I received my order for these two proteins and tried them both. I tried Vanilla Cake batter last night made into a shake/smoothie. I used ice, skim milk and some caramel topping. Honestly, it's too sweet and it's not from the caramel topping since I used that in all my past protein shakes and never had a overpowering sweet flavor like I did with this shake. I was hoping for something close to ATW's cupcake batter but it is sweeter then I expected. Almost like it's vanilla cake icing not batter.
This morning I made a shake/smoothie with CGC without caramel topping mixed in. I found it to almost taste like an iced coffee a little. Maybe it's just me but that is the flavor I got a hint of.