Does caramel candy bar = chocolate caramel? Because if so, that stuff was god awful. I've only been able to have like ten servings. I'm thinking about just throwing it away. Ive enjoyed choc peanut butter cup, chocolate, strawberry, cinnamon bun and cup cake batter. I had high hopes for it, it smelled great, then I tried it in milk and water and they both were bad. Milk I can choke down... water is a struggle. Hopefully I don't get attacked for this review. I only buy from ATW as my protein source, but I was extremely disappointed. Waste of my (limited) money.