Working out when sick: Good or Bad?

  1. Working out when sick: Good or Bad?


    Whenever I am hungover or sick, I always look to working out as my cure- for it rejuvinates me mentally and physically. The bloodpump, the rush, and the physically acitivity always make me feel great.

    But, being currently sick from spring break, is working out bad for me? I ask this because I know working out and lifting depletes the body of its nutrients and energy, which sounds especially bad when one's ammune system is down.

    Any ideas or comments on this would be great, thanks.


  2. Quote Originally Posted by [fiorentino]
    Whenever I am hungover or sick, I always look to working out as my cure- for it rejuvinates me mentally and physically. The bloodpump, the rush, and the physically acitivity always make me feel great.

    But, being currently sick from spring break, is working out bad for me? I ask this because I know working out and lifting depletes the body of its nutrients and energy, which sounds especially bad when one's ammune system is down.

    Any ideas or comments on this would be great, thanks.
    I am getting over a cold and I am still have the cough since the start of the full blown symptoms which was March 7th. I went back to the gym too early even though I knew it was a mistake. I'm just stubborn though. I finally went to the doctor and got treated. Anyway heres a link that explains things. You SHOULD NOT workout while you are sick!

    http://www.grow-muscle-now.com/newsline05.html

  3. Yeah not only is working out while you're sick a bad thing, but you have to think of others as well. If some jerkoff is sick and spreading germs all over the gym equipment guess who he just infected...
    •   
       


  4. maybe its not the smartest thing to work out when you are sick, but it seems to make me feel better when i am done

  5. What if you have a 24hr stomach flu? Should you train the next day or wait a week?

    Assuming diet is correct, how long can you go w/out working out before you'll start to lose gains?

  6. Quote Originally Posted by Moyer
    What if you have a 24hr stomach flu? Should you train the next day or wait a week?

    Assuming diet is correct, how long can you go w/out working out before you'll start to lose gains?
    I would definately take a few days off to recover completely. Don't worry about losing gains, you have your whole life to catch up. Besides, a couple of days off will be good for you.

  7. I always go with the saying. Above the neck good to go, anything below is a no no. Like if I have head cold, hungover, or something like that I will workout. If its a horrible cough, sinus infection, or stomach bug, I will take a couple days off.

  8. i think bohica's advice is excellent. (it's what i was going to say)

    seriously, though...

    working out does not mean "working out at 100%"

    i would NOT go for PR's when one is sick

    i would not work out at either 100% intensity or 100% volume when one is sick

    but a workout at about 50-70% of normal can actually be BENEFICIAL for the sick person. raising internal temperature can HELP. that's part of the reason WHY people get feverish in the first place

    if one has a HIT mentality, that one has to work to failure and improve every workout - don't do that when sick

    getting the joints moving, doing some reasonable strength work, etc. otoh can be beneficial, mentally and physically

  9. Quote Originally Posted by jjjd
    i think bohica's advice is excellent. (it's what i was going to say)

    seriously, though...

    working out does not mean "working out at 100%"

    i would NOT go for PR's when one is sick

    i would not work out at either 100% intensity or 100% volume when one is sick

    but a workout at about 50-70% of normal can actually be BENEFICIAL for the sick person. raising internal temperature can HELP. that's part of the reason WHY people get feverish in the first place

    if one has a HIT mentality, that one has to work to failure and improve every workout - don't do that when sick

    getting the joints moving, doing some reasonable strength work, etc. otoh can be beneficial, mentally and physically
    That's fine and dandy, but I'm gonna be pissed if some jerk is infecting me with his germs because he couldn't stay out of the gym an extra day.
  10. ItriedtoripoffBobosonowIamgonehaveaniceday
    ItriedtoripoffBobosonowIamgonehaveaniceday's Avatar

    Take the few days off....I am sick now but I won't go knowing my workout will feel like **** when I feel like **** getting out of bed! Remember you are in this for the long haul and the health, the great body is just a great extra! Plus I hate when dickheads are in the gym coughing up a storm on equipment I am just about to use!

  11. Quote Originally Posted by MaNiaK1027
    Take the few days off....I am sick now but I won't go knowing my workout will feel like **** when I feel like **** getting out of bed! Remember you are in this for the long haul and the health, the great body is just a great extra! Plus I hate when dickheads are in the gym coughing up a storm on equipment I am just about to use!
    I hear ya.

  12. of course, being sick =/= being sick and contagious/hacking, etc.

    i readily agree that in the latter case, if one is in THAT state, one should not workout (in a public gym at least)

    people who do so are inconsiderate imo

  13. Quote Originally Posted by jjjd
    of course, being sick =/= being sick and contagious/hacking, etc.

    i readily agree that in the latter case, if one is in THAT state, one should not workout (in a public gym at least)

    people who do so are inconsiderate imo
    I'd agree..whether a light work out may benefit one when sick or not, going to a public gym is inconsiderate.

    personally, I'll probably stick to my old pititful personal dumbbell set while Im feeling under the weather.

    But on the main idea --"whether a light workout when sick is good for you or not", I'm still undecided

  14. Heres a good article advising against any workouts due to the stress on the immune system, from webmd.com

    Click here

    or
    http://my.webmd.com/content/article/12/1685_52519.htm

  15. Quote Originally Posted by natedogg
    Yeah not only is working out while you're sick a bad thing, but you have to think of others as well. If some jerkoff is sick and spreading germs all over the gym equipment guess who he just infected...
    Damn f'n straight.

    And let me just say bro, nice avatar.

  16. Quote Originally Posted by BOHICA
    I always go with the saying. Above the neck good to go, anything below is a no no. Like if I have head cold, hungover, or something like that I will workout. If its a horrible cough, sinus infection, or stomach bug, I will take a couple days off.
    but being hungover is due to dehydration is it really smart to further dehydrate yourself in the gym? when im hungover i never go to the gym. i understand that when at the gym your constantly intaking fluids but your also burning off fluids that were never there to begin with.

  17. Quote Originally Posted by iwinulose2981
    but being hungover is due to dehydration is it really smart to further dehydrate yourself in the gym? when im hungover i never go to the gym. i understand that when at the gym your constantly intaking fluids but your also burning off fluids that were never there to begin with.
    But it also gets my body back to feeling better. I don't go in and give it a full bore workout, but just something to sweat out the toxins in my body from the alcohol. It also lets me that day since I normally have no appetite while being hungover.
  

  
 

Similar Forum Threads

  1. Replies: 9
    Last Post: 07-21-2004, 08:44 PM
  2. BigCasino's Workout - Good or Bad for size?
    By BigCasino in forum Exercise Science
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 05-25-2004, 08:08 PM
  3. good or bad diet for m1t cycle?
    By DumbRussian in forum Weight Loss
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 12-18-2003, 02:07 PM
  4. UCP1 pre-contest. Good or bad idea?
    By FullyBuilt in forum Supplements
    Replies: 16
    Last Post: 07-09-2003, 09:06 AM
  5. Cortisol: Good or Bad?
    By YellowJacket in forum Exercise Science
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 03-02-2003, 08:11 PM
Log in
Log in