article on shbg and diet AKA fiber plays a huge role

[hardasnails1973]

Invalid Link Removed

 

[Scottyo]

I found this line interesting:
Vegetarians consuming about 50 grams of fiber a day excrete in stool samples approximately twice as much estrone,
estradiol-17 b and testosterone compared to omnivores consuming 20 grams of fiber a day.2

so fiber might not be bad to get rid of bad estrogens, but might impact test too? YEt for those of us on HRT (maybe because of estrogen imbalances)..and thus 'supported', who have normal shbg, fiber might be a good thing.

speaking of which...how much fiber soluble/insoluble you have these days HAN? I usually have some benefiber with breakfast and dinner (like half or 1/3 serving) plus my rice bran because of soluble fibers help in constipation as well as IBS issues. Plus I have some oatmeal with lunch...usually.

 

[MarkLA]

Here is the source for the fiber information which is cited in your article.

Invalid Link Removed

Interesting to look at the cholesterol consumption of the vegetarians vs. non vegetarians. There's a correlation there.

Possibly the fiber reduces cholesterol absorption and that's part of it..

 

[hardasnails1973]

Here is the source for the fiber information which is cited in your article.

Invalid Link Removed

Interesting to look at the cholesterol consumption of the vegetarians vs. non vegetarians. There's a correlation there.

Possibly the fiber reduces cholesterol absorption and that's part of it..

Bingo!!
Fiber binds with cholestrol as well as binds up fats possible causing EFA defieincy. I looked at all variables and that increase shbg and only one I have come up with is low insulin levels due to high fiber intake. Also beans contains lignands which I eat alot of 10 grams of fiber a day. I'm hitting about 30-40 grams of fiber a day easily and article mentions that 100 grams fat increase and lower the fiber to 20 grams a day caused a significant decrease in shbg. I not eating alot of fat like I should and may be the fiber is binding with what little fat I am eating and not being absorbed..It also mentioned that estrogens increase shbg but 64 million dollar question is will also estrogen metabolites do same thing. I have found reference to that altered metabolites cause estrogen domainace which in my case would put stress on adrenals and thyroid as indicated..So with shbg of 39 and e2 of 17 this caused an low free e2 and evidentible an e2 defiency hence altered homocysteine levels because of it. As e2 increased homocystiene levels increased and LP(A) droppde by over 40% HOW INTERESTING !!

By having low free e2 this would cause a decrease in serotonin and gaba levels as well as hypomethylation, imparing iodine uptake into thyroid as well as choline to produce acetylcholine. The lower estrogen levels would cause excessive stress to thyroid and adrenals and force more t4 to convert to t3. So with out proper e2 levels serotonin or 5hiaa metabolite (by product of serotonin metabolism ) would be low or like mine non existant, but the serotonin whole blood was perfect but it was just not turnuing over in the brain due to lack of e2 or build up of estrogen metabolism clogging the e2 receptors.

 

[MarkLA]

The study covers cholesterol intake not (unfortunately) cholesterol levels.

This is a subtle point, but we're hypothesizing that the fiber intake reduces cholesterol which reduces hormones. We know that oat bran reduces cholesterol, so this hypothesis is probably at least partly true. However is it responsible for all of the differences in T that we see in the study?

It also could be that the cholesterol intake in food is responsible for some (or most? or all?) of the T difference. The NV group ate about double the cholesterol of the vegetarian group.

In other words, it's not clear to me that eating less fiber is the route to more T. It may be that eating more cholesterol is the answer, or perhaps it's both.

Maybe for you, eating less fiber AND more cholesterol would be the way to go?

Mark

 

[dsade]

Why the dichotomy of either low-fat, high fiber or High-fat, low-fiber?

What about high-fat, high fiber?

 

[hardasnails1973]

The study covers cholesterol intake not (unfortunately) cholesterol levels.

This is a subtle point, but we're hypothesizing that the fiber intake reduces cholesterol which reduces hormones. We know that oat bran reduces cholesterol, so this hypothesis is probably at least partly true. However is it responsible for all of the differences in T that we see in the study?

It also could be that the cholesterol intake in food is responsible for some (or most? or all?) of the T difference. The NV group ate about double the cholesterol of the vegetarian group.

In other words, it's not clear to me that eating less fiber is the route to more T. It may be that eating more cholesterol is the answer, or perhaps it's both.

Maybe for you, eating less fiber AND more cholesterol would be the way to go?

Mark

Consider my shbg is high and fiber significant affects it plus all the beans ans legumes I eat contains lignands which increase shbg. I tihnk more so it not the cholesterol that is binding but more so the fat causing hormonal problems. I eat 4 whole organic eggs a day and was told flax seed oils is bad som I stay away from it because of certain reason, but in mean time I need my EFA in proper balance which i have not been getting as indicated on my RC fatty acid test. It may be that low e2 was affecting bile out put and affecting fat metabolism. I do not know. All I know is that My shbg was 20 and now its almost 40 and onyl thing I change was stoping fish oil and fish for 9 months due to EFA imbalances. In mean time my 16/2 ratio is way out of wack probably because of this.

 

[GOTSPEED]

Bingo!!
Fiber binds with cholestrol as well as binds up fats possible causing EFA defieincy. I looked at all variables and that increase shbg and only one I have come up with is low insulin levels due to high fiber intake. Also beans contains lignands which I eat alot of 10 grams of fiber a day. I'm hitting about 30-40 grams of fiber a day easily and article mentions that 100 grams fat increase and lower the fiber to 20 grams a day caused a significant decrease in shbg. I not eating alot of fat like I should and may be the fiber is binding with what little fat I am eating and not being absorbed..It also mentioned that estrogens increase shbg but 64 million dollar question is will also estrogen metabolites do same thing. I have found reference to that altered metabolites cause estrogen domainace which in my case would put stress on adrenals and thyroid as indicated..So with shbg of 39 and e2 of 17 this caused an low free e2 and evidentible an e2 defiency hence altered homocysteine levels because of it. As e2 increased homocystiene levels increased and LP(A) droppde by over 40% HOW INTERESTING !!

By having low free e2 this would cause a decrease in serotonin and gaba levels as well as hypomethylation, imparing iodine uptake into thyroid as well as choline to produce acetylcholine. The lower estrogen levels would cause excessive stress to thyroid and adrenals and force more t4 to convert to t3. So with out proper e2 levels serotonin or 5hiaa metabolite (by product of serotonin metabolism ) would be low or like mine non existant, but the serotonin whole blood was perfect but it was just not turnuing over in the brain due to lack of e2 or build up of estrogen metabolism clogging the e2 receptors.

What the?? Can somebody explain the second paragraph to me??

 

[The Matrix]

What the?? Can somebody explain the second paragraph to me??

Lamen's term
Estrogen defieincy can stress thyroid and adrenal function
It also can lower your neurotransmitters turn over.