I think both look good. I see a problem with the photos though. It's been said, the lighting is different, which, as we know, creates a huge difference. Maybe your skin is not as tan. Another issue, you're holding your arms differently. Looks like you're pulling your shoulders up in the second pic. That makes it difficult to really tell how you're looking, as it gives your body a more narrow appearance at the shoulders, which could make your torso look more wide. It is also pulling your chest up, which is taking away definition there. Looking just below your belly button though, it appears you DID cut some fat from the first photo. Again, you are looking good. You gotta have continuity as far as lighting and tan in order for us to make a real informed judgement.