said here isn't too far off topic. Just in case it is, I have one last thing to say with regards to voting. I saw Marc Emery speak today in St. John's, Newfoundland. It was a very good talk. Something he mentioned was that voting can change things, but not voting is absolutely worthless. This is true. If you feel like you have to choose between (to cite South Park) a giant douche or a turd sandwich, why even choose? Why be forced to choose between the lesser of two evils? Or maybe all options are not worthy of your vote for different and difficult to quantify reasons? In Canada, I think that they record the number of spoiled ballots. If this is the case, that is one option. In fact, it is the only option present that I can think of. Well, besides "strategically voting," which is very anti-democratic.
I would very much like to see an additional box on every ballot:
"None of the above."
- 08-18-2009, 04:25 AM
Where do I begin? haha This is a great post. I completely agree it affirmative action is reverse discrimination, but do understand some believe it is the only way they can find good jobs.
As far as race and gender, I don't think it is as big of a problem as some believe. I think alot of people think that because they don't get the job they want they assume its due to discrimination. I see that in my work. Example: a female I work with thinks the supervisor is being sexist because he doesn't use her for special assignments but when you look at her work product she doesnt have much if anything to show. That was her first conclusion without discussing it with him. I also see it with people claiming the race card. Maybe its me not seeing the real picture. I think I am pretty observant.
Also one thing I see alot of working in the lower income areas is the parents don't invest in their kids. I see alot of parents who don't interact with the kids when they are young (teaching them the abc's and 123's before they start school) then blaming the school and racism when their kid doesn't perform at the same level as others. Then they turn around and get money from the government because the child is labeled with a learning disability. This drives me crazy!! Sorry, I'll tryto stay off my soapbox.
I also agree that not voting is a waste but if we start voting more at the lower levels of government we can begin to change the higher levels. I mean how many times do people complain about the presidential or govenor candidates but don't know who is running for mayor, city council, and state reps and senators.
Anyways, definetely not as well thought out, but those are my opinions.
09-19-2009, 02:10 AM
My 19 year old son works two jobs, 60+ hours a week to pay for his college education. Yeah, that means 100+ hours a week between work and college - so what?
This idea of "entitlement" - using my tax dollars to pay for your loan because you're too lazy to get a job and bust your ass is one of the reasons America is going down the tube.
Stop smoking weed and get a job!!
Similar Forum Threads
- By bigbadboss101 in forum General ChatReplies: 15Last Post: 09-05-2014, 06:54 AM
- By Lifeguard in forum General ChatReplies: 7Last Post: 04-28-2010, 08:05 PM
- By AE14 in forum PoliticsReplies: 18Last Post: 05-11-2008, 01:47 PM
- By Sir Foxx in forum General ChatReplies: 2Last Post: 06-18-2004, 02:21 PM
- By bigbadboss101 in forum General ChatReplies: 28Last Post: 11-04-2002, 01:13 AM