Poll: How long a break before losing significant muscle/strength?

How long a break before losing significant muscle/strength?

Page 1 of 2 12 Last
  1. How long a break before losing significant muscle/strength?


    Traveling for the holidays disrupted my normal gym schedule, and it got me curious... How long can you take completely off from lifting before you start to lose significant muscle and/or strength? (Assume continuation of high-protein diet with at least maintenance kCals.)


  2. I think after two weeks of inactivity i personally can tell if ive been slacking. If im doing other physical activities i dont really notice. Im going on three currently but do meanial little tasks to keep me fresh.
    •   
       


  3. Many studies I have read have alluded to a 14 day period before muscle atrophy ensues; however, these studies were not done on resistant trained individuals. I think it also depends on the rate of one's metabolism as a unit. For myself, I have seen very significant muscle loss after 21 days. During a shoulder injury period of three months I lost a total of about 21 pounds, continuing even with maintenance calories. However, my metabolism is extremely fast.

  4. Around 2 weeks I will notice a temporary loss in strength, and muscles start to feel flat/lose hardness.

  5. I took 3 weeks off for xmas break, and lost 4lbs and 1/3" off my arms. During this break I caught a flu though.
    •   
       


  6. You have to understand that everybody is different. But, for me I can notice a difference after a week of not lifting. I never like to go any longer than that.

  7. I've gone a week without noticeable loss. Everytime I take 2 weeks off I notice considerable drop offs in strength and endurance, not to mention mental focus.
    Give a man a fish, feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish, feed him for life. Lao Tse 6th century BC

  8. I got busy and or lazy.. ( Work related ) and I took off for about 6 weeks.. I lost 2 inches on my chest.. 1/4" on my biceps, and I was very weak when I went back.. I have only been back for a week now, and it is murder..

  9. A professional bodybuilder and nutritionist once told me that it takes about 8 weeks of inactivity for a muscle to truly atrophy. I know I start to feel ****ty after about 5 days of not hitting the gym...but after a good workout everything comes back almost immediately.

  10. I always take a full week off every 2 months. The week I get back I'm weaker but the week after that I'm usually a little stronger then before I left. I did take my week off once just to get sick the following week. I noticed then a big drop off in strength.

  11. I think we all start to notice it within a couple weeks, but I don't think you will get a significant drop until about four weeks or more.

    Of course that will spped up if you're not eating also.

    When my second marriage broke up, it was pretty devastating for me. A long story too. Regardless, I didn't workout or eat anything (less than 500 cals per day) due to the depression for a good six weeks. I lost over 25 freaking pounds in that time. I went from 235 lbs to under 210. That was bad! There are some truelly evil women out there.

    On a good note, four years later, I now look better than I ever have and she's gained at least 80 pounds! Gotta love karma!

  12. Quote Originally Posted by CRUNCH View Post
    I think we all start to notice it within a couple weeks, but I don't think you will get a significant drop until about four weeks or more.

    Of course that will spped up if you're not eating also.

    When my second marriage broke up, it was pretty devastating for me. A long story too. Regardless, I didn't workout or eat anything (less than 500 cals per day) due to the depression for a good six weeks. I lost over 25 freaking pounds in that time. I went from 235 lbs to under 210. That was bad! There are some truelly evil women out there.

    On a good note, four years later, I now look better than I ever have and she's gained at least 80 pounds! Gotta love karma!
    80 lbs??? DAYUMMM! thats a HUGE *****! haha.

  13. Quote Originally Posted by getjacked63 View Post
    80 lbs??? DAYUMMM! thats a HUGE *****! haha.
    Oh yeah! She was a very hot 5'7" at 120 lbs, she's now over 2 bills!! I love it!

  14. $hit, i feel like a bad person when i take more than 3 DAYS off. i think it gets in your head if you take too much time off. you lose that feeling of knowing you can put up heavy weight. it then turns into a " i hope i can still lift that".

  15. A highly conditioned/ trained person can begin losing muscle very fast and the rule of thumb is about 3-4% per day. It depends on the quality of muscle you have and it varys from person to person on how fast it happens.

  16. Quote Originally Posted by CRUNCH View Post
    I think we all start to notice it within a couple weeks, but I don't think you will get a significant drop until about four weeks or more.

    Of course that will spped up if you're not eating also.

    When my second marriage broke up, it was pretty devastating for me. A long story too. Regardless, I didn't workout or eat anything (less than 500 cals per day) due to the depression for a good six weeks. I lost over 25 freaking pounds in that time. I went from 235 lbs to under 210. That was bad! There are some truelly evil women out there.

    On a good note, four years later, I now look better than I ever have and she's gained at least 80 pounds! Gotta love karma!

    hey i have a similair story. I wont go into details but now shes gained alot of weight. I was depressed and hardly ate, let me tell you! I had the craziest abs ive ever seen on me. Not to mention cuts galore but, it did a toll on my strength for sure.

    Anyway, Im going on a 1 week vacation and Ill probably just do pushups in the morning or something to keep in a little shape.....this thread helps ease my mind.

  17. Quote Originally Posted by Motox View Post
    A highly conditioned/ trained person can begin losing muscle very fast and the rule of thumb is about 3-4% per day. It depends on the quality of muscle you have and it varys from person to person on how fast it happens.
    3-4%/day seems pretty extreme, no? That means you go on a 2-week vacation and you've lost 42-56% of your muscle! I don't think so.

  18. Quote Originally Posted by pistonpump View Post
    hey i have a similair story. I wont go into details but now shes gained alot of weight. I was depressed and hardly ate, let me tell you! I had the craziest abs ive ever seen on me. Not to mention cuts galore but, it did a toll on my strength for sure.

    Anyway, Im going on a 1 week vacation and Ill probably just do pushups in the morning or something to keep in a little shape.....this thread helps ease my mind.
    I just found out from some friends that she just got her 3rd or 4th DWI too. Her license is now gone for a year! I mentioned something about karma didn't I?? LOL.

    I don't even remember if I had abs after that weight loss bout, the whole thing is still kind of a fog to this day.

  19. Quote Originally Posted by TeamSavage View Post
    3-4%/day seems pretty extreme, no? That means you go on a 2-week vacation and you've lost 42-56% of your muscle! I don't think so.
    Well, actually accute muscle atrophy occurs within 48-72 hours due to muscle inactivity. Depending on many factors, one dictates the speed of muscle lose. Remember, the body is always in a constant state of change, which allows homeostasis to control us. Otherwords...we lose and gain protein-based tissue daily. factors such as eating, reducing stress, ect...help keep muscle, but as stated above...the 'turn-over-rate" depends upon the person's daily choices.

    Simple study on Anabolic/Catabolic Ratio explains the answer genetleman.

    Losing 42% is highly unlikely. Because of the stamenet mentioned above.

  20. Quote Originally Posted by nutratroy View Post
    Well, actually accute muscle atrophy occurs within 48-72 hours due to muscle inactivity. Depending on many factors, one dictates the speed of muscle lose. Remember, the body is always in a constant state of change, which allows homeostasis to control us. Otherwords...we lose and gain protein-based tissue daily. factors such as eating, reducing stress, ect...help keep muscle, but as stated above...the 'turn-over-rate" depends upon the person's daily choices.

    Simple study on Anabolic/Catabolic Ratio explains the answer genetleman.

    Losing 42% is highly unlikely. Because of the stamenet mentioned above.
    Yeah, but we're not talking about the rate of turnover. We're talking about losing muscle & strength during sustained periods of not working out. If you have catabolism of 4% but anabolism of 3.5% then you're not really "losing" 4% or anything close.

  21. TS: I should have been clearer…I side with you on the percentages as if you re-read my post.

    But unless I am mistaking, we all here eat and sleep, train daily. So our environment is in favor for positive state of change. Since we actually favor anabolism by a few percent, thus will result in new muscle.

    But when we stop (for long periods or short) our “perceived normal” state of being or balance of homeostasis will come into effect. Thus means the ratio at which we react to losing muscle will dictate PTOR (rate at which protein based tissue (muscle) is gained or lost, due to anabolic/catabolic ratio. Muscle atrophy does occur in about 72 hours of no stimulation.

    But as I stated, many factors also influence how fast we can lose hard earned muscle. If one just stopped inducing positives gains and suddenly took in phytoestrogens, soy, and a hell of a lot of stress…25 pound lose quickly could feasibly happen. Or better yet, cancer! (Which I know all to well)…but my simple reply to the orginal question is one starts losing serious muscle in 4 days. I say serious because it is so hard to gain it, why not to try to keep it.
    But a good vaca is needed every now and then too...

  22. Quote Originally Posted by CRUNCH View Post
    I think we all start to notice it within a couple weeks, but I don't think you will get a significant drop until about four weeks or more.

    Of course that will spped up if you're not eating also.
    If I start eating less or just junk then strength drops very quickly...If I eat well and take a week off I always come back stronger.

    I think diet is really more important unless you are off for a 3+ weeks.

  23. Diet does not have much to do with it at all, the reason you come back stronger is prolly because your muscles get completly replenished. The thing is what you do while your taking time off if you are bedridden and sendentary it happens very fast and drastic. If you are more active then you will keep more. Why would your body want to keep extra muscle it just takes up space and is basically extra mouths to feed for your body.

  24. well its been almost 5 days, jet lag, new home, finally being a daddy (stress haha), not my normal diet and walking my only excercise, i already feel small and weak. Just woke up and did some push ups, DAMN! I can feel the difference and i still have about another 5 days of this! i think diet is a BIG factor honestly. I have not protien shakes here and im just taking a multi. ....Very curious to see what performance will be like in the gym when i get back home.

  25. Quote Originally Posted by Motox View Post
    Diet does not have much to do with it at all, the reason you come back stronger is prolly because your muscles get completly replenished. The thing is what you do while your taking time off if you are bedridden and sendentary it happens very fast and drastic. If you are more active then you will keep more. Why would your body want to keep extra muscle it just takes up space and is basically extra mouths to feed for your body.
    Diet doesn't have much to do with it????? If you're eating dughnuts and Mtn Dew all day vs. your normal high protein/good carb meals, there be a very drastic difference in how fast your body loses muscle and strengh! Weather it's a week or a month.

  26. No why would it make a difference? That would dictate how fat you get. If you are not using your muscles then why would your body feed them more energy? Our bodies are efficient like that. Its not like when you eat protein and brocolli it turns into muscle imediatly, if that were so we we just sit on the couch and do eat.

  27. Ooookay.

  28. Quote Originally Posted by Motox View Post
    No why would it make a difference? That would dictate how fat you get. If you are not using your muscles then why would your body feed them more energy? Our bodies are efficient like that. Its not like when you eat protein and brocolli it turns into muscle imediatly, if that were so we we just sit on the couch and do eat.
    It makes a difference because if you eat above maintenence kCals and eat enough protein to maintain a positive nitrogen balance, your muscles will be largely spared. If you eat sub-maintenance kCals muscle will be catabolized MUCH faster, especially if you aren't eating enough protein and have a neg nitrogen balance.

    Diet has everything to do with how fast you lose muscle.

  29. Quote Originally Posted by TeamSavage View Post
    It makes a difference because if you eat above maintenence kCals and eat enough protein to maintain a positive nitrogen balance, your muscles will be largely spared. If you eat sub-maintenance kCals muscle will be catabolized MUCH faster, especially if you aren't eating enough protein and have a neg nitrogen balance.

    Diet has everything to do with how fast you lose muscle.
    Exactly!

  30. Quote Originally Posted by TeamSavage View Post
    It makes a difference because if you eat above maintenence kCals and eat enough protein to maintain a positive nitrogen balance, your muscles will be largely spared. If you eat sub-maintenance kCals muscle will be catabolized MUCH faster, especally if you aren't eating enough protein and have a neg nitrogen balance.

    Diet has everything to do with how fast you lose muscle.
    im doing that right now and i think if i did stick to regular workout/bb'er diet id be holding alot if not all muscle. Since im eating higher than normal fat and sub maintenance kCals im seeing significant muscle and strength loss. So I mean im living it right now and Diet is more important than actually working out in terms of holding muscle Imo. Which leads me to believe that in the whole scheme of things....diet is more important in bodybuilding than actual routine. But then again even the pros are still not sure about that.
  •   

      
     

Similar Forum Threads

  1. gaba - how long a cycle before benefits decline?
    By dubplate6 in forum Supplements
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 04-06-2010, 02:42 PM
  2. how long to wait before starting stack
    By mike g in forum LG Sciences
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 09-23-2009, 01:06 AM
  3. Replies: 5
    Last Post: 08-10-2008, 08:19 AM
  4. How long to wait before starting RPM/Drive?
    By Gladius in forum Supplements
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 05-04-2008, 03:07 PM
  5. how long to wait before cutting after bulk cycle?
    By DieTrying in forum Anabolics
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 08-20-2003, 10:41 PM
Log in
Log in