Hey Bro, welcome to my little slice of the world!!! I wouldn't suggest taking her to any place in the Times Square area. It's all very "touristy" and not a good representation of NYC, at all IMO. I would suggest that you pick up a copy of the magazine "Time Out NY" and make your decisions based off of that. But yeah, Times Square blows. You'll find better places in different parts of Manhattan. Good luck and feel free to PM me is you have any questions.