I suppose so, but my point was just that it's not just because people think Bonds is an A**h*le that people want him hung drawn and quartered. To some people, having a tactical advantage that someone else chooses not to, or is'nt supposed to have is as bad as molesting children. And IMO, that's overblowing the situation. Ty Cobb used to play dirty all the time and he's still in the hall of fame, and he didnt have an * next to any of his batting records. Dozens of guys have pitched spitballs or used corked bats, and their statistics were left alone. Ricky Henderson is rumored to have been a meth head when he set some of his stolen base records. Maris hadnt reached 60hr's by the time 154 games had passed. (I know they said his record would have a * next to it, but I've heard that that never actually happened and his 61hr's in 1961 were written as is in the official record books, w no *) At worst, if someone is caught juicing, they should be suspended for a while. That would make sure their not going to put up earth shattering #'s anyway, cuz they'd only be playing 2 thirds of a season. (if they actually get caught that is.)
But if you start messing with statistics, wich are merely a recording of what ACTUALLY happened, youd be neglecting the stats of anyone who did it but didnt get caught. In this case youd be basing it on guilt by overwhelming suspicion. Stats record WHAT happened, not what COULD have or SHOULD have or WOULD have happened. If you start thinking that way then you could just start saying, oh well so in so would have pitched a great game if he didnt catch that stomach virus before the game. Or so in so would have hit more homeruns if he hadnt been sidelined for that hamstring pull. Or so in so would have been to tired to go 4 for 4 in that game if they hadnt let him drink 4 cups of esspreso before and during the game.
Eradicating the stats just doesnt seem reasonable to me weather the player was a jerk, an real american hero, or in between. And if we're going to use an * based on suspicion, we might as well put an * by the last 16 seasons of everybody, cuz we'll never know who used what in that time.