Ecdy Causes Cancer?

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
I just ordered 2 bottles of the Ecdy, and have been real excited to give it a try. I read an old thread today, and it kind of scared me. Maybe my fears aren't warrented and you can relay some newer thoughts on these findings.


(was going to post a link to the thead "ecdysterone and cancer?" from bodybuilding dot com, but unfortunately I can't since my post count is so low)


Specifically the part in the middle of the thread where it says that ecdysterone was on a list submitted to the (national toxicology program), and determined to be carcinogenic by the national cancer institute. Also the part near the bottom of the thread that says 95% pure ecdysterone powder dust should not be inhaled or allowed to touch the skin. If this stuff shouldn't even touch the skin, then how safe could it be to orally ingest it? Not trying to cause any false alarm, and I'm sure you can provide some insight as to these findings. I've really been looking forward to trying the Ecdy, so hopefully you can ease my worries.
 
VaughnTrue

VaughnTrue

Well-known member
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
First off, no it won't cause cancer. PM me a link to what you're talking about
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
Ok here is my 7th post, so I should be able to send you a pm lol.
 

criticalbench

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
I am very interested to see this as well.

Mike
 
StackedCop

StackedCop

Well-known member
Awards
2
  • RockStar
  • Established
I cant post links until I have 20 posts, but if you google "ecdysterone and cancer", it will bring up a link from bbdotcom.
I hate bb dot come...

I never heard of this before, but if you look below the Bb, com post there's a bunch of links for ecdysterone fights cancer.:::
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
I'm not exactly a big fan either lol, but I did see some links that made me wonder. If you aren't supposed to breath the stuff or let it touch your skin, then wouldn't ingesting it be kind of scary?
 
StackedCop

StackedCop

Well-known member
Awards
2
  • RockStar
  • Established
I'm not exactly a big fan either lol, but I did see some links that made me wonder. If you aren't supposed to breath the stuff or let it touch your skin, then wouldn't ingesting it be kind of scary?
I'll look into it
 
poison

poison

Board Sponsor
Awards
3
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
Vaughn, WTF happened to your thread over there?
 
baldwanus

baldwanus

Well-known member
Awards
2
  • Established
  • RockStar
Does that surprise anyone? Lol
to be honest, i wasnt expecting it to turn out the way it did.......especially since the product was pretty much in positive light over here, figured it would at least stay half way civil
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
to be honest, i wasnt expecting it to turn out the way it did.......especially since the product was pretty much in positive light over here, figured it would at least stay half way civil
What happened? What did I miss?
 
wideguy

wideguy

Board Supporter
Awards
1
  • Established
I missed it too. I will poiny out(assuminh I am allowed to) that its used intramuscularly in some circles and I never heard of anyone getting cancer from using ecyd.
 
StackedCop

StackedCop

Well-known member
Awards
2
  • RockStar
  • Established
If ecdy causes cancer I will die a very young man...
 

criticalbench

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
I cant post links until I have 20 posts, but if you google "ecdysterone and cancer", it will bring up a link from bbdotcom.
Thanks for the insight bro.

BB.com is not a place a I really turn to for legit information, to many people on that board with far inferior knowledge and to much time on there hands to create drama. There are many good members there, but the bad over-ride the good imo.

Mike
 
StackedCop

StackedCop

Well-known member
Awards
2
  • RockStar
  • Established
Thanks for the insight bro.

BB.com is not a place a I really turn to for legit information, to many people on that board with far inferior knowledge and to much time on there hands to create drama. There are many good members there, but the bad over-ride the good imo.

Mike
I concur
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
Thanks for the insight bro.

BB.com is not a place a I really turn to for legit information, to many people on that board with far inferior knowledge and to much time on there hands to create drama. There are many good members there, but the bad over-ride the good imo.

Mike
Oh I hear ya man, and I totally agree. The thread did seem to contain some interesting stuff however. So am I the only one that wonders what harm might be done in ingesting something that isn't even supposed to come in contact with the skin? What about the link on the national cancer instutute declaring it a carcinogen? I'm not a hater and have 2 bottles on the way. I was hoping you guys could easy my worries lol. I sent Vaughn a pm with the info, but haven't heard back. This stuff only worries me??
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
I go tanning... daily! Bring it
Well, that definitely doesn't ease my worries any lol. I've had several family members die of cancer, and would rather not go that route personally :). I think I'll wait for vaughn to refute the claims and/or add new evidence to the contrary before I start taking my ecdy. I'd also still like to know why 95% pure extract isn't supposed to come in contact with your skin. I had hoped for someone to make me feel good about taking the ecdy, but saying "I'll die young, and bring it" isn't exactly the comfort I was looking for lol.
 
StackedCop

StackedCop

Well-known member
Awards
2
  • RockStar
  • Established
Sorry man, I'm not trying to down play the situation. It's just EVERYTHING nowa days causes cancer. I do my best to live a healthy life and I think it's safe to say most members here on AM do. Ecdy has always been known as a safe supplement but then bang there's someone at BB with a link to claims it causes cancer...

Bottom line I'm not worried for now. I've search ecdy for hours on end and never seen a health concern. Who knows maybe I missed something...
 
sapentia

sapentia

Member
Awards
0
I read this on Friday and sort of scratched my head without giving it too much thought at the time. Since then I've had a bit of time to think about it and here is my rationale for ecdysterone's safety. It is a significant component in spinach and quinoa right? We all know that it is, so if ecdy really caused cancer then it follows that spinach and quinoa would have to be carcinogenic too. Now, does anyone honestly think spinach causes cancer, seriously.

I will qualify the above with the following. I am not familiar with the plant that is used for the extraction of ecdy, but it is possible that lower purity extracts could contain some type of phytochemical which is carcinogenic, not ecdysterone though. This is my logic; I am not backing it up by any scientific studies, but in this case I honestly don't think it is necessary. I welcome your guys thoughts. I ordered 4 bottles of the 99% pure ECDY btw.
 
freefall365

freefall365

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
i think it's worth exploring even if there is a slight chance something can be a carcinogen. I haven't the slightest clue on ECDY, but let's not knock the OP, or anyone for that matter, on have a concern over safety of supplementation.
 

criticalbench

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
I go tanning... daily! Bring it
same same, hell some old lady at my gym who tans herself to death just got skin cancer.. scared me! Now i got melanotan :p
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
+1 on the melanotan lol :)! Ya hopefully Vaughn will post up soon with his take on this. I pm'd him the info like he asked, but he hasn't got back to me.
 
BB12

BB12

Well-known member
Awards
1
  • Established
Coffee used to be bad for you and now it has a ton of anti-ox. Hell the rank of the guy next to be in the stale as I breath could be effecting my lungs.

Enjoy your supplements and respect them, as your body is a work of art!



Damn, I must have taken my hemp sup ;)
 

sizematters10

Guest
very interested in hearing more about this, and of course I read this right after I ordered two bottles lol. positive studies or GTFO just kidding, just dont want to get spooked out of this like I did daa. any info would be appreciated....
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
very interested in hearing more about this, and of course I read this right after I ordered two bottles lol. positive studies or GTFO just kidding, just dont want to get spooked out of this like I did daa. any info would be appreciated....

Bummer! I had all my links posted, and then realized I need 50 posts before I can share a link...I thought it was 20. :11: I'll be back in a little bit lol...
 
sapentia

sapentia

Member
Awards
0
My initial foray into the abstracts leads me to believe that ecdysterone is actually anti-carcinogenic helping to lead to cancer cell aptosis.


Ecdysterone Modulates Antitumor Activity of Cytostatics and Biosynthesis of Macromolecules in Tumor-Bearing Mice

N. P. Konovalova, Yu. I. Mitrokhin, L. M. Volkova, L. I. Sidorenko and I. N. Todorov

Abstract
The influence of therapeutic and half doses of cisplatin and adriamycin combination with the anabolic drug ecdysterone (20-hydroecdison) on development of subcutaneously and intraperitoneally transplanted P388 and L1210 leukemia and metastasizing B16 melanoma was studied. Ecdysterone significantly stimulated the chemotherapeutic effect of low doses of the cytostatics: inhibition of tumor growth, mice survival rate, their lifespan, and the antimetastatic activity index were comparable or better than after therapy with high doses of the antitumor drugs. The influence of high and low doses of cisplatin and its low dose in combination with ecdysterone on the dynamics of protein and DNA biosynthesis in the liver, pancreas, thymus, spleen, and adrenals of tumor-bearing mice were also studied. Although the therapeutic effect of 4 mg/kg cisplatin by activated protein biosynthesis and DNA repair is comparable or better than that of its low dose (2 mg/kg) in combination with ecdysterone, in terms of chemotherapy the combination looks preferable since the therapeutic dose of cisplatin is toxic for the intact tissues.

________________________________________________

This is from a patent filing, note that beta-ecdysterone is listed for possible inclusion in a cancer therapy treatment:

Compositions of botanical extracts for cancer therapy
United States Patent Application 20050208070


The compositions can also be formulated with other active ingredients, such as anti-oxidants, vitamins (A, C, ascorbic acid, B's, such as B1, thiamine, B6, pyridoxine, B complex, biotin, choline, nicotinic acid, pantothenic acid, B12, cyanocobalamin, and/or B2, D, D2, D3, calciferol, E, such as tocopherol, riboflavin, K, K1, K2). Preferred compounds, include, e.g creatine monohydrate, pyruvate, L-Carnitine, α-lipoic acid, Phytin or Phytic acid, Co Enzyme Q10, NADH, NAD, D-ribose, amino acids such as L-glutamine, Lysine, chrysin; pre-hormones such as 4-androstenedione, 5-androstenedione, 4(or 5-)androstenediol, 19-nor-4 (or 5-)-androstenedione, 19-nor-4 (or 5-)-androstenediol, Beta-ecdysterone, and 5-Methyl-7-Methoxy Isoflavone. Preferred active ingredients include, e.g., pine pollen, fructus lycii, Hippophae rhamnoides, Ligusticum, Acanthopanax, Astragalus, Ephedra, codonopsis, polygola tenuifolia Willd, Lilium, Sparganiuma , ginseng, panax notogiseng, Garcinia , Guggle, Grape Seed Extract or powder, and/or Ginkgo Biloba.

___________________________________________________________

Not related to cancer but I found this interesting as mitochondrial maintenance/support supplementation is a focus of life extension supplementation.

Rhaponticum carthamoides ( Leuzea carthamoides , or Maral Root) contains a mixture of compounds called ‘levseins’. Levseins represents a complex of more than 10 ecdysterones including 20-beta-ecdysterone, makisterone C, 24-dehydromakisterone A, carthamosterone, polypodyne B and ajugasterone C. Researchers extracted and purified various ecdysteroids from Rhaponticum and found that the ecdysteroids increased the muscle mass in a dose-dependent manner, with the rate of increase proportional to the ecdysteroids content. Ecdysteroids normalize NADH dehydrogenase activity, enzyme which catalyses NADH electron transfer to the ubiquinone in the oxidative phosphorylation processes at the mitochondrial level, contributing to buildup the electrochemical potential used to produce ATP. It also normalizes the succinate dehydrogenase activity, enzyme which acts in the tricarboxilic acid cycle, which translates in ATP synthesis and patient energy level increases [Tashmukhamedova M A, Almatov K T, Syrov V N. Comparative study of the effect of ecdysterone, turkesterone and nerobol on the function of rat liver mitochondria in experimental diabetes. Vopr Med Khim. 1986; 32:24-8]. Incorporation of this phytomedicine provides at least 10 active principles in a single therapeutic.



There were some other papers relating to cancer cell aptosis and ecdysterone, but I didn't have access to the full text and ecdysterone's role wasn't covered in the abstract.
 

sizematters10

Guest
cool cool sap, thanks for producing those abstracts, interesting stuff.
 
sapentia

sapentia

Member
Awards
0
So here is the only negative study I could find regarding ecdysterone and cancer; it regards the proliferation of breast cancer cells which have the estrogen receptor alpha. Note: T47D = Human ductal breast epithelial tumor cell line - Whole Cell Lysate


Influence of isopsoralen and ecdysterone on T47D cell proliferation and ER subtype expression of human breast cancer

ZHAO Pi-wen,NIU Jian-zhao,WANG Ji-feng,et al.(School of Fundamental Medical Sciences,Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing 100029)

Objective To observe the effects of isopsoralen and ecdysterone on the proliferation of T47D cells and detect their influence on the expressions of T47D subtypes-estrogen receptor α(ERα) and estrogen receptor β(ERβ) cells in human breast cancer.Methods The influence of isopsoralen and ecdysterone(the active principles of Fructus Psoraleae,Radix Cyathulae) on the proliferation of ERα and ERβ cells and on the expression levels of ERα and ERβ mRNA by MTT assay and RT-PCR respectively.The changes of cell proliferation cycle were detected by flow cytometry.Results Isopsoralen and ecdysterone(in dose of 10-6 mol/L and 10-7 mol/L respectively) promoted obviously the proliferation of cultured T47D cells,increased the proliferation indexes with an estrogenic effect.The result of RT-PCR showed that isopsoralen(10-6 mol/L) and ecdysterone(10-7 mol/L) improved the expression of ERα mRNA and isopsoralen improved the expression of ERβ mRNA at the same time.Conclusion Isopsoralen and ecdysterone have the phytoestrogenic effects and can influence the mRNA expression level of ER subtype.

_______________________________________________________________

I'm not rushing to any negative conclusions because of the above study. Other studies have shown that ecdysterone encourages tumor cell aptosis in prostrate cancer.
 
BBB

BBB

Well-known member
Awards
1
  • Established
I've used and researched ecdy for years. I love the concept of a product with an almost unlimited health benefits that can also build muscle. I have even mega dosed on the stuff. The problem is that the oral bioavailability is very poor. I just finished a 4 week run of E-Bol from Thermo life and did not notice any increase in muscle mass or any leaning effect. But It does provide a deep and restful night’s sleep. In fact, if I dose too high prior to bedtime I'm groggy the next morning. From what I can discern the Russians injected the stuff. I have even read excerpts where modern day bodybuilders have injected ecdy with great results. It obviously has to be modified in order to be injected.
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
Thanks for posting sapentia.:yup: That definitley makes me feel a little better. Maybe Vaughn will also get around to responding one day.:11:
 
sapentia

sapentia

Member
Awards
0
I've used and researched ecdy for years. I love the concept of a product with an almost unlimited health benefits that can also build muscle. I have even mega dosed on the stuff. The problem is that the oral bioavailability is very poor. I just finished a 4 week run of E-Bol from Thermo life and did not notice any increase in muscle mass or any leaning effect. But It does provide a deep and restful night’s sleep. In fact, if I dose too high prior to bedtime I'm groggy the next morning. From what I can discern the Russians injected the stuff. I have even read excerpts where modern day bodybuilders have injected ecdy with great results. It obviously has to be modified in order to be injected.
I've just started running the new I-Force ECDY. This is my first time on an ecdysterone product so I am watching carefully as apparently there are responders and non-responders. Perhaps those who respond are somehow better able to get the ecdy into their bloodstream either through less efficient liver mechanisms or perhaps something found in the digestion/uptake chain. I am really hoping that I am a responder as this product sounds too good to be true.
 

jayice

Member
Awards
0
just wondering why dont people just drink grapefruit juice to help with the digestion and biovaliablity of Ecdy?
 
VaughnTrue

VaughnTrue

Well-known member
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
I haven't responded because there isn't much to respond to. Any compound in its pure form will have an MSDS which claims it can be harmful if inhaled or touched with skin. This is true for caffeine...vitamin c...everything. Ecdy can not and will not cause cancer.
 
StackedCop

StackedCop

Well-known member
Awards
2
  • RockStar
  • Established
I haven't responded because there isn't much to respond to. Any compound in its pure form will have an MSDS which claims it can be harmful if inhaled or touched with skin. This is true for caffeine...vitamin c...everything. Ecdy can not and will not cause cancer.
Thank u
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
I haven't responded because there isn't much to respond to. Any compound in its pure form will have an MSDS which claims it can be harmful if inhaled or touched with skin. This is true for caffeine...vitamin c...everything. Ecdy can not and will not cause cancer.
Oh i see.:yup: That's fine that you aren't interested lol. Well I looked this up for ceffeine and vitamin c, and under "personal protection" it does not say don't inhale or let them touch the skin. That is unique to ecdysterone. Anyways, just posting this up for people that care. I'm not saying anyone should be worried..just relaying what I had read. I'm not all that concerned myself after researching the topic more.
 
VaughnTrue

VaughnTrue

Well-known member
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
you apparently did not look at a caffeine MSDS as I told you to...

http://www.jtbaker.com/msds/englishhtml/c0165.htm

Emergency Overview
--------------------------
WARNING! HARMFUL IF SWALLOWED OR INHALED. CAUSES IRRITATION TO SKIN, EYES AND RESPIRATORY TRACT. POSSIBLE BIRTH DEFECT HAZARD. MAY CAUSE BIRTH DEFECTS BASED ON ANIMAL DATA.

SAF-T-DATA(tm) Ratings (Provided here for your convenience)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Health Rating: 2 - Moderate (Poison)
Flammability Rating: 1 - Slight
Reactivity Rating: 1 - Slight
Contact Rating: 2 - Moderate
Lab Protective Equip: GOGGLES; LAB COAT; VENT HOOD; PROPER GLOVES
Storage Color Code: Blue (Health)

so to handle caffeine, we need goggles, lab coat, and gloves...omg!
 
VaughnTrue

VaughnTrue

Well-known member
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
It is not that I am not interested...it is that there is nothing for me to add to this. I am correct in saying that just about EVERY pure chemical has a MSDS that claims it can be harmful. Ecdy is not unique in this matter(as can be seen above).
 
BBB

BBB

Well-known member
Awards
1
  • Established
I haven't responded because there isn't much to respond to. Any compound in its pure form will have an MSDS which claims it can be harmful if inhaled or touched with skin. This is true for caffeine...vitamin c...everything. Ecdy can not and will not cause cancer.
Not only will it not cause cancer it has also been reported to protect against many forms of cancer. There may be something to the non-responder issue. A friend of mine, (long time body builder), uses it pre-contest. He claims it helps lean him out.
 

Antabolix

New member
Awards
0
you apparently did not look at a caffeine MSDS as I told you to...






so to handle caffeine, we need goggles, lab coat, and gloves...omg!

Actually I did, and I would gladly post up the links if I had enough posts to do it.:deal: It was obviously something different than you found however. I do appreciate you posting up the link though, because I can see what you mean now. It isnt so concerning when caffeine also includes those warnings. Since the national cancer institute "suspects" it may be a carcinogen, then it would have the potential to cause cancer, if it indeed was a carcinogen. I'd like to know what "suspect" means to them though. Oh well, this makes me feel alot better about taking the Ecdy I got the other day..after 2 days taking it, my muscles DO feel fuller. Still haven't gone to the gym yet, but I'm expecting a great pump.
 
StackedCop

StackedCop

Well-known member
Awards
2
  • RockStar
  • Established
Not only will it not cause cancer it has also been reported to protect against many forms of cancer. There may be something to the non-responder issue. A friend of mine, (long time body builder), uses it pre-contest. He claims it helps lean him out.
Yup I can eat like a pig on Ecdymorph and not gain a gram of fat.
 
kingjameskjf

kingjameskjf

Well-known member
Awards
2
  • RockStar
  • Established
I haven't responded because there isn't much to respond to. Any compound in its pure form will have an MSDS which claims it can be harmful if inhaled or touched with skin. This is true for caffeine...vitamin c...everything. Ecdy can not and will not cause cancer.
Currently being in my fourth college chemistry class, I have come to see that this is absolutely correct. Just about everything seems to be an "irritant" or "harmful if swallowed". Now when it's says toxic or corrosive, then I take further precautions! No need to hype up anything without any substantiated proof. Of course we are all concerned with our health, that's what we do and why we're on the boards, to maximize our results in the gym, increase our physical health, and to learn.

We must also understand that ecdy was been around for years and people have been using various forms of it. Hell, we see studies on those that bypassed their hepatic system which acts to detoxify things we ingest and put it straight into their muscle cells (fibers) via IM injection. Basically what I'm saying is that we need to look at the whole picture, not just small selections of it. We try to put out the highest quality products that we can and don't sacrifice health for a quick sale.

you apparently did not look at a caffeine MSDS as I told you to...

http://www.jtbaker.com/msds/englishhtml/c0165.htm
I've actually used this same site as a reference several times. Helpful resource.
 

SynergyIre

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
Actually I did, and I would gladly post up the links if I had enough posts to do it.:deal: It was obviously something different than you found however. I do appreciate you posting up the link though, because I can see what you mean now. It isnt so concerning when caffeine also includes those warnings. Since the national cancer institute "suspects" it may be a carcinogen, then it would have the potential to cause cancer, if it indeed was a carcinogen. I'd like to know what "suspect" means to them though. Oh well, this makes me feel alot better about taking the Ecdy I got the other day..after 2 days taking it, my muscles DO feel fuller. Still haven't gone to the gym yet, but I'm expecting a great pump.
Suspect usually means it's non conclusive, so it's not scientifically proven. So lets just say there was a study that showed that eating large amounts of spinach have a effect on cancer cells.

Because there is EDCY in spinach you could SUSPECT that could be the cause, based on knowledge about the other components of spinach, but that would be reason to conduct a specific test to find evidence.

Since SOO many things can be potentially linked to cancer, almost regardless of how big a test group is, other effects can possible skew result, so a very focused study is required to produce any useful information.
 

anabolicRyan1

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
Interesting discussion. Anybody have any good logs with the stuff yet?

Wondering about the iforce dosage vs other companies. Iforce is way more potent. But damn I think I've seen 300mg pills from other companies.

Any comments?
 

Similar threads


Top